文献速递神经肿瘤功能神经外科

术前经颅磁刺激与术中直接皮层刺激的语言错误发生率及语言质量比较

Incidence and linguistic quality of speech errors: a comparison of preoperative transcranial magnetic stimulation and intraoperative direct cortex stimulation.
PubMed 文献 · J Neurosurg · 2020-05-29

结果显示rnTMS阳性语言点数量为DCS的两倍以上,但空间重叠敏感性仅35%、阳性预测值16%,特异性90%、阴性预测值96%,且重叠区内错误质量无相关性。结论认为当前rnTMS方案能可靠识别语言阴性位点,但无法可靠检测语言阳性位点。

要点

  • rnTMS定位语言阴性位点可靠性高(特异性90%,阴性预测值96%)。
  • rnTMS检测语言阳性位点敏感性低(35%),阳性预测值仅16%。
  • rnTMS与DCS重叠区内语言错误质量无相关性。

核心结论

  • 当前rnTMS语言映射方案可可靠识别语言阴性位点,但不能可靠检测语言阳性位点。
  • 需进一步改进技术才能使rnTMS语言映射成为有用的临床工具。

研究设计与样本

  • 术前行rnTMS(5 Hz,五个脉冲串,平均105%静息运动阈值)定位语言区。
  • 术中清醒手术下行导航直接皮层刺激(双极,50 Hz,6-8 mA,200微秒脉宽)结合图片命名任务。
  • 阳性与阴性刺激点记录于同一MRI数据集,比较空间重叠、皮层分区系统分配及语言质量。

主要发现

  • 暴露区内rnTMS阳性语言点数量为DCS的两倍以上。
  • rnTMS与DCS(金标准)阳性重叠比较:敏感性35%,阳性预测值16%,特异性90%,阴性预测值96%。
  • 重叠区内语言错误质量无相关性。
  • DCS语言阳性点中73%位于额盖岛盖部及三角部,24%位于缘上回及颞上回背侧部分;rnTMS语言阳性分布更均匀地分布于多个脑回。

临床怎么用

  • rnTMS可用于术前排除语言阴性位点,辅助患者咨询和手术规划。
  • 不宜单独依赖rnTMS定位语言阳性位点,清醒手术下直接皮层刺激仍为必要验证手段。

局限性

  • rnTMS与DCS重叠区内语言错误质量无相关性,提示两种方法捕获的语言功能信息可能不同。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: Given the interindividual variance of functional language anatomy, risk prediction based merely on anatomical data is insufficient in language area-related brain tumor surgery, suggesting the need for direct cortical and subcortical mapping during awake surgery. Reliable, noninvasive preoperative methods of language localization hold the potential for reducing the necessity for awake procedures and may improve patient counseling and surgical planning. Repetitive navigated transcranial magnetic stimulation (rnTMS) is an evolving tool for localizing language-eloquent areas. The aim of this study was to investigate the reliability of rnTMS in locating cortical language sites. METHODS: Twenty-five patients with brain tumors in speech-related areas were prospectively evaluated with preoperative rnTMS (5 Hz, train of five, average 105% resting motor threshold) and navigated direct cortical stimulation (DCS; bipolar, 50 Hz, 6-8 mA, 200-μsec pulse width) during awake surgeries employing a picture-naming task. Positive and negative stimulation spots within the craniotomy were documented in the same MRI data set. TMS and DCS language-positive areas were compared with regard to their spatial overlap, their allocation in a cortical parcellation system, and their linguistic qualities. RESULTS: There were over twofold more positive language spots within the exposed area on rnTMS than on DCS. The comparison of positive rnTMS and DCS (ground truth) overlaps revealed low sensitivity (35%) and low positive predictive value (16%) but high specificity (90%) and high negative predictive value (96%). Within the overlaps, there was no correlation in error quality. On DCS, 73% of language-positive spots were located in the pars opercularis and pars triangularis of the frontal operculum and 24% within the supramarginal gyrus and dorsal portion of the superior temporal gyrus, while on rnTMS language positivity was distributed more evenly over a large number of gyri. CONCLUSIONS: The current protocol for rnTMS for language mapping identified language-negative sites with good dependability but was unable to reliably detect language-positive spots. Further refinements of the technique will be needed to establish rnTMS language mapping as a useful clinical tool.

来源:J Neurosurg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bährend I, Muench MR, Schneider H, et al. Incidence and linguistic quality of speech errors: a comparison of preoperative transcranial magnetic stimulation and intraoperative direct cortex stimulation. J Neurosurg. 2020. PMID: 32470943. doi:10.3171/2020.3.JNS193085

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。