文献速递神经肿瘤功能神经外科

术中语言测试与解读在神经外科医生或神经心理学家间存在高评分者间变异性:标准化需求初现

High Interrater Variability in Intraoperative Language Testing and Interpretation in Awake Brain Mapping Among Neurosurgeons or Neuropsychologists: An Emerging Need for Standardization.
PubMed 文献 · World Neurosurg · 2020-06-06

本研究通过国际电子问卷调查了137名神经外科医生和神经心理学家,评估术中语言测试实践的可变性。结果显示20个问题的评分者间一致性低(Krippendorff α = -0.023至0.312),且不受专业和经验影响。结论指出需要标准化以减少观察者间、机构间和专业间的变异性。

要点

  • 术中语言测试实践在专家间存在高度变异性,一致性低。
  • 变异性与专业背景和经验年限无关。
  • 亟需标准化以提高术中 mapping 的效度和预测能力。

核心结论

  • 术中语言测试与解读存在高评分者间变异性,无论专业或经验如何,提示需要标准化和共识。

研究设计与样本

  • 由伦敦Queen Square多学科团队开发电子问卷,通过选定组织学会国际分发,调查术语理解和特定脑区术中测试选择,参与者按专业、经验年限和月病例量分层,使用Krippendorff α、Wilcoxon秩和检验和Kruskal-Wallis方差分析进行数据分析。

主要发现

  • 共137名专家参与,20个问题的Krippendorff α为-0.023至0.312,一致性低。
  • 亚组分析显示神经外科医生与非神经外科医生的α分别为0.013-0.318和-0.021至0.398,P=0.808。
  • 经验年限亚组(<1年、2-5年、6-10年、>10年)的α分别为-0.003至0.282、0.009-0.327、0.003-0.234、-0.003至0.372,P=0.200。

临床怎么用

  • 临床实践中应意识到术中语言测试存在显著变异性,考虑参与标准化制定以提高测试效度和解读一致性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: Brain mapping with direct electric stimulation is considered the gold standard for maximum safe resection of tumors affecting eloquent regions. However, no consensus exists in selection and interpretation of intraoperative testing for language and other cognitive domains. Our aim was to capture and statistically analyze variability in practices in intraoperative language testing among neurosurgeons and neuropsychologists in the United States, Europe, and the rest of the world. METHODS: An electronic questionnaire was developed by a multidisciplinary team at Queen Square, London, and distributed internationally through selected organized societies. The survey included 2 domains: terminology and common understanding of clinical deficits; and selection of intraoperative tests used per specific brain region. Participants were stratified by specialty, years of experience, and monthly caseload. Data were analyzed using Krippendorff α, Wilcoxon rank sum test, and Kruskal-Wallis analysis of variance. RESULTS: A total of 137 specialists participated. A low agreement was recorded for each of the 20 questions (Krippendorff α = -0.023 to 0.312). Further subgroup analysis revealed low interrater reliability independent of specialism (neurosurgeons, α = 0.013-0.318 compared with nonneurosurgeons, α = -0.021 to 0.398; P = 0.808) and years of experience (<1 years, α = -0.003 to 0.282; 2-5 years, α = 0.009-0.327; 6-10 years, α = 0.003-0.234; and >10 years, α = -0.003 to 0.372; P = 0.200). CONCLUSIONS: The current study documents high interrater variability, regardless of specialism and years of experience in the cohort of neurosurgeons and language specialists surveyed and may be applicable to a wider group of specialists, indicating the need to reduce interobserver, interinstitutional and interspecialty variability, reach consensus, and increase the validity, interpretation, and predictive power of intraoperative mapping.

来源:World Neurosurg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Sefcikova V, Sporrer JK, Ekert JO, et al. High Interrater Variability in Intraoperative Language Testing and Interpretation in Awake Brain Mapping Among Neurosurgeons or Neuropsychologists: An Emerging Need for Standardization. World Neurosurg. 2020. PMID: 32522656. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2020.05.250

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。