文献速递神经肿瘤功能神经外科

Dandy大脑半球切除术:历史回顾与文献引用准确性分析

Dandy's hemispherectomies: historical vignette.
PubMed 文献 · J Neurosurg · 2021-05-14

本文回顾Walter Dandy 1928年关于大脑半球切除术的原始论文,并检索Web of Science和Scopus评估88篇引用文献的准确性。Dandy的5例手术患者中1例术后48小时内死于出血,1例2周死于肺炎,2例分别于3个月和3.5年死于肿瘤复发,第5例术后2周后失访。仅11%的引用文献准确引用了Dandy的论文,76%引用错误,且错误引用均发表于1997年及以后。

要点

  • Dandy时代胶质瘤被认为不可治愈,他基于运动功能丧失提示半球无有用组织的假说首创 radical 半球切除术。
  • Dandy的5例手术患者预后差:1例术后48小时死于出血,1例2周死于肺炎,2例死于肿瘤复发。
  • 现代文献对Dandy工作的引用准确性低,仅11%准确,76%错误,且错误引用集中于1997年后。

核心结论

  • 结合历史背景批判性阅读Dandy的原始报告有助于理解其意图和贡献价值。
  • 现代文献对Dandy半球切除术的引用准确性呈下降趋势,早期论文引用更准确。

研究设计与样本

  • 历史回顾性研究,回顾Dandy 1928年原始论文,并检索Thomson Reuters Web of Science和Scopus数据库。
  • 共纳入88篇符合标准的论文,分析其对Dandy论文引用的准确性。

主要发现

  • Dandy的5例手术患者中,1例术后48小时内死于出血(血管夹移位),1例2周死于肺炎,2例分别于3个月和3.5年死于肿瘤复发,第5例术后2周后失访。
  • 88篇论文中仅11%(10/88)准确引用Dandy的论文,其中一半发表于1997年前。
  • 76%(67/88)的论文错误引用Dandy,全部发表于1997年及以后;剩余13%(11/88)引用准确性不明确。

临床怎么用

  • 神经外科医生在引用历史文献时应核对原始来源,避免传播错误信息。
  • 理解Dandy时代胶质瘤不可治愈的背景及其基于运动功能丧失推断半球无有用组织的假说,有助于客观评价半球切除术的历史意义。

局限性

  • 仅检索Web of Science和Scopus,可能遗漏其他数据库的文献。
  • 引用准确性判断可能受主观因素影响,且部分论文引用准确性不明确。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

To better understand Walter Dandy's intentions and the historical context of his work on hemispherectomy, the authors reviewed his original 1928 publication. Gliomas were considered incurable at that time. Presuming that the loss of motor function denoted a lack of useful tissue in that hemisphere, he pioneered radical removal of the involved cerebral hemisphere. Of the 5 patients operated on by Dandy, 1 died within 48 hours of hemorrhage because of a displaced vascular clip; 1 died of pneumonia in 2 weeks; 2 died of tumor recurrence, at 3 months and 3.5 years, respectively; and a fifth patient was lost to follow-up beyond the 2nd postoperative week. The authors queried the Thomson Reuters Web of Science and Scopus. A total of 88 papers fulfilled inclusion criteria. Half of these papers (44/88) were published after 2012. Only 11% of papers (10/88) quoted Dandy's paper accurately; half of them were published before 1997. Most publications (76% [67/88]) quoted Dandy incorrectly, all of them from 1997 and later. In the remaining 11 papers (13%), the accuracy of the quotes was unclear. The authors found a trend toward more accurate citation in earlier papers. Critically reviewing Dandy's report, with an understanding of the historical context, allows a better understanding of his intentions and the value of his contribution.

来源:J Neurosurg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jusue-Torres I, Prabhu VC, Jones GA, et al. Dandy's hemispherectomies: historical vignette. J Neurosurg. 2021. PMID: 33990086. doi:10.3171/2020.9.JNS202824

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。