眶上与迷你翼点锁孔开颅治疗脑肿瘤:204例临床与解剖对比
该回顾性研究比较了眶上(SO)与迷你翼点(MP)锁孔开颅在204例脑肿瘤手术中的适应证、结局及解剖界限。SO占84.8%,MP占15.2%。SO入路整体可达范围更广,尤其鞍旁上方;两种入路安全且互补,内镜可辅助扩大视野。
要点
- SO入路可达同侧及对侧内侧前颅窝、鞍旁、外侧裂等,范围大于MP。
- SO和MP分别有56.6%和22.6%使用内镜,其中49%和71.4%进一步切除肿瘤。
- 总切除或近全切除率SO 69%、MP 68%,主要并发症率分别为6.4%和3.2%(p=0.49)。
核心结论
- SO与MP锁孔开颅是安全、互补的入路,适用于前中颅窝、外侧裂及鞍旁肿瘤。
- SO入路占85%,整体可达范围大于MP入路。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2007至2020年接受SO或MP开颅的脑肿瘤患者,共204例手术(158例患者)。
主要发现
- SO手术173例(84.8%),MP手术31例(15.2%);71例(34.8%)为再手术。
- SO组56.1%肿瘤位于鞍旁,MP组41.9%;轴位热图显示SO可达对侧内侧前颅窝、前中脑等。
- 内镜使用率SO 56.6%、MP 22.6%;全切或近全切率SO 69%、MP 68%。
- 主要并发症SO 6.4%、MP 3.2%(p=0.49);研究最后两年中位住院时间降至2天。
临床怎么用
- SO入路适用于需广泛显露前颅窝、鞍旁及对侧内侧的肿瘤,MP适用于外侧裂及中颅窝外侧病变。
- 内镜有助于观察开颅远隔或成角区域(如筛板区),可辅助增加切除范围。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The authors' objective was to compare the indications, outcomes, and anatomical limits of supraorbital (SO) and mini-pterional (MP) craniotomies in patients with intra- and extraaxial brain tumors, and to assess approach selection, utility of endoscopy, and surgical field overlap. METHODS: A retrospective analysis was conducted of all brain tumor patients who underwent an SO or MP approach. The analyzed characteristics included pathology, endoscopy use, extent of resection, length of stay (LOS), and complications. On the basis of preoperative MRI data, tumor heatmaps were constructed to compare surgical access provided by both routes, including coronal projection heatmaps for parasellar tumors. RESULTS: From 2007 to 2020, 158 patients underwent 173 (84.8%) SO craniotomies and 30 patients underwent 31 (15.2%) MP craniotomies; 71 (34.8%) procedures were reoperations. Of these 204 operations, 110 (63.6%) SO and 21 (67.7%) MP approaches were for extraaxial tumors (meningiomas in 65% and 76.2%, respectively). Gliomas and metastases together represented 84.1% and 70% of intraaxial tumors accessed with SO and MP approaches, respectively. Overall, 56.1% of tumors accessed with the SO approach and 41.9% of those accessed with the MP approach were in the parasellar region. Axial projection heatmaps showed that SO access extended along the entire ipsilateral and medial contralateral anterior cranial fossa, parasellar region, ipsilateral sylvian fissure, medial middle cranial fossa, and anterior midbrain, whereas MP access was limited to the ipsilateral middle cranial fossa, sylvian fissure, lateral parasellar region, and posterior aspect of anterior cranial fossa. Coronal projection heatmaps showed that parasellar access extended further superiorly with the SO approach compared with that of the MP approach. Endoscopy was utilized in 98 (56.6%) SO craniotomies and 7 (22.6%) MP craniotomies, with further tumor resection in 48 (49%) and 5 (71.4%) cases, respectively. Endoscope-assisted tumor removal was clustered in areas that were generally at farther distances from the craniotomy or in angled locations such as the cribriform plate region where microscopic visualization is limited. Gross-total or near-total resection was achieved in 120/173 (69%) SO approaches and 21/31 (68%) MP approaches. Major complications occurred in 11 (6.4%) SO approaches and 1 (3.2%) MP approach (p = 0.49). The median LOS decreased to 2 days in the last 2 years of the study. CONCLUSIONS: This clinical experience suggests the SO and MP craniotomies are versatile, safe, and complementary approaches for tumors located in the anterior and middle cranial fossae and perisylvian and parasellar regions. The SO route, used in 85% of cases, achieved greater overall reach than the MP route. Both approaches may benefit from expanded visualization with endoscopy.
引用
- Avery MB, Mallari RJ, Barkhoudarian G, et al. Supraorbital and mini-pterional keyhole craniotomies for brain tumors: a clinical and anatomical comparison of indications and outcomes in 204 cases. J Neurosurg. 2021. PMID: 34715664. doi:10.3171/2021.6.JNS21759
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。