补充Spetzler-Martin分级中等别脑动静脉畸形手术可操作性边界
OBJECTIVE: Supplemented Spetzler-Martin grading (Supp-SM), which is the combination of Spetzler-Martin and Lawton-Young grades, was validated as being more accurate than stand-alone Spetzler-Martin grading, but an operability cutoff was not established.…
要点
- Supp-SM 7级AVM术后神经功能恶化风险显著增高(OR 3.7,95%CI 1.9-7.3,p<0.001)
- Supp-SM 6级可作为手术可操作性截断值,7级多数不宜手术
- 年轻、小型病灶的低风险7级(grade 7-)患者术后预后较好
核心结论
- Supp-SM 7级AVM术后神经功能恶化风险显著增高,Supp-SM 6级为适宜手术可操作性截断值。
- 年轻、小型病灶的低风险7级(grade 7-)患者术后预后较好,可考虑手术。
- 7级患者预后不随术者经验改善,提示可操作性边界为反映高级别AVM复杂性的硬性限制。
研究设计与样本
- 另对2000至2011年Supp-SM 6级和7级AVM数据进行二次分析,以确定预后改善或不变的亚型。
- 按病灶大小(S1<3cm,S2 3-6cm,S3>6cm)和年龄(A1<20岁,A2 20-40岁,A3>40岁)组合分为低风险(S1A1、S1A2、S2A1)、中风险(S2A2、S1A3、S3A1)和高风险(S3A3、S3A2、S2A3)三组。
主要发现
- 随访mRS恶化比例:5级24.5%(25/102),6级29.3%(29/99),7级57.8%(26/45),组间差异显著(p<0.001)。
- Supp-SM 7级AVM患者术后mRS恶化风险显著增高(p<0.001;OR 3.7,95%CI 1.9-7.3)。
- 扩大队列349例Supp-SM 6级中,年龄较大且病灶较大的grade 6+患者神经功能恶化比例显著高于其他6级患者(38.6% vs 22.9%,p=0.02)。
- 扩大队列197例Supp-SM 7级中,年轻且病灶较小的grade 7-患者神经功能恶化比例显著低于其他7级患者(19% vs 44.9%,p=0.01)。
关键数值与推荐
- Supp-SM 5级术后mRS恶化比例24.5%(25/102)。
- Supp-SM 6级术后mRS恶化比例29.3%(29/99)。
- Supp-SM 7级术后mRS恶化比例57.8%(26/45),OR 3.7(95%CI 1.9-7.3,p<0.001)。
- Supp-SM 6级中grade 6+恶化比例38.6%,其他6级22.9%(p=0.02)。
- Supp-SM 7级中grade 7-恶化比例19%,其他7级44.9%(p=0.01)。
临床怎么用
- 将Supp-SM 6级作为手术可操作性截断值,7级多数患者手术风险高,需谨慎评估。
- 对Supp-SM 7级中年轻、小型病灶的低风险亚型(grade 7-)可考虑积极手术。
- 对Supp-SM 6级中年龄较大、病灶较大的grade 6+患者应警惕术后神经功能恶化风险。
局限性
- 研究为回顾性分析,样本来自两中心,可能存在选择偏倚。
- 扩大队列分析基于2000至2011年数据,与主队列时间跨度不同。
- 未报告术者经验对7级患者预后影响的具体量化数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Supplemented Spetzler-Martin grading (Supp-SM), which is the combination of Spetzler-Martin and Lawton-Young grades, was validated as being more accurate than stand-alone Spetzler-Martin grading, but an operability cutoff was not established. In this study, the authors surgically treated intermediate-grade AVMs to provide prognostic factors for neurological outcomes and to define AVMs at the boundary of operability. METHODS: Surgically treated Supp-SM intermediate-grade (5, 6, and 7) AVMs were analyzed from 2011 to 2018 at two medical centers. Worsened neurological outcomes were defined as increased modified Rankin Scale (mRS) scores on postoperative examinations. A second analysis of 2000-2011 data for Supp-SM grade 6 and 7 AVMs was performed to determine the subtypes with improved or unchanged outcomes. Patients were separated into three groups based on nidus size (S1: < 3 cm, S2: 3-6 cm, S3: > 6 cm) and age (A1: < 20 years, A2: 20-40 years, A3: > 40 years), followed by any combination of the combined supplemented grade: low risk (S1A1, S1A2, S2A1), intermediate risk (S2A2, S1A3, S3A1, or high risk (S3A3, S3A2, S2A3). RESULTS: Two hundred forty-six patients had intermediate Supp-SM grade AVMs. Of these patients, 102 had Supp-SM grade 5 (41.5%), 99 had Supp-SM grade 6 (40.2%), and 45 had Supp-SM grade 7 (18.3%). Significant differences in the proportions of patients with worse mRS scores at follow-up were found between the groups, with 24.5% (25/102) of patients in Supp-SM grade 5, 29.3% (29/99) in Supp-SM grade 6, and 57.8% (26/45) in Supp-SM grade 7 (p < 0.001). Patients with Supp-SM grade 7 AVMs had significantly increased odds of worse postoperative mRS scores (p < 0.001; OR 3.7, 95% CI 1.9-7.3). In the expanded cohort of 349 Supp-SM grade 6 AVM patients, a significantly higher proportion of older patients with larger Supp-SM grade 6 AVMs (grade 6+, 38.6%) had neurological deterioration than the others with Supp-SM grade 6 AVMs (22.9%, p = 0.02). Conversely, in an expanded cohort of 197 Supp-SM grade 7 AVM patients, a significantly lower proportion of younger patients with smaller Supp-SM grade 7 AVMs (grade 7-, 19%) had neurological deterioration than the others with Supp-SM grade 7 AVMs (44.9%, p = 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Patients with Supp-SM grade 7 AVMs are at increased risk of worse postoperative neurological outcomes, making Supp-SM grade 6 an appropriate operability cutoff. However, young patients with small niduses in the low-risk Supp-SM grade 7 group (grade 7-) have favorable postoperative outcomes. Outcomes in Supp-SM grade 7 patients did not improve with surgeon experience, indicating that the operability boundary is a hard limit reflecting the complexity of high-grade AVMs.
引用
- Catapano JS, Frisoli FA, Nguyen CL, et al. Intermediate-grade brain arteriovenous malformations and the boundary of operability using the supplemented Spetzler-Martin grading system. J Neurosurg. 2021. PMID: 34171830. doi:10.3171/2020.11.JNS203298
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。