脑灌注SPECT在癫痫术前评估中:发作间期SPECT高置信度定侧时是否仍需发作期SPECT,反之亦然?
该回顾性研究纳入177例癫痫患者,比较发作间期、发作期及联合判读SPECT对致痫区定侧的高置信度比例与错误定侧率。发作间期高置信度定侧仅4.5%且错误定侧率达12.5%,发作期高置信度定侧为31.6%且96.4%与联合判读一致。作者认为以发作间期SPECT高置信度结果跳过发作期SPECT不可行,而以发作期高置信度结果跳过发作间期SPECT可推荐。
要点
- 发作间期SPECT高置信度定侧比例仅4.5%,其中12.5%定侧错误。
- 发作期SPECT高置信度定侧比例31.6%,96.4%与联合判读同侧。
- 作者推荐以发作期高置信度定侧跳过发作间期SPECT。
核心结论
- 以发作间期SPECT高置信度致痫区候选跳过发作期SPECT不是有用方法。
- 以发作期SPECT高置信度致痫区候选跳过发作间期SPECT可推荐。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性纳入177例患者,48%为女性,中位年龄38岁,四分位距27-48岁。
- 发作期与发作间期SPECT分别使用99mTc-HMPAO(n=141)或99mTc-ECD(n=36)采集。
- 绝大多数患者疑似颞叶癫痫。
- 3名阅片者独立在发作间期仅、发作期仅和联合三种设置下视觉判读SPECT。
- 以联合设置下的致痫区定侧为参考标准。
主要发现
- 高置信度定侧比例在发作间期仅、发作期仅和联合设置下分别为4.5%、31.6%和38.4%。
- 发作间期仅设置下8例高置信度定侧中1例(12.5%)定侧至错误半球。
- 发作期仅设置下56例高置信度定侧中54例(96.4%)在联合设置下也定侧且均同侧。
关键数值与推荐
- 高置信度定侧定义为所有阅片者定侧至同一半球且置信度评分至少4分(满分5分)。
- 发作间期仅设置高置信度定侧比例4.5%,发作期仅31.6%,联合38.4%。
- 发作间期仅设置高置信度定侧错误率12.5%(8例中1例)。
- 发作期仅设置高置信度定侧与联合设置同侧一致率96.4%(56例中54例)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为以发作间期SPECT高置信度定侧跳过发作期SPECT不是有用方法。
- 作者推荐以发作期SPECT高置信度定侧跳过发作间期SPECT。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Ictal brain perfusion SPECT provides higher sensitivity for the identification of the epileptic seizure onset zone (SOZ) than interictal SPECT. However, ictal SPECT is demanding due to the unpredictable waiting period for the next seizure to allow for ictal tracer injection. Thus, starting with an interictal scan and skipping the ictal scan if the interictal scan provides a SOZ candidate with high confidence could be an efficient approach. The current study estimated the rate of high-confidence SOZ candidates and the false lateralization rate among them for interictal and ictal SPECT. METHODS: 177 patients (48% females, median age 38y, interquartile range 27-48y) with ictal and interictal SPECT acquired with 99mTc-HMPAO (n = 141) or -ECD (n = 36) were included retrospectively. The vast majority of the patients was suspected to have temporal lobe epilepsy. Visual interpretation of the SPECT data was performed independently by 3 readers in 3 settings: "interictal only" (interictal SPECT and statistical hypoperfusion map), "ictal only" (ictal SPECT and hyperperfusion map), and "full" setting (side-by-side interpretation of ictal and interictal SPECT including statistical maps and SISCOM analysis). The readers lateralized the SOZ (right, left, none) and characterized their confidence using a 5-score. A case was considered "lateralizing with high confidence" if all readers lateralized to the same hemisphere with at least 4 of 5 confidence points. Lateralization of the SOZ in the "full" setting was used as reference standard. RESULTS: The proportion of "lateralizing with high confidence" cases was 4.5/31.6/38.4% in the "interictal only"/"ictal only"/"full" setting. One (12.5%) of the 8 cases that were "lateralizing with high confidence" in the "interictal only" setting lateralized to the wrong hemisphere. Among the 56 cases that were "lateralizing with high confidence" in the "ictal only" setting, 54 (96.4%) were also lateralizing in the "full" setting, all to the same hemisphere. CONCLUSIONS: Starting brain perfusion SPECT in the presurgical evaluation of epilepsy with an interictal scan to skip the ictal scan in case of a high-confidence interictal SOZ candidate is not a useful approach. In contrast, starting with an ictal scan to skip the interictal scan in case of a high-confidence ictal SOZ candidate can be recommended.
引用
- Baradaran-Salimi K, Karimzadeh A, Voges B, et al. Brain perfusion SPECT in the presurgical evaluation of epilepsy: is additional ictal SPECT required in case of high-confidence lateralization of the seizure onset zone by interictal SPECT and vice versa? EJNMMI Res. 2024. PMID: 39264384. doi:10.1186/s13550-024-01149-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。