脊髓脑膜瘤硬膜切除的肿瘤学获益:Simpson分级与复发率的荟萃分析
该系统分析纳入32项研究共896例脊髓脑膜瘤患者,比较不同Simpson分级切除的复发率与并发症。结果显示Simpson I级与II级切除的复发率无显著差异(OR 1.43,95%CI 0.61-3.39,p=0.43),但I级切除的手术相关并发症(OR 4.75,95%CI 1.27-17.8,p=0.021)和新发意外神经功能缺损(OR ∞,95%CI NaN-∞,p=0.009)均显著高于II级。作者以低置信度认为两级的复发率相当,但需进一步长期研究。
要点
- Simpson I级与II级切除的脊髓脑膜瘤复发率无显著差异(OR 1.43,95%CI 0.61-3.39,p=0.43)。
- Simpson I级切除的手术相关并发症风险显著高于II级(OR 4.75,95%CI 1.27-17.8,p=0.021)。
- Simpson I级切除的新发意外术后神经功能缺损风险显著高于II级(OR ∞,95%CI NaN-∞,p=0.009)。
核心结论
- 本分析以低置信度提示,脊髓脑膜瘤Simpson I级切除的并发症和新发意外神经功能缺损率高于II级切除,且两级切除的复发率相当,但需进一步长期研究才能得出可靠结论。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索PubMed/Medline数据库,纳入描述脊髓脑膜瘤Simpson I、II、III或IV级切除后肿瘤学和临床结局的研究,共32项研究、896例患者。
主要发现
- Simpson I级、II级、III/IV级切除分别占27.5%、64.6%、7.9%。
- Simpson I级、II级、III/IV级切除的平均影像学随访时间分别为99.3±46.4个月、95.4±57.1个月、82.4±49.3个月,复发率分别为2.8%、4.1%、39.4%。
- Simpson I级与II级切除的复发率无显著差异(OR 1.43,95%CI 0.61-3.39,p=0.43)。
- 7项直接比较Simpson I级与II级切除复发率的研究的荟萃分析显示,I级切除较II级切除复发可能性有降低趋势,但未达统计学显著(OR 0.56,95%CI 0.23-1.36,p=0.20)。
- 与Simpson II级切除相比,Simpson I级切除的手术相关并发症风险(OR 4.75,95%CI 1.27-17.8,p=0.021)和新发意外术后神经功能缺损风险(OR ∞,95%CI NaN-∞,p=0.009)均显著更高。
局限性
- 作者指出需进一步长期研究才能得出可靠结论。
- 作者以低置信度呈现结论。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: While resection of the dural attachment has been shown by Simpson and others to reduce recurrence rates for intracranial meningiomas, the oncological benefit of dural resection for spinal meningiomas is less clear. The authors performed a systematic analysis of the literature, comparing recurrence rates for patients undergoing various Simpson grade resections of spinal meningiomas to better understand the role of dural resection on outcomes after resection of spinal meningiomas. METHODS: The PubMed/Medline database was systematically searched to identify studies describing oncological and clinical outcomes after Simpson grade I, II, III, or IV resections of spinal meningiomas. RESULTS: Thirty-two studies describing the outcomes of 896 patients were included in the analysis. Simpson grade I, grade II, and grade III/IV resections were performed in 27.5%, 64.6%, and 7.9% of cases, respectively. The risk of procedure-related complications (OR 4.75, 95% CI 1.27-17.8, p = 0.021) and new, unexpected postoperative neurological deficits (OR ∞, 95% CI NaN-∞, p = 0.009) were both significantly greater for patients undergoing Simpson grade I resections when compared with those undergoing Simpson grade II resections. Tumor recurrence was seen in 2.8%, 4.1%, and 39.4% of patients undergoing Simpson grade I, grade II, and grade III/IV resections over a mean radiographic follow-up period of 99.3 ± 46.4 months, 95.4 ± 57.1 months, and 82.4 ± 49.3 months, respectively. No significant difference was detected between the recurrence rates for Simpson grade I versus Simpson grade II resections (OR 1.43, 95% CI 0.61-3.39, p = 0.43). A meta-analysis of 7 studies directly comparing recurrence rates for Simpson grade I and II resections demonstrated a trend toward a decreased likelihood of recurrence after Simpson grade I resection when compared with Simpson grade II resection, although this trend did not reach statistical significance (OR 0.56, 95% CI 0.23-1.36, p = 0.20). CONCLUSIONS: The results of this analysis suggest with a low level of confidence that the rates of complications and new, unexpected neurological deficits after Simpson grade I resection of spinal meningiomas are greater than those seen with Simpson grade II resections, and that the recurrence rates for Simpson grade I and grade II resections are equivalent, although additional, long-term studies are needed before reliable conclusions may be drawn.
引用
- Barber SM, Konakondla S, Nakhla J, et al. Oncologic benefits of dural resection in spinal meningiomas: a meta-analysis of Simpson grades and recurrence rates. J Neurosurg Spine. 2019. PMID: 31703204. doi:10.3171/2019.8.SPINE19859
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。