学习曲线的尾端有多长?初始200例后连续1000例内镜经鼻颅底手术的结果
研究回顾性分析连续1000例内镜经鼻颅底手术病例(剔除最初200例以避开早期学习曲线),发现后半程与前半程相比全切除率从60%升至73%(p<0.005),颅咽管瘤全切除率从47%升至71%(p<0.05),脊索瘤从56%升至100%(p<0.05),垂体腺瘤从67%升至75%(p<0.05),分泌性腺瘤激素治愈率从83%升至89%(p<0.05),而并发症率和脑脊液漏率无变化。作者结论认为学习曲线并未进入平台期,可持续数年。
要点
- 剔除前200例后连续1000例内镜经鼻颅底手术,后半程全切除率73% vs 前半程60%(p<0.005)
- 脊索瘤全切除率后半程100% vs 前半程56%(p<0.05),颅咽管瘤71% vs 47%(p<0.05)
- 并发症率前半程6.4% vs 后半程6.2%,术后脑脊液漏2%且前后半程无变化
核心结论
- 本研究显示,与普遍看法相反,手术学习曲线并未进入平台期,而是可持续数年,具体取决于所考虑终点的复杂性。
- 作者认为这些发现可能对临床试验设计、外科教育和患者安全措施有启示。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析前瞻性采集的Weill Cornell Medicine/NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital高级作者所有内镜经鼻颅底手术病例数据库。
- 剔除最初200例,纳入随后连续1000例,以避免早期学习曲线造成的偏倚。
主要发现
- 1000例中最常见病理为垂体腺瘤(51%)、脑膜脑膨出或脑脊液漏修补(8.6%)、脑膜瘤(8.4%)、颅咽管瘤(7.3%)、基底凹陷(3.1%)、Rathke裂囊肿(2.8%)和脊索瘤(2.4%)。
- 从系列前半程到后半程,腰大池引流使用减少(p<0.05),单纯脂肪(p<0.005)或单纯垫片(p<0.005)用于硬膜闭合减少,而鼻中隔瓣使用增加(p<0.005)。
- 平均肿瘤直径保持不变(平均而言),全切除率从前半程60%升至后半程73%(p<0.005)。
- 各病理全切除率均升高,其中脊索瘤后半程100% vs 前半程56%(p<0.05),颅咽管瘤后半程71% vs 前半程47%(p<0.05),垂体腺瘤后半程75% vs 前半程67%(p<0.05)。
- 分泌性腺瘤激素治愈率从前半程83%升至后半程89%(p<0.05)。
关键数值与推荐
- 任何并发症发生率前半程6.4% vs 后半程6.2%,无变化;血管损伤仅占0.6%。
- 术后脑脊液漏发生率为2%,系列前半程与后半程之间无变化。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Endoscopic endonasal approaches (EEAs) to the skull base have evolved over the last 20 years to become an essential component of a comprehensive skull base practice. Many case series show a learning curve from the earliest cases, in which the authors were inexperienced or were not using advanced closure techniques. It is generally accepted that once this learning curve is achieved, a plateau is reached with little incremental improvement. Cases performed during the early steep learning curve were eliminated to examine whether the continued improvement exists over the "tail end" of the curve. METHODS: A prospectively acquired database of all EEA cases performed by the senior authors at Weill Cornell Medicine/NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital was reviewed. The first 200 cases were eliminated and the next 1000 consecutive cases were examined to avoid the bias created by the early learning curve. RESULTS: Of the 1000 cases, the most common pathologies included pituitary adenoma (51%), meningoencephalocele or CSF leak repair (8.6%), meningioma (8.4%), craniopharyngioma (7.3%), basilar invagination (3.1%), Rathke's cleft cyst (2.8%), and chordoma (2.4%). Use of lumbar drains decreased from the first half to the second half of our series (p <0.05) as did the authors' use of fat alone (p <0.005) or gasket alone (p <0.005) for dural closure, while the use of a nasoseptal flap increased (p <0.005). Although mean tumor diameter was constant (on average), gross-total resection (GTR) increased from 60% in the first half to 73% in the second half (p <0.005). GTR increased for all pathologies but most significantly for chordoma (56% vs 100%, p <0.05), craniopharyngioma (47% vs 0.71%, p <0.05) and pituitary adenoma (67% vs 75%, p <0.05). Hormonal cure for secreting adenomas also increased from 83% in the first half to 89% in the second half (p <0.05). The rate of any complication was unchanged at 6.4% in the first half and 6.2% in the latter half of cases, and vascular injury occurred in only 0.6% of cases. Postoperative CSF leak occurred in 2% of cases and was unchanged between the first and second half of the series. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates that contrary to popular belief, the surgical learning curve does not plateau but can continue for several years depending on the complexity of the endpoints considered. These findings may have implications for clinical trial design, surgical education, and patient safety measures.
引用
- Younus I, Gerges MM, Uribe-Cardenas R, et al. How long is the tail end of the learning curve? Results from 1000 consecutive endoscopic endonasal skull base cases following the initial 200 cases. J Neurosurg. 2020. PMID: 32032942. doi:10.3171/2019.12.JNS192600
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。