YouTube脑膜瘤治疗视频质量:DISCERN工具评估
该研究用DISCERN工具评估YouTube上脑膜瘤治疗相关视频的质量。结论认为视频信息内容总体较差,医护人员需重视不准确视频对患者理解治疗的影响。
要点
- YouTube脑膜瘤治疗视频信息质量总体较差,平均DISCERN总分仅36.4。
- 健康信息频道上传的视频平均DISCERN总分最高(46.7,标准差=14.6)。
- 含症状、治疗风险、预后信息或动画图解的视频DISCERN评分显著更高。
核心结论
- YouTube上脑膜瘤治疗视频的信息内容总体较差,医护人员须认识到不准确视频对患者理解治疗的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 同时评估视频时长、上传来源、流行度等定量数据及其与DISCERN评分的关联。
主要发现
- 平均DISCERN总分为36.4。
- 约三分之一视频为极差,32.8%为差,11.5%为一般,16.4%为好,4.9%为优秀。
- 「视频是否提及不确定性领域」得分最低(2.0),「视频是否描述每种治疗如何起效」得分最高(3.0)。
- 健康信息频道作者视频平均总分最高(46.7,标准差=14.6)。
- 含脑膜瘤症状、治疗期间危险因素、预后信息或动画图解的视频DISCERN评分显著更高。
临床怎么用
- 应告知患者YouTube脑膜瘤治疗视频质量参差,优先推荐健康信息频道来源。
- 可引导患者选择含症状、风险、预后信息及动画图解的较长视频。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To assess the quality of YouTube videos on meningioma treatment. METHODS: A search was performed on YouTube using the keywords "meningioma treatment," "meningeal tumor treatment," "meningioma brain tumor treatment," "meningioma cure," and "meningioma therapy." Sixty-one videos were independently evaluated by 2 fifth-year medical students using the DISCERN scoring system for quality analysis. Quantitative data such as video length, source of upload, and popularity and their associations with DISCERN scores were also evaluated. RESULTS: The mean total DISCERN score was 36.4. Approximately a third of YouTube videos were classified as very poor, 32.8% as poor, 11.5% as fair, 16.4% as good, and 4.9% as excellent. The question "Does the video refer to areas of uncertainty?" obtained the lowest score (2.0), and the question "Does the video describe how each treatment works?" obtained the highest score (3.0). Videos authored by a health information channel had the highest mean total DISCERN score (46.7, standard deviation = 14.6). Videos had significantly higher DISCERN scores if they included information about the symptoms of meningioma, risk factors during treatment, prognosis, or included animations and diagrams. DISCERN scores were moderately positively correlated with duration of videos and referrers and moderately negatively correlated with number of channel subscribers, video power index, and average daily views. CONCLUSION: The information content on meningioma treatment in YouTube videos was generally poor. The impact of inaccurate YouTube videos on patients' understanding of meningioma treatment must be recognized by health care professionals.
引用
- Śledzińska P, Bebyn MG, Furtak J, et al. Quality of YouTube Videos on Meningioma Treatment Using the DISCERN Instrument. World Neurosurg. 2021. PMID: 34166826. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2021.06.072
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。