东非小儿神经外科教育与需求调查
本研究向东非小儿神经外科培训工作坊的11名神经外科医生和学员发放问卷,调查神经外科教育现状与实践需求。结果显示,所有受访者均在肯尼亚完成培训,创伤、出血性卒中和儿童肿瘤最常见,所有受访者认为需要更多直接手术教学。脑积水、神经内镜和肿瘤被视为最有用的培训内容。
要点
- 所有受访者均在肯尼亚完成神经外科培训,尽管来自5个国家。
- 创伤、出血性卒中和儿童肿瘤是最常治疗的病种。
- 全部受访者认为增加直接手术教学对教育改进重要。
核心结论
- 调查识别了东非神经外科教育与培训需求的重点领域,可指导后续教育努力。
研究设计与样本
- 针对东非小儿神经外科培训工作坊的学员和顾问进行问卷调查,共11名神经外科医生和学员完成调查,包括6名住院医师(55%)和5名顾问(45%)。
主要发现
- 受访者最常治疗的病种为创伤(均值4.55±0.93)、出血性卒中(均值4.27±0.79)和儿童肿瘤(均值4.27±1.01)。
- 培训中最常用的学习资源为在线资源(9人;82%)、教科书(7人;64%)和在线讲座(7人;64%)。
- 感知教育需求最大的领域包括普通神经外科(9人;82%)、小儿(9人;82%)、创伤与神经重症(7人;64%)和神经肿瘤(7人;64%)。
- 全部11名受访者(100%)报告更多直接手术教学对教育改进重要。
- 在小儿神经外科培训中最有用的内容为脑积水(均值5.00±0.00)、神经内镜(均值4.91±0.30)和肿瘤(均值4.91±0.30)。
临床怎么用
- 教育规划者可优先加强普通神经外科、小儿神经外科、创伤与神经重症及神经肿瘤的培训。
- 应增加直接手术教学,并重点覆盖脑积水、神经内镜和肿瘤内容。
局限性
- 样本量小(11人),且所有受访者均在肯尼亚完成培训,可能限制结果的代表性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: A pediatric neurosurgery training workshop was organized for residents and consultants in East Africa. We aimed to compile feedback from the course participants to 1) characterize the state of neurosurgical education; and 2) identify the perceived practical education needs. METHODS: The survey of demographic, clinical background and practice, and feedback questions was distributed to all attendees. Responses were elicited via yes/no questions and Likert scales, with the score ranging from 1 (not important, not useful, never) to 5 (very important, very useful, often). The data were de-identified and analyzed in aggregate. RESULTS: A total of 11 neurosurgeons and trainees completed the survey, including 6 residents (55%) and 5 consultants (45%). Although 5 countries of origin were represented, all attendees (100%) have completed their neurosurgery training in Kenya. The respondents had most frequently treated trauma (least common to most common, 1-5; mean, 4.55 ± 0.93), hemorrhagic stroke (mean, 4.27 ± 0.79), and pediatric tumors (mean, 4.27 ± 1.01). In training, the most commonly used study resources were online resources (9; 82%), textbooks (7; 64%), and online lectures (7; 64%). The areas of greatest perceived need in education and training included general neurosurgery (least to most need, 1-10: 9; 82%), pediatric (9; 82%), trauma and neurocritical care (7; 64%), and neuro-oncology (7; 64%). All 11 respondents (100%) reported that more direct operative teaching was important for educational improvement. Hydrocephalus (least to most useful, 1-5: 5.00 ± 0.00), neuro-endoscopy (4.91 ± 0.30), and tumor (4.91 ± 0.30) were considered the most useful content covered in the pediatric neurosurgery-focused training program to improve skills and knowledge base. CONCLUSIONS: The results from the present survey identified areas of education and training needs to guide further neurosurgical education efforts in East Africa.
引用
- Du RY, Thiong'o GM, LoPresti MA, et al. Pediatric Neurosurgery in East Africa: An Education and Needs-Based Survey. World Neurosurg. 2020. PMID: 32454199. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2020.05.155
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。