儿童人群中的偶然发现脑肿瘤:系统综述与文献再评价
该系统综述遵循PRISMA指南,检索至2019年8月,纳入14项研究共308例18岁以下无症状偶然发现疑似脑肿瘤的患者,所有病例均经磁共振成像诊断。随访显示保守监测者中177例(73%)在平均30个月内保持稳定,而 upfront 手术切除57例在平均68.3个月内均获完全缓解。作者认为现有证据异质性和矛盾结果明显,手术与观察等待的决策应基于个体化评估。
要点
- 308例儿童偶然发现脑肿瘤中,头痛(93例,30%)和创伤(72例,23%)是最常见的影像检查指征。
- 保守监测的243例中,177例(73%)平均30个月内稳定,54例(22%)进展,12例(5%)自行消退。
- upfront 手术切除的57例在平均68.3个月随访中均获完全缓解。
核心结论
- 现有证据量小且异质性和矛盾结果明显,限制得出可靠结论;手术与观察等待的决策应基于恶性嫌疑、临床或影像进展及家长意愿个体化制定。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述遵循PRISMA指南,检索数据库至2019年8月,关键词为「incidental」「brain tumor」「pediatric」,纳入14项研究共308例18岁以下无症状、神经影像偶然发现疑似脑肿瘤的患者,排除囊性、血管性和炎性脑病变。
主要发现
- 所有病例均经磁共振成像诊断;影像检查最常见指征为头痛(93例,30%)和创伤(72例,23%)。
- 病变分布为幕上179例(58%)、幕下121例(40%)、脑室内8例(3%)。
- 308例中243例(79%)接受神经影像监测,57例(19%)接受 upfront 手术切除。
- 保守监测者中177例(73%)在平均30个月随访内保持稳定,54例(22%)进展,12例(5%)自行消退。
- upfront 手术切除的57例在平均68.3个月随访中均获完全缓解。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为手术与观察等待之间的决策应基于恶性嫌疑、临床或影像进展及家长意愿,在个体患者基础上量身定制。
局限性
- 现有证据量小,研究间异质性和矛盾结果明显,限制得出可靠结论。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Management of incidental asymptomatic brain tumors in children is controversial due to lack of clear evidence-based guidelines. We present this systematic review in an attempt to highlight an optimal treatment paradigm. METHODS: This systematic review was conducted in compliance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses guidelines. Databases were searched up to August 2019 using the keywords "incidental," "brain tumor," and "pediatric." Our main focus was on brain lesions suspected for neoplasm, diagnosed incidentally on neuroimaging in an otherwise asymptomatic patient <18 years old. Cystic, vascular, and inflammatory brain lesions were excluded. RESULTS: Fourteen studies comprising 308 patients were included. All cases were diagnosed using magnetic resonance imaging. The most common indications for imaging were headache (93; 30%) and trauma (72; 23%). Lesion distribution was supratentorial (179; 58%), infratentorial (121; 40%), and intraventricular (8; 3%). Of 308 cases, 243 (79%) were managed with neuroradiological surveillance and 57 (19%) by upfront surgical excision. Of those managed conservatively, 177 (73%) remained stable within a mean follow-up of 30 months, 54 (22%) progressed, and 12 (5%) spontaneously regressed. Meanwhile, upfront excision achieved complete remission in all 57 cases over a mean follow-up of 68.3 months. CONCLUSION: A small body of evidence has emerged, highlighting the marked heterogeneity and contradictory results between the available studies, limiting our ability to draw solid conclusions. At this point, the decision between surgery and "watchful waiting" should be tailored on an individual patient basis depending on suspicion of malignancy, clinical or radiologic progression, and parental preference.
引用
- Jumah F, Rallo MS, Quinoa T, et al. Incidental Brain Tumors in the Pediatric Population: A Systematic Review and Reappraisal of Literature. World Neurosurg. 2020. PMID: 32165344. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2020.02.178
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。