文献速递神经创伤神经重症

去骨瓣减压术中真空引流、被动引流与不引流的随机对照试验(VADER 试验)

Vacuum Drains versus Passive Drains versus No Drains in Decompressive Craniectomies-A Randomized Controlled Trial on Subgaleal Drain Complication Rates (VADER Trial).
PubMed 文献 · World Neurosurg · 2021-09-23

VADER 试验为两中心随机对照试验,将 78 例需去骨瓣减压术的患者按 1:1:1 分为真空引流组、被动引流组与不引流组,比较术后帽状腱膜下血肿相关并发症。结果显示三组在帽状腱膜下血肿厚度与体积、需手术清除、新发远隔血肿及去骨瓣减压术后脑积水方面无显著差异,仅 1 例真空引流组患者因帽状腱膜下血肿需手术清除。

要点

  • 三组帽状腱膜下血肿厚度与体积差异无统计学意义(P=0.171 与 P=0.320)。
  • 仅 1 例真空引流组患者需手术清除帽状腱膜下血肿。
  • 创伤性脑损伤亚组中被动引流与不引流的帽状腱膜下血肿量显著高于真空引流,但未转化为不良功能结局或死亡风险。

核心结论

  • 就并发症发生率而言,真空引流、被动引流与不引流均可安全用于去骨瓣减压术。
  • 帽状腱膜下血肿量较高与结局较差无关。
  • 真空引流在功能结局与死亡率方面的优势、不引流是否降低去骨瓣减压术后脑积水率,尚需进一步研究。

研究设计与样本

  • 两中心随机对照试验,78 例需去骨瓣减压术的患者按 1:1:1 随机分为真空引流组、被动引流组与不引流组。
  • 研究并发症包括需手术修正、帽状腱膜下血肿量、新发远隔血肿、去骨瓣减压术后脑积水、功能结局与死亡率。

主要发现

  • 仅 1 例真空引流组患者需手术清除帽状腱膜下血肿。
  • 三种引流方式的帽状腱膜下血肿厚度与体积差异无统计学意义(P=0.171 与 P=0.320)。
  • 新发远隔血肿与去骨瓣减压术后脑积水的发生率差异无统计学意义(P=0.647 与 P=0.083),但不引流组无患者发生去骨瓣减压术后脑积水。
  • 49 例创伤性脑损伤患者的亚组分析中,被动引流组与不引流组的帽状腱膜下血肿量显著高于真空引流组。
  • 上述较高的帽状腱膜下血肿量未成为不良功能结局或死亡的显著危险因素,真空引流可能功能结局与死亡率更优。

关键数值与推荐

  • 帽状腱膜下血肿厚度组间比较 P=0.171,体积组间比较 P=0.320。
  • 新发远隔血肿发生率组间比较 P=0.647,去骨瓣减压术后脑积水发生率组间比较 P=0.083。
  • 创伤性脑损伤亚组共 49 例。

临床怎么用

  • 去骨瓣减压术后可依据情况选择真空引流、被动引流或不引流,三者并发症发生率相近。
  • 帽状腱膜下血肿量较高不必单独视为结局不良的预测因素。
  • 真空引流对功能结局与死亡率的潜在优势及不引流对脑积水的影响尚待证实,暂不能作为常规推荐依据。

局限性

  • 原文未涉及该试验的局限性描述。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: Subgaleal drains are generally deemed necessary for cranial surgeries including decompressive craniectomies (DCs) to avoid excessive postoperative subgaleal hematoma (SGH) formation. Many surgeries have moved away from routine prophylactic drainage but the role of subgaleal drainage in cranial surgeries has not been addressed. METHODS: This was a randomized controlled trial at 2 centers. A total of 78 patients requiring DC were randomized in a 1:1:1 ratio into 3 groups: vacuum drains (VD), passive drains (PD), and no drains (ND). Complications studied were need for surgical revision, SGH amount, new remote hematomas, postcraniectomy hydrocephalus (PCH), functional outcomes, and mortality. RESULTS: Only 1 VD patient required surgical revision to evacuate SGH. There was no difference in SGH thickness and volume among the 3 drain types (P = 0.171 and P = 0.320, respectively). Rate of new remote hematoma and PCH was not significantly different (P = 0.647 and P = 0.083, respectively), but the ND group did not have any patient with PCH. In the subgroup analysis of 49 patients with traumatic brain injury, the SGH amount of the PD and ND group was significantly higher than that of the VD group. However, these higher amounts did not translate as a significant risk factor for poor functional outcome or mortality. VD may have better functional outcome and mortality. CONCLUSIONS: In terms of complication rates, VD, PD, and ND may be used safely in DC. A higher amount of SGH was not associated with poorer outcomes. Further studies are needed to clarify the advantage of VD regarding functional outcome and mortality, and if ND reduces PCH rates.

来源:World Neurosurg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Sam JE, Kandasamy R, Wong ASH, et al. Vacuum Drains versus Passive Drains versus No Drains in Decompressive Craniectomies-A Randomized Controlled Trial on Subgaleal Drain Complication Rates (VADER Trial). World Neurosurg. 2021. PMID: 34563715. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2021.09.074

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。