在低资源环境下评估创伤性脑损伤患者的预后:医生的判断与CRASH风险计算器的比较
本研究在乌干达两家医院招募28名参与TBI诊疗的医生,采用模拟TBI病例的选择实验,一半医生获得CRASH风险评分。CRASH模型预测的14天死亡率为51.4%(95%CI 42.8%, 59.8%)、6个月不良结局为89.8%(95%CI 86.0%, 92.6%);总体上医生对预后的估计过于乐观,获得CRASH评分的医生估计更接近该评分,在经验较少的医生中更明显;86%的受访者选择手术作为最佳下一步治疗。
要点
- 模拟病例的CRASH评分:14天死亡率51.4%(95%CI 42.8%, 59.8%),6个月不良结局89.8%(95%CI 86.0%, 92.6%)。
- 医生总体对TBI预后估计过于乐观。
- 提供CRASH评分后医生估计更接近该评分,经验较少者更明显。
核心结论
- 在低资源环境下,接触CRASH风险评分数据可减少医生对TBI预后的过于乐观估计,尤其在经验较少的医生中。
研究设计与样本
- 采用模拟TBI病例的选择实验,所有参与医生接受同一病例(含病史、生命体征和体格检查),一半参与者额外获得CRASH风险评分。
- 在乌干达一家区域转诊医院和一家国家转诊医院以便利抽样招募28名参与TBI诊疗的医生。
主要发现
- 模拟病例的CRASH风险评分为14天死亡率51.4%(95%CI 42.8%, 59.8%)、6个月不良结局89.8%(95%CI 86.0%, 92.6%)。
- 总体上参与者对患者预后的估计过于乐观。
- 获得CRASH风险评分的医生所作风险估计比对照组医生的估计更接近该评分,此效应在经验较少的医生中更明显。
- 86%的受访者选择手术作为最佳下一步治疗。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Traumatic brain injury (TBI), a burgeoning global health concern, is one condition that could benefit from prognostic modeling. Risk stratification of TBI patients on presentation to a health facility can support the prudent use of limited resources. The CRASH (Corticosteroid Randomisation After Significant Head Injury) model is a well-established prognostic model developed to augment complex decision-making. The authors' current study objective was to better understand in-hospital decision-making for TBI patients and determine whether data from the CRASH risk calculator influenced provider assessment of prognosis. METHODS: The authors performed a choice experiment using a simulated TBI case. All participant doctors received the same case, which included a patient history, vitals, and physical examination findings. Half the participants also received the CRASH risk score. Participants were asked to estimate the patient prognosis and decide the best next treatment step. The authors recruited a convenience sample of 28 doctors involved in TBI care at both a regional and a national referral hospital in Uganda. RESULTS: For the simulated case, the CRASH risk scores for 14-day mortality and an unfavorable outcome at 6 months were 51.4% (95% CI 42.8%, 59.8%) and 89.8% (95% CI 86.0%, 92.6%), respectively. Overall, participants were overoptimistic when estimating the patient prognosis. Risk estimates by doctors provided with the CRASH risk score were closer to that score than estimates made by doctors in the control group; this effect was more pronounced for inexperienced doctors. Surgery was selected as the best next step by 86% of respondents. CONCLUSIONS: This study was a novel assessment of a TBI prognostic model's influence on provider estimation of risk in a low-resource setting. Exposure to CRASH risk score data reduced overoptimistic prognostication by doctors, particularly among inexperienced providers.
引用
- Elahi C, Williamson T, Spears CA, et al. Estimating prognosis for traumatic brain injury patients in a low-resource setting: how do providers compare to the CRASH risk calculator? J Neurosurg. 2020. PMID: 32244205. doi:10.3171/2020.2.JNS192512
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。