大脑半球切开术失败经验:40例早期病例分析
单外科医生癫痫手术项目前4年连续40例患者共接受47次功能性大脑半球切开术,9例(23.5%)首次手术失败,6例接受再次手术,失败者均来自项目前2年治疗的前15例患者。末次随访35/40例(87.5%)无发作(Engel Ia),再次手术对4/6例有效,无死亡。
要点
- 半球切开术失败多因离断不彻底,影像可识别残留连接。
- 大脑半球巨脑畸形和手术项目早期阶段失败风险更高。
- 再次手术前明确神经影像有助于改善预后。
核心结论
- 再次手术在大脑半球巨脑畸形和手术项目早期更常见,明确的神经影像可改善再次手术结局。
研究设计与样本
- 单外科医生癫痫手术项目启动后4年内连续40例功能性大脑半球切开术患者,共47次手术(6例患者7次再次手术),平均年龄9.45±14.84岁,含7例婴儿(<2岁)。
主要发现
- 9例(23.5%)首次手术失败,其中6例符合再次手术条件,全部来自项目前2年治疗的前15例患者。
- 失败最常见病因为大脑半球巨脑畸形(n=4),影像识别的未离断残留包括同侧颞干(n=3)、额底连接(n=2)、胼胝体压部(n=2)和后岛叶(n=2)。
- 6例中5例失败原因明确为离断不彻底,提示手术充分性不足。
- 平均随访30±13.17个月(范围13-55个月),35/40例(87.5%)保持无发作(Engel Ia),包括4/6例再次手术患者。
- 再次手术未使剩余2例获益(Engel III),无死亡。
临床怎么用
- 对大脑半球巨脑畸形及手术项目早期病例应警惕离断不彻底风险。
- 失败后再次手术前应通过神经影像明确残留连接,以提高再次手术成功率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To study the factors responsible for failure of hemispherotomy and outcomes of revision surgery. The effect of the surgeon's learning curve on failures was also analyzed. METHODS: Forty consecutive patients, who underwent functional hemispherotomy through a 4-year period, from the inception of the single-surgeon epilepsy surgery program, were analyzed. RESULTS: A total of 47 functional hemispherotomies were performed in the study period in 40 patients (7 revision surgeries on 6 patients). Mean age of the cohort was 9.45 ± 14.84 years and it included 7 infants (<2 years). Of the 9 patients (23.5%) who failed the first procedure, 6 qualified for revision surgery, all of whom belonged to the cohort of the first 15 patients treated during the first 2 years of the program. Hemimegalencephaly was the most common disease (n = 4). Ipsilateral temporal stem (n = 3), frontobasal connections (n = 2), splenium of corpus callosum (n = 2), and posterior insula (n = 2) were residual undisconnected substrates identified for revision on imaging. The substrates for failure were obvious in 5/6 patients and resulted from incomplete disconnection, implying surgical inadequacy. At the mean follow-up of 30 ± 13.17 months (range, 13-55 months), 35 of 40 patients (87.5%) remained seizure free (Engel class Ia), including 4/6 patients who underwent redo surgery. Revision did not benefit the remaining 2 patients (Engel class III). There was no mortality. CONCLUSIONS: Surgical revision is more common in hemimegalencephaly and in the early days of a surgical program. Affirmative neuroimaging improves the outcomes of subsequent revision surgery.
引用
- Kurwale NS, Patil SB, Jagtap SA, et al. Failed Hemispherotomy: Insights from Our Early Experience in 40 Patients. World Neurosurg. 2020. PMID: 33171323. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2020.10.170
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。