腹腔镜辅助脑室腹腔分流置管术既不具成本效益也不能预防远端分流故障
该研究在单一学术机构评估腹腔镜与迷你开腹脑室腹腔分流置管的可靠性和成本效益,68例患者中腹腔镜组40例、开腹组28例,12个月内远端分流翻修率两组无统计学显著差异(P=1.000),但腹腔镜组直接成本(9461美元)高于开腹组(8247美元;P=0.033)。
要点
- 腹腔镜组远端分流翻修率5.0%(2/40)与开腹组3.6%(1/28)无统计学显著差异(P=1.000)。
- 腹腔镜组直接成本9461美元高于开腹组8247美元(P=0.033)。
- 两种腹膜置管方式均安全,本系列12个月远端翻修率约4%。
核心结论
- 腹腔镜与开腹腹膜分流置管均为安全术式,本系列12个月远端翻修率约4%。
- 腹腔镜未在安全性或并发症规避方面带来相对改善,但导致每例患者平均成本增加超过1200美元。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心学术机构评估2013年11月至2017年9月期间所有接受脑室腹腔分流置管的患者,比较腹腔镜与迷你开腹腹膜置管。
- 共68例患者符合纳入标准,腹腔镜组40例(58.8%),开腹组28例。
- 从Vizient数据库比较择期分流置管的直接住院成本,直接成本为归因于手术的住院费用比例。
- 主要终点为成本及指数手术后12个月内腹膜导管翻修。
主要发现
- 3例患者需要至少1次远端分流翻修:腹腔镜组2例(5.0%;其中1例需要第二次翻修),开腹组1例(3.6%)。
- 两组需要远端分流翻修的患者无统计学显著差异(P=1.000;Fisher精确检验)。
- 腹腔镜脑室腹腔分流置管的直接成本(9461美元)高于开腹入路(8247美元;P=0.033)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Laparoscopy for ventriculoperitoneal shunt creation might offer smaller incisions and more reliable placement. We assessed the reliability and cost-effectiveness of this technique compared with mini-laparotomy shunt placement. METHODS: All patients undergoing ventriculoperitoneal shunt creation between November 2013 and September 2017 at a single academic institution were evaluated. Individual cases were assessed for the use of laparoscopy for peritoneal shunt placement (laparoscopy) versus mini-laparotomy for peritoneal shunt placement (open). The direct hospital costs for the laparoscopy and open groups were compared for elective shunt placement from the Vizient database. These direct costs were the proportion of the admission cost attributed to surgery. The primary endpoints included costs and revision of the peritoneal catheter within 12 months of the index procedure. RESULTS: A total of 68 patients met the inclusion criteria. Most cases (n = 40; 58.8%) had been performed with laparoscopy, with 28 performed using an open peritoneal approach. Three patients had required ≥1 distal shunt revision: 2 laparoscopy patients (5.0%; 1 had required a second revision) and 1 open patient (3.6%). No statistically significant differences were found for the patients requiring distal shunt revision between the 2 groups (P = 1.000; Fisher's exact test). The direct cost ($9461) of ventriculoperitoneal shunt creation with laparoscopy was greater than that with an open approach ($8247; P = 0.033). CONCLUSIONS: Both laparoscopy and open peritoneal shunt creation are safe procedures, with a 12-month distal revision rate in the present series of ~4%. Laparoscopy provided no relative improvement in safety or complication avoidance but had resulted in a mean increase in costs of >$1200 per patient.
引用
- Gravbrot N, Aguilar-Salinas P, Walter CM, et al. Laparoscopically Assisted Ventriculoperitoneal Shunt Placement Is not Cost-Effective nor Preventive for Distal Shunt Malfunction. World Neurosurg. 2020. PMID: 32028009. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2020.01.193
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。