COVID-19大流行期间基于共识的围手术期方案
加州大学旧金山分校组建26名多学科领导者小组,采用改良两轮盲法Delphi法基于18条同意/不同意陈述达成共识。15/18条首轮达成共识,3条显著分歧(p<0.01)修改后重新提交达成共识,最终制定量化疫情级别、按急迫性分诊、紧急侵入性操作清单及个人防护装备分配评分系统等围手术期方案。
要点
- 改良Delphi法两轮盲法评估18条陈述,15条首轮达成共识,3条修改后达成共识
- 共识方案包括量化疫情级别、按急迫性分诊、紧急侵入性操作清单和PPE分配评分系统
- 修改美国外科医师学会三级分诊系统以纳入更多神经外科和脊柱外科常见急症
核心结论
- 基于共识的围手术期方案可协助医疗提供者在COVID-19大流行期间优化围手术期护理。
研究设计与样本
- 加州大学旧金山分校组建26名多学科领导者小组,涵盖10个学术部门,包括7名部门主席、首席医疗官、首席运营官、感染控制官员、护理领导者和住院医师代表,并咨询流行病学家、伦理学家和统计学家。
- 采用基于18条同意/不同意陈述的改良两轮盲法Delphi法建立共识,使用单侧精确二项检验检测每条陈述的显著分歧,预期共识度为95%,显著性阈值p<0.05。
- 最终分诊方案通过非盲组级讨论制定。
主要发现
- 18条陈述中15条在首轮Delphi法中达成共识。
- 3条存在显著分歧(p<0.01)的陈述经修改后迭代重新提交专家小组以达成共识。
- 基于共识的方案通过非盲多学科小组讨论制定。
关键数值与推荐
- 最终算法包括:1)量化疫情级别;2)根据急迫性对患者进行分诊;3)提供紧急/侵入性操作清单;4)创建个人防护装备分配的新评分系统。
- 作者修改了美国外科医师学会三级分诊系统以纳入更多急症病例,如神经外科和脊柱外科常见情况。
临床怎么用
- 紧急和侵入性操作在COVID-19大流行期间仍需进行。
- 共识方案可协助医疗提供者在疫情期间优化围手术期护理。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: During the COVID-19 pandemic, quaternary-care facilities continue to provide care for patients in need of urgent and emergent invasive procedures. Perioperative protocols are needed to streamline care for these patients notwithstanding capacity and resource constraints. METHODS: A multidisciplinary panel was assembled at the University of California, San Francisco, with 26 leaders across 10 academic departments, including 7 department chairpersons, the chief medical officer, the chief operating officer, infection control officers, nursing leaders, and resident house staff champions. An epidemiologist, an ethicist, and a statistician were also consulted. A modified two-round, blinded Delphi method based on 18 agree/disagree statements was used to build consensus. Significant disagreement for each statement was tested using a one-sided exact binomial test against an expected outcome of 95% consensus using a significance threshold of p < 0.05. Final triage protocols were developed with unblinded group-level discussion. RESULTS: Overall, 15 of 18 statements achieved consensus in the first round of the Delphi method; the 3 statements with significant disagreement (p < 0.01) were modified and iteratively resubmitted to the expert panel to achieve consensus. Consensus-based protocols were developed using unblinded multidisciplinary panel discussions. The final algorithms 1) quantified outbreak level, 2) triaged patients based on acuity, 3) provided a checklist for urgent/emergent invasive procedures, and 4) created a novel scoring system for the allocation of personal protective equipment. In particular, the authors modified the American College of Surgeons three-tiered triage system to incorporate more urgent cases, as are often encountered in neurosurgery and spine surgery. CONCLUSIONS: Urgent and emergent invasive procedures need to be performed during the COVID-19 pandemic. The consensus-based protocols in this study may assist healthcare providers to optimize perioperative care during the pandemic.
引用
- Mummaneni PV, Burke JF, Chan AK, et al. Consensus-based perioperative protocols during the COVID-19 pandemic. J Neurosurg Spine. 2020. PMID: 33007752. doi:10.3171/2020.6.SPINE20777
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。