PET心电图门控在PET/MR影像心脏功能评估交叉验证研究中的价值
本研究在30例接受PET/MR检查的患者中,比较三种PET心电图门控方法(每搏固定门控数STD、带搏动接受窗的STD-BR、固定门控时长FW)与MRI评估左室EDV、ESV和EF的相关性与一致性。结果显示各方法MR-PET相关性均高,但一致性界限宽,STD偏差最大;作者认为需严格质控R峰检测。
要点
- 三种PET心电图门控法与MRI的EDV、ESV、EF均呈高相关,其中ESV相关性优于EDV和EF。
- 各PET门控法相对MRI的偏差在EDV小于13%、ESV小于5%、EF小于14%,但一致性界限宽。
- STD门控法偏差最大,STD-BR与FW之间无显著差异;作者认为需严格质控R峰检测。
核心结论
- 基于PET与MR的心脏功能参数高度相关,但存在实质性不一致,差异由所选PET心电图门控方法引入。
- 差异最大的是对高度不规则搏动敏感的心电图门控方法,而STD-BR与FW两种方法表现相似。
- 作者认为需对R峰检测进行严格质量控制,以尽量减少其对功能评估的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 在30例接受PET/MR检查的患者中,基于MR和PET勾画左心室舒张末期容积、收缩末期容积和射血分数(EDV、ESV、EF)。
- PET心脏成像采用三种心电图门控方法:每搏固定门控数(STD)、带搏动接受窗的STD(STD-BR)和固定门控时长(FW)。
主要发现
- 所有数值均发现MR-PET高相关。
- ESV相关性优于EDV和EF:Pearson r系数在ESV为[0.92, 0.92, 0.92],在EDV为[0.75, 0.81, 0.80],在EF为[0.79, 0.91, 0.87],按方法[STD, STD-BR, FW]顺序。
- 所有评估的PET方法相对MRI的偏差在EDV小于13%、ESV小于5%、EF小于14%,但一致性界限宽,EDV范围(59-68)%、ESV范围(65-70)%、EF范围(49-71)%。
- STD显示最强的不一致,而STD-BR与FW之间无显著差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: This work investigated the impact of different cardiac gating methods on the assessment of cardiac function by FDG-PET in a cross-validation PET/MR study. METHODS AND RESULTS: MR- and PET-based left ventricular end-diastolic, end-systolic volumes, and ejection fraction (EDV, ESV, and EF) were delineated in 30 patients with a PET/MR examination. Cardiac PET imaging was performed using three ECG gating methods: fixed number of gates per beat (STD), STD with a beat acceptance window (STD-BR), and fixed gate duration (FW). High MR-PET correlations were found in all the values. ESVs correlated better than EDVs and EFs: Pearson's r coefficient [0.92, 0.92, 0.92] in ESV vs [0.75, 0.81, 0.80] in EDV and [0.79, 0.91, 0.87] in EF, for each method [STD, STD-BR, FW]. Biases with respect to MRI for all the evaluated PET methods were less than 13% in EDV, 5% in ESV, and 14% in EF, but with wide limits of agreements, in the range (59-68)% in EDV, (65-70)% in ESV, and (49-71)% in EF. STD showed the strongest disagreement, while there were no marked differences between STD-BR and FW. CONCLUSION: Based on these findings, PET- and MR-based cardiac function parameters were highly correlated but in substantial disagreement with variabilities introduced by the selected PET ECG gating method. The most significant differences were associated with the ECG gating method susceptible to highly irregular beats, while similar performance was observed in the methods using uniform adjustment of gates width per beat with the beat acceptance window, and fixed gate width along all the beats. Thus, strict quality controls of R peak detection are needed to minimize its impact on the function assessment.
引用
- Villagran Asiares A, Vitadello T, Bogdanovic B, et al. Value of PET ECG gating in a cross-validation study of cardiac function assessment by PET/MR imaging. J Nucl Cardiol. 2022. PMID: 36180767. doi:10.1007/s12350-022-03105-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。