镰状脑膜瘤是镰的弥漫性疾病吗?病例系列及「零级」切除分析
该回顾性研究分析了59例接受手术的镰状脑膜瘤患者,发现对于新发肿瘤,全切除(GTR)较次全切除显著降低复发率(P≤.0001);对于复发肿瘤,GTR组中位无进展生存期(PFS)显著优于次全切除组(37个月 vs 12个月;P=.017,HR .243(.077-.774))。「零级」切除(距肿瘤附着处额外切除2-3 cm镰边缘)在复发患者中显著改善PFS(P=.003,HR 1.544(1.156-2.062)),但在有限随访期(平均2.8年)内,其PFS获益未达统计学显著优于Simpson 1级。
要点
- 新发镰状脑膜瘤中,GTR较次全切除显著降低复发率(P≤.0001)。
- 复发镰状脑膜瘤中,GTR组中位PFS为37个月,次全切除组为12个月(P=.017,HR .243)。
- 「零级」切除在复发患者中显著改善PFS(P=.003,HR 1.544),但对新发患者亦显示良好持久性。
核心结论
- 镰状脑膜瘤的复发与肿瘤在镰叶间弥漫存在有关;扩大切除范围包括在可能时切除肿瘤基底周围清晰的镰边缘,在本系列中与最佳长期结局相关,尤其是复发肿瘤。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析59例接受手术的镰状脑膜瘤患者的特征和结局。
- 当实现距肿瘤附着处额外2至3 cm的切除边缘时,使用「零级」切除类别。
主要发现
- 对于新发镰状脑膜瘤,全切除(GTR)与次全切除相比,复发发生率显著降低(P≤.0001)。
- 对于复发镰状脑膜瘤,GTR组中位无进展生存期(PFS)显著改善(37个月 vs 12个月;P=.017,风险比(HR).243(.077-.774))。
- 「零级」切除在新发和复发病例中均表现出极好的持久性,且复发患者中「零级」切除显著改善PFS(P=.003,HR 1.544(1.156-2.062))。
- 在有限随访期(平均2.8年)内,「零级」切除的PFS获益未达统计学显著优于Simpson 1级。
局限性
- 在有限随访期(平均2.8年)内,「零级」切除的PFS获益未达统计学显著优于Simpson 1级。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Falcine meningiomas have unique characteristics including their high rates of recurrence, association with high grade pathology, increased male prevalence, and potential for diffuse involvement of the falx. OBJECTIVE: To address these issues in a substantial series of falcine meningiomas and report on the impact of extent of resection for this distinct meningioma entity. METHODS: Retrospective analysis of characteristics and outcomes of 59 falcine meningioma patients who underwent surgery with the senior author. A "Grade Zero" category was used when an additional resection margin of 2 to 3 cm from the tumor insertion was achieved. RESULTS: For de novo falcine meningiomas, gross total resection (GTR) was associated with significantly decreased recurrence incidence compared with subtotal resection (P ≤ .0001). For recurrent falcine meningiomas, median progression-free survival (PFS) was significantly improved for GTR cases (37 mo vs 12 mo; P = .017, hazard ratio (HR) .243 (.077-.774)). "Grade Zero" resection demonstrated excellent durability for both de novo and recurrent cases, and PFS was significantly improved with "Grade Zero" resection for recurrent cases (P = .003, HR 1.544 (1.156-2.062)). The PFS benefit of "Grade Zero" resection did not achieve statistical significance over Simpson grade 1 during the limited follow-up period (mean 2.8 yr) for these groups. CONCLUSION: The recurrence of falcine meningiomas is related to the diffuse presence of tumor between the leaflets of the falx. Increased extent of resection including, when possible, a clear margin of falx surrounding the tumor base was associated with the best long-term outcomes in our series, particularly for recurrent tumors.
引用
- Mooney MA, Abolfotoh M, Bi WL, et al. Is Falcine Meningioma a Diffuse Disease of the Falx? Case Series and Analysis of a "Grade Zero" Resection. Neurosurgery. 2020. PMID: 32294205. doi:10.1093/neuros/nyaa038
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。