术者经验对80岁及以上颅内脑膜瘤患者手术结局的影响
该研究纳入2010至2018年间由12位神经外科医生手术的83例80岁及以上颅内脑膜瘤患者,按术者手术量分为低、中、高容量组,分析术者经验与患者1年死亡率和3个月独立生活能力的关系。结果显示,低容量术者组患者1年死亡率风险最低(OR 0.15 [0.01-2.05]),术后3个月在家居住可能性最高(OR 12.61 [1.21-131.03]);手术生涯长度每增加5年与1年死亡率相关(OR 1.34 [1.03-1.73]),但调整年龄、性别和术前独立性后略无统计学意义。结论提示在高容量学术医院中,经验较少的神经外科医生即使对高危脑膜瘤患者也能取得与经验丰富者相似的结果。
要点
- 低容量术者组1年死亡率OR为0.15(0.01-2.05),风险最低。
- 低容量术者组术后3个月在家居住OR为12.61(1.21-131.03)。
- 手术生涯每增5年与1年死亡率OR 1.34(1.03-1.73)相关。
核心结论
- 在高容量学术医院中,经验较少的神经外科医生对高龄脑膜瘤患者的手术结果与经验丰富者相似。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入2010至2018年间83例80岁及以上颅内脑膜瘤手术患者,由12位神经外科医生完成。
- 按术者手术量分为低容量组(8位医生,每人1-4例)、中容量组(3位医生,每人8-12例)和高容量组(1位医生,37例)。
主要发现
- 低容量术者组患者1年死亡率OR为0.15(95%CI 0.01-2.05),为最低风险组。
- 低容量术者组患者术后3个月在家居住OR为12.61(95%CI 1.21-131.03),可能性最高。
- 手术生涯长度每增加5年与1年死亡率OR 1.34(95%CI 1.03-1.73)相关,与3个月在家居住OR 0.83(95%CI 0.69-1.00)相关,但调整年龄、性别和术前独立性后略无统计学意义。
临床怎么用
- 在高容量中心,不应仅凭术者手术量或从业年限预判高龄脑膜瘤患者的手术结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Previous reports suggest that more experienced surgeons have better postoperative outcomes in neurosurgery. We studied whether this association is found in a fragile cohort of ≥80-year-old intracranial meningioma (IM) patients. METHODS: We identified 83 very old IM patients who were operated on by 12 different surgeons between 2010 and 2018. Besides general patient- and tumor-related characteristics, we collected information about the surgeons' case volume and length of surgical career (LSC). We classified neurosurgeons into 3 different categories: 1) low-volume (8 surgeons; 1-4 operations per surgeon); 2) moderate-volume (3 surgeons; 8-12 operations per surgeon); and 3) high-volume (1 reference surgeon; 37 operations). We calculated odds ratios (ORs) with 95% confidence intervals for 1-year mortality and 3-month independency (capability to live at home) by surgeon volume categories and per 5-year increase of LSC. RESULTS: We found no significant differences in any preoperative characteristics between the surgeon volume categories. IM patients operated on by low-volume surgeons had the lowest risk of first-year mortality (OR, 0.15 [0.01-2.05]) and the highest likelihood of living at home 3 months after surgery (OR, 12.61 [1.21-131.03]). Increasing LSC was associated with 1-year mortality (OR, 1.34 [1.03-1.73]) and with lower likelihood to live at home 3 months after surgery (OR, 0.83 [0.69-1.00]), but these associations were slightly nonsignificant after adjusting for IM patients' age, sex, and preoperative independency. CONCLUSIONS: In a high-volume academic hospital, less experienced neurosurgeons seem to achieve similar results as the more experienced neurosurgeons, even when operating on selected highly fragile meningioma patients.
引用
- Rautalin I, Schwartz C, Niemelä M, et al. Effect of Surgeon Experience on Surgical Outcome of 80-Year-Old or Older Intracranial Meningioma Patients. World Neurosurg. 2021. PMID: 33422717. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2020.12.166
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。