导航与透视引导下椎弓根螺钉置入准确性与并发症率比较
回顾性研究评估2013至2018年间176例脊柱内固定手术共831枚螺钉,导航引导296枚(35.6%),透视引导535枚(64.4%)。导航组螺钉位置欠佳率2.03%(6枚),透视组4.11%(22枚),总体误置率3.4%。导航有助于降低学习曲线早期或手术量较少术者的螺钉误置率。
要点
- 导航引导椎弓根螺钉置入的欠佳位置率(2.03%)低于透视引导(4.11%)。
- 透视引导下术者间螺钉置入准确性差异更大,低手术量术者误置率更高。
- 对于学习曲线早期或不常进行该手术的脊柱外科医生,导航可降低螺钉误置率。
核心结论
- 导航引导脊柱内固定比透视引导更准确,且并发症率似乎更低。
- 对于学习曲线早期或不常进行脊柱内固定的术者,导航有助于降低螺钉误置率。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,评估2013至2018年间在Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust放置的所有椎弓根螺钉,并进行影像学和临床评估。
- 共纳入176例脊柱内固定病例,植入831枚螺钉,其中导航引导296枚(35.6%),透视引导535枚(64.4%)。
主要发现
- 导航引导系列中螺钉位置欠佳占2.03%(6枚),透视引导系列占4.11%(22枚),总体螺钉误置率为3.4%。
- 治疗的病理包括椎管狭窄、脊椎滑脱、肿瘤和创伤。
- 评估术者个体准确率发现,透视引导技术下螺钉位置欠佳变异更大,且低手术量术者的误置率更高。
临床怎么用
- 对于学习曲线早期或手术量较少的脊柱外科医生,可优先考虑使用导航引导进行椎弓根螺钉置入以降低误置率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Accurate placement of the pedicle screw is requisite for any successful spinal instrumentation procedure. Screw insertion can be achieved using free-hand and fluoroscopic- or navigation-guided techniques. We sought to assess the variation in accuracy between fluoroscopic- and navigation-guided techniques, which are both used in Sheffield Teaching Hospitals National Health Service Trust, a tertiary spine referral center. METHODS: Using a retrospective study design, we assessed all the pedicle screws placed between 2013 and 2018. Radiographic and clinical assessment of all cases was performed. RESULTS: We studied 176 spinal instrumented cases, with a total of 831 screws implanted, out of which 296 (35.6%) were navigated and 535 (64.4%) were fluoroscopic guided. Pathology treated included spinal stenosis, spondylolisthesis, tumors, and trauma. Suboptimal screw position was identified in 2.03% (n = 6) of the navigation-guided series and 4.11% (n = 22) of the fluoroscopic-guided series with an overall screw misplacement rate of 3.4%. Evaluating surgeons' individual accuracy rates revealed that suboptimal screw placement registered a higher variation for the fluoroscopy-guided technique, and the misplacement rate was higher for surgeons with a lower volume of cases. CONCLUSIONS: Use of navigation during spinal instrumentation helps lower the rate of screw misplacement for spinal surgeons who are at the beginning of their learning curve or do not frequently perform this kind of procedure. Navigation-guided spinal instrumentation is more accurate compared with fluoroscopic-guided techniques and appears to have a lower complication rate.
引用
- Budu A, Sims-Williams H, Radatz M, et al. Comparison of Navigated versus Fluoroscopic-Guided Pedicle Screw Placement Accuracy and Complication Rate. World Neurosurg. 2020. PMID: 32891853. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2020.08.207
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。