脊柱短缩术与翻修松解术治疗复发性成人脊髓栓系综合征的围手术期与临床结局初步比较
回顾2005至2018年16例复发性成人脊髓栓系综合征患者,8例接受脊柱短缩术、8例接受翻修松解术。短缩组无并发症且神经功能均改善或稳定,翻修组3例下肢肌力或大小便功能恶化并出现伤口并发症;短缩组手术时间与出血量较高,但作者认为在瘢痕复杂病例中或可替代翻修松解。
要点
- 短缩组8例均无并发症,下肢及大小便功能均改善或稳定。
- 翻修组2例下肢肌力恶化、3例大小便功能恶化、3例伤口并发症。
- 短缩组中位出血731 ml、手术358分钟,均高于翻修组163 ml、226分钟。
核心结论
- 两组临床结局相当,但脊柱短缩组无患者恶化,而翻修松解组有3例恶化并出现伤口相关并发症。
- 尽管脊柱短缩组手术时间和出血量较高,作者认为在瘢痕严重或复杂伤口翻修病例中该术式或可替代翻修松解术。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2005至2018年收治的16例复发性成人脊髓栓系综合征患者的病历资料。
- 8例接受脊柱短缩术,8例接受翻修松解术,分析人口学、临床结局和围手术期因素。
- 文中附视频展示脊柱短缩技术。
主要发现
- 脊柱短缩组8例均无并发症,下肢及大小便功能均改善或稳定。
- 翻修松解组2例下肢肌力恶化、3例大小便功能恶化、1例膀胱功能改善,3例出现伤口相关并发症。
- 中位估计出血量:短缩组731 ml,翻修松解组163 ml。
- 中位手术时间:短缩组358分钟,翻修松解组226分钟。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,在瘢痕严重或复杂伤口翻修病例中,脊柱短缩术或可替代翻修松解术。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Recurrent tethered cord syndrome (TCS), believed to result from tension on the distal portion of the spinal cord, causes a constellation of neurological symptoms. Detethering surgery has been the traditional treatment for TCS. However, in cases of recurrent TCS, there is a risk of new neurological deficits developing, and subsequent retethering is difficult to prevent. Spinal column shortening has been proposed as an alternative technique to reduce the tension on the spinal cord without incurring the morbidity of revision surgery on the spinal cord. The authors compared the perioperative outcomes and morbidity of patients who were treated with one or the other procedure. METHODS: The medical records of 16 adult patients with recurrent TCS who were treated between 2005 and 2018 were reviewed. Eight patients underwent spinal column shortening, and 8 patients underwent revision detethering surgery. Patient demographics, clinical outcomes, and perioperative factors were analyzed. The authors include a video to illustrate their technique of spinal column shortening. RESULTS: Within the spinal column shortening group, no patients experienced any complications, and all 8 patients either improved or stabilized with regard to lower-extremity and bowel and bladder function. Within the revision detethering group, 2 patients had worsening of lower-extremity strength, 3 patients had worsening of bowel and bladder function, and 1 patient had improvement in bladder function. Also, 3 patients had wound-related complications. The median estimated blood loss was 731 ml in the shortening group and 163 ml in the revision detethering group. The median operative time was 358 minutes in the shortening group and 226 minutes in the revision detethering group. CONCLUSIONS: Clinical outcomes were comparable between the groups, but none of the spinal column shortening patients experienced worsening, whereas 3 of the revision detethering patients did and also had wound-related complications. Although the operative times and blood loss were higher in the spinal column shortening group, this procedure may be an alternative to revision detethering in extremely scarred or complex wound revision cases.
引用
- Zhang C, Chang CC, Mummaneni PV, et al. Spinal column shortening versus revision detethering for recurrent adult tethered cord syndrome: a preliminary comparison of perioperative and clinical outcomes. J Neurosurg Spine. 2020. PMID: 32032960. doi:10.3171/2019.12.SPINE19659
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。