术前常规MRI预测脑膜瘤高级别组织学与复发
本文系统综述术前常规MRI特征与脑膜瘤高级别组织学及复发的关系,纳入35项研究并以QUADAS标准评价质量。结果显示非颅底位置、囊变、不均匀强化、形态不规则及肿瘤/脑边界破坏多与WHO II/III级相关,而肿瘤与水肿大小多与复发相关,但各研究结果部分不一致。
要点
- 非颅底位置、囊变、不均匀强化、形态不规则及肿瘤/脑边界破坏多与高级别组织学相关。
- 肿瘤大小与瘤周水肿大小多与复发相关,但不均匀强化、囊变、T2信号及瘤壁强化多与进展无关。
- 各研究质量差异大,MRI变量与组织学及预后之间的关联并不一致,需标准化研究进一步明确。
核心结论
- 术前常规MRI的若干变量与脑膜瘤高级别组织学或预后相关,但结果部分不一致,考虑这些发现有助于改善预后评估和术后管理。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,纳入35项关于术前MRI表现与高级别组织学及复发相关性的研究,并使用QUADAS标准评价纳入研究质量。
主要发现
- 多数研究中非颅底肿瘤位置、囊形成、不均匀对比强化、肿瘤形态不规则及肿瘤/脑边界破坏与II/III级组织学相关,而T2加权像病变强度、钙化或骨受累未显示该关联。
- 肿瘤大小和水肿大小通常与复发相关,但不均匀对比强化、囊形成、T2加权MRI肿瘤强度及肿瘤包膜强化多与进展无关。
- 肿瘤大小、瘤周水肿大小及肿瘤包膜对比强化与高级别组织学的相关性存在争议。
- 依据QUADAS标准,各系列研究质量差异很大。
- 与高级别组织学相关的MRI变量通常并不一致地与预后相关,反之亦然。
临床怎么用
- 临床可参考非颅底位置、囊变、不均匀强化、形态不规则及肿瘤/脑边界破坏等术前MRI特征辅助预估脑膜瘤高级别组织学风险。
- 肿瘤大小与瘤周水肿大小可辅助评估复发风险,但不宜单独依据不均匀强化、囊变、T2信号或瘤壁强化判断进展。
- 因证据部分不一致,MRI变量应结合其他临床信息综合用于预后评估与术后管理。
局限性
- 纳入研究的方法学质量按QUADAS标准差异很大。
- 多个MRI变量与高级别组织学或预后的相关性在不同研究间存在争议或不一致。
- 原文指出仍需标准化研究以进一步明确相关变量。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Estimating the risk of recurrence after surgery remains crucial during care of patients with meningioma. Numerous studies identified correlations of characteristics on routine preoperative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with postoperative recurrence or high-grade histology but showed partially inconclusive results. METHODS: A systematic review of the literature was performed about findings on preoperative MRI and their correlation with high-grade histology and recurrence. Quality of the included studies was analyzed using standardized Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies criteria. RESULTS: Among the 35 studies included, quality of the series according to the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies criteria differed widely. Remarkably, MRI variables found to be associated with high-grade histology were commonly not consistently associated with prognosis and vice versa. Correlations of the tumor size, the peritumoral edema size, and contrast-enhancement of the tumor capsule with high-grade histology were controversial. In most studies, non-skull base tumor location, cyst formation, heterogenous contrast-enhancement, an irregular tumor shape, and disruption of the tumor/brain border but not intensity of the lesion on T2-weighted images, calcifications, or bone involvement were associated with grade II/III histology. Although tumor and edema size were usually found to correlate with recurrence, heterogenous contrast enhancement, cyst formation, intensity of the tumor on T2-weighted MRI, and enhancement of the tumor capsule were mostly not related with progression. CONCLUSIONS: Several mostly consistent but partially inconsistent variables associated with high-grade histology or prognosis were identified. Although standardized studies are needed to provide further clarification, consideration of these findings can help to improve estimation of prognosis and can therefore improve postoperative care in patients with meningioma.
引用
- Spille DC, Sporns PB, Heß K, et al. Prediction of High-Grade Histology and Recurrence in Meningiomas Using Routine Preoperative Magnetic Resonance Imaging: A Systematic Review. World Neurosurg. 2019. PMID: 31082555. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2019.05.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。