大脑中动脉动脉瘤夹闭优先与栓塞优先策略的比较
本研究比较了两个中心分别采用夹闭优先和栓塞优先策略治疗大脑中动脉动脉瘤的结果,共治疗187个动脉瘤(栓塞88个,夹闭99个)。在破裂和未破裂动脉瘤中,两种治疗方式的并发症率、功能结局和死亡风险相似,但夹闭组的完全闭塞率更高(84.2% vs 31%),栓塞组2年内再治疗风险更高(p=0.04)。
要点
- 夹闭优先与栓塞优先策略治疗大脑中动脉动脉瘤的临床结局相似。
- 夹闭组完全闭塞率84.2%,高于栓塞组的31%。
- 栓塞组2年内动脉瘤再治疗风险更高(p=0.04)。
核心结论
- 夹闭和栓塞治疗大脑中动脉动脉瘤在破裂和未破裂病例中提供相同的临床结局。
- 夹闭提供更高的短期和长期完全闭塞率,从而降低动脉瘤再治疗风险。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性比较两个中心2012年1月至2015年12月治疗的大脑中动脉动脉瘤患者,一个中心采用夹闭优先策略,另一个采用栓塞优先策略。
- 共治疗187个动脉瘤,其中栓塞88个,夹闭99个。
主要发现
- 破裂动脉瘤队列(n=90)中,栓塞组额外手术率更高,但并发症率、功能结局和死亡风险两组相似。
- 未破裂动脉瘤队列(n=97)中,并发症率、功能结局和死亡风险两组相似,但手术组颞肌萎缩相关不适风险更高。
- 总体完全闭塞率夹闭组为84.2%,栓塞组为31%,栓塞组2年内再治疗风险更高(p=0.04)。
临床怎么用
- 对于大脑中动脉动脉瘤,夹闭和栓塞均可作为治疗选择,临床结局相似。
- 若追求更高的完全闭塞率和更低的再治疗风险,夹闭可能更有优势。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计。
- 栓塞组完全闭塞率较低对长期临床影响需进一步评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Middle cerebral artery (MCA) aneurysms are a particular subset of intracranial aneurysms that can be excluded by clipping or coiling. A comparison of the results between these two methods is often limited by a selection bias in which wide-neck and large aneurysms are frequently treated with surgery. Here, the authors report the results of two centers using opposing policies in the management of MCA aneurysms: one center used a clip-first policy while the other used a coil-first policy, which limited the selection bias and ensured a good comparison of these two treatment modalities. METHODS: All patients treated for either ruptured or unruptured MCA aneurysms at one of two institutions between January 2012 and December 2015 were eligible for inclusion in this study. At one center a clip-first policy was applied, whereas the other applied a coil-first policy. The authors retrospectively reviewed the medical records of these patients and compared their clinical and radiological outcomes. RESULTS: A total of 187 aneurysms were treated during the inclusion period; 88 aneurysms were treated by coiling and 99 aneurysms by clipping. The baseline patient and radiological characteristics were similar between the two groups, but the clinical presentation of the ruptured aneurysm cohort differed slightly. In the ruptured cohort (n = 90), although patients in the coiling group had a higher rate of additional surgery, the complication rate, functional outcome, and risk of death were similar between the two treatment groups. In the unruptured cohort (n = 97), the complication rate, functional outcome, and risk of death were also similar between the two treatment groups, although the risk of discomfort related to the temporal muscle atrophy was higher in the surgical group. Overall, the rate of complete occlusion was higher in the clipping group (84.2%) than in the coiling group (31%), which led to a higher risk in the coiling group of aneurysm retreatment within the first 2 years (p = 0.04). CONCLUSIONS: Clipping and coiling for MCA aneurysm treatment provide the same clinical outcome for ruptured and unruptured aneurysms. However, clipping provides higher short- and long-term rates of complete exclusion, which in turn decreases the risk of aneurysm retreatment. Whether this lower occlusion rate can have a clinical impact in the long-term must be further evaluated.
引用
- Berro DH, L'Allinec V, Pasco-Papon A, et al. Clip-first policy versus coil-first policy for the exclusion of middle cerebral artery aneurysms. J Neurosurg. 2019. PMID: 31597117. doi:10.3171/2019.5.JNS19373
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。