多中心研究:玻璃与树脂微球装置中厂商声明与PET实测90Y活度的差异
这项4中心、5台PET设备研究比较了56个玻璃微球瓶和18个树脂微球瓶中厂商校准的90Y活度与定量90Y PET/CT实测活度。玻璃微球APET/AM均值为0.79±0.04,树脂微球为1.15±0.06,两者校准平均差异46%;90Y氯化物瓶比值为1.00±0.04。作者预计该差异将推动进一步研究以建立可靠准确的患者剂量学与剂量效应评估。
要点
- 玻璃微球瓶PET实测90Y活度平均为厂商声明值的0.79±0.04。
- 树脂微球瓶PET实测90Y活度平均为厂商声明值的1.15±0.06。
- 玻璃与树脂微球活度校准平均相差46%,氯化物溶液则高度一致。
核心结论
- 玻璃与树脂微球装置的活度校准平均相差46%,而90Y氯化物溶液实测与厂商声明值高度一致。
- 作者预计所报告的差异将推动进一步研究以建立可靠准确的患者剂量学与剂量效应评估。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为4中心、5台PET设备的多中心研究,比较微球瓶中厂商校准的90Y活度与定量90Y PET/CT实测活度。
- 共分析56个90Y标记玻璃微球瓶、18个90Y标记树脂微球瓶和4个90Y氯化物瓶。
主要发现
- 玻璃微球瓶APET/AM均值为0.79±0.04(范围0.71-0.89)。
- 树脂微球瓶APET/AM均值为1.15±0.06(范围1.05-1.25)。
- 90Y氯化物瓶APET/AM均值为1.00±0.04(范围0.96-1.06)。
- 玻璃与树脂微球活度校准平均差异为46%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Dosimetry-guided treatment planning in selective internal radiation therapy relies on accurate and reproducible measurement of administered activity. This 4-center, 5-PET-device study compared the manufacturer-declared 90Y activity in vials with quantitative 90Y PET/CT assessment of the same vials. We compared 90Y PET-measured activity (APET) for 56 90Y-labeled glass and 18 90Y-labeled resin microsphere vials with the calibrated activity specified by the manufacturer (AM). Additionally, the same analysis was performed for 4 90Y-chloride vials. The mean APET/AM ratio was 0.79 ± 0.04 (range, 0.71-0.89) for glass microspheres and 1.15 ± 0.06 (range, 1.05-1.25) for resin microspheres. The mean APET/AM ratio for 90Y-chloride vials was 1.00 ± 0.04 (range, 0.96-1.06). Thus, we found an average difference of 46% between glass and resin microsphere activity calibrations, whereas close agreement was found for chloride solutions. We expect that the reported discrepancies will promote further investigations to establish reliable and accurate patient dosimetry and dose-effect assessments.
引用
- Gnesin S, Mikell JK, Conti M, et al. A Multicenter Study on Observed Discrepancies Between Vendor-Stated and PET-Measured 90Y Activities for Both Glass and Resin Microsphere Devices. J Nucl Med. 2022. PMID: 36418169. doi:10.2967/jnumed.122.264458
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。