WHO II级脑膜瘤全切除后辅助放疗与观察后挽救性放疗的比较:倾向性评分校正分析
该回顾性研究纳入1996-2019年单中心160例WHO II级脑膜瘤全切除患者,比较辅助放疗与观察后必要时挽救性放疗的策略。采用倾向性评分校正和IPTW Cox回归分析,发现观察后挽救性放疗组放疗失败-free生存(RFFS)显著更长(HR 0.21,p<0.01),辅助放疗未显示显著获益。
要点
- 全切除后观察+挽救性放疗策略的RFFS优于辅助放疗(HR 0.21)。
- 辅助放疗后3年、5年PFS/RFFS分别为86.1%和59.2%。
- 观察后挽救性放疗的3年、5年、10年RFFS为97.7%、90.3%、87.9%。
核心结论
- WHO II级脑膜瘤全切除后,辅助放疗相比观察后必要时挽救性放疗未显示显著获益。
- 倾向性评分校正后,观察+挽救性放疗组RFFS显著更长(HR 0.21,p<0.01)。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性非随机研究,单中心1996-2019年WHO II级脑膜瘤全切除患者160例。
- 采用倾向性评分校正和IPTW Cox回归分析比较辅助放疗与观察后挽救性放疗。
主要发现
- 观察组121例中32例(26.4%)复发并接受挽救性放疗。
- 观察组3年、5年、10年PFS分别为75.1%、65.6%、45.5%。
- 挽救性放疗后3年、5年PFS分别为81.7%、61.3%。
- 辅助放疗组39例,3年和5年PFS/RFFS分别为86.1%和59.2%。
- 观察+挽救性放疗组3年、5年、10年RFFS分别为97.7%、90.3%、87.9%。
关键数值与推荐
- PS模型和IPTW模型均显示观察+挽救性放疗组RFFS显著更长(HR 0.21,p<0.01)。
临床怎么用
- 对于WHO II级脑膜瘤全切除后患者,可考虑观察并在复发时行挽救性放疗,而非常规辅助放疗。
- 需结合个体复发风险和放疗副作用综合决策。
局限性
- 回顾性非随机研究设计,存在选择偏倚可能。
- 结果需在考虑研究设计局限性的背景下解读。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: After gross-total resection (GTR) of a newly diagnosed WHO grade II meningioma, the decision to treat with radiation upfront or at initial recurrence remains controversial. A comparison of progression-free survival (PFS) between observation and adjuvant radiation fails to account for the potential success of salvage radiation, and a direct comparison of PFS between adjuvant and salvage radiation is hampered by strong selection bias against salvage radiation cohorts in which only more aggressive, recurrent tumors are included. To account for the limitations of traditional PFS measures, the authors evaluated radiation failure-free survival (RFFS) between two treatment strategies after GTR: adjuvant radiation versus observation with salvage radiation, if necessary. METHODS: The authors performed a retrospective review of patients who underwent GTR of newly diagnosed WHO grade II meningiomas at their institution between 1996 and 2019. They assessed traditional PFS in patients who underwent adjuvant radiation, postoperative observation, and salvage radiation. For RFFS, treatment failure was defined as time from initial surgery to failure of first radiation. To assess the association between treatment strategy and RFFS while accounting for potential confounders, a multivariable Cox regression analysis adjusted for the propensity score (PS) and inverse probability of treatment weighted (IPTW) Cox regression analysis were performed. RESULTS: A total of 160 patients underwent GTR and were included in this study. Of the 121 patients who underwent observation, 32 (26.4%) developed recurrence and required salvage radiation. PFS at 3, 5, and 10 years after observation was 75.1%, 65.6%, and 45.5%, respectively. PFS at 3 and 5 years after salvage radiation was 81.7% and 61.3%, respectively. Of 160 patients, 39 received adjuvant radiation, and 3- and 5-year PFS/RFFS rates were 86.1% and 59.2%, respectively. In patients who underwent observation with salvage radiation, if necessary, the 3-, 5-, and 10-year RFFS rates were 97.7%, 90.3%, and 87.9%, respectively. Both PS and IPTW Cox regression models demonstrated that patients who underwent observation with salvage radiation treatment, if necessary, had significantly longer RFFS (PS model: hazard ratio [HR] 0.21, p < 0.01; IPTW model: HR 0.21, p < 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: In this retrospective, nonrandomized study, adjuvant radiation after GTR of a WHO II meningioma did not add significant benefit over a strategy of observation and salvage radiation at initial recurrence, if necessary, but results must be considered in the context of the limitations of the study design.
引用
- Momin AA, Soni P, Shao J, et al. Adjuvant radiation versus observation with salvage radiation after gross-total resection of WHO grade II meningiomas: a propensity score-adjusted analysis. J Neurosurg. 2021. PMID: 34624866. doi:10.3171/2021.4.JNS21559
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。