当代疼痛外科概念综述
本文综述了疼痛外科的当代概念,回顾过去50年作为亚专科的成功与失败经验,涉及癌痛、伤害性疼痛和神经病理性疼痛。作者基于证据评估了各类毁损性手术、电刺激和神经调控方法,提出应继续、放弃或进一步研究的具体术式,并指出未来挑战是获取更高级别证据。
要点
- 三叉神经痛的毁损性手术应继续开展,而脊神经根切断术等应放弃
- 脊髓切开术是癌痛控制的重要且未被充分利用的方法
- 运动皮层刺激应被放弃,深部脑刺激可能对特定疼痛有效
核心结论
- 疼痛外科需在继承历史基础上发展,修复性手术有望找到位置,未来挑战是获取更高级别证据支持临床实践。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为综述,回顾疼痛外科作为神经外科亚专科50年来的成功与失败经验,并展望当前与未来实践。
主要发现
- 小样本病例系列显示扣带回切开术、垂体切除术和中脑切开术有令人鼓舞的结果,但需进一步详细分析。
- 高频脊髓电刺激、爆发式脊髓电刺激和背根神经节刺激可能或未必比传统脊髓电刺激更有效。
- 尽管有失败历史,深部脑刺激治疗疼痛仍可能被证明对特定疼痛状况有效。
关键数值与推荐
- 非癌痛:背根入区毁损和三叉神经痛神经根切断术应继续实践;内侧丘脑切开术未证明有效需继续研究;背根神经切断术、背根神经节切除术和神经切断术应放弃。
- 癌痛:脊髓切开术是重要且未被充分利用的疼痛控制方法;经植入系统鞘内注射阿片类药物仍是重要选择。
- 神经调控:运动皮层刺激应放弃;枕神经痛和三叉神经病理性疼痛可行周围神经刺激,但结局数据质量存挑战。
临床怎么用
- 临床决策应依据现有证据选择应继续、放弃或进一步研究的疼痛外科术式,并优先采用证据支持的方法。
局限性
- 疼痛外科领域缺乏高级别证据,多数术式基于小样本病例系列,需未来研究加以验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Pain surgery is one of the historic foundations of neurological surgery. The authors present a review of contemporary concepts in surgical pain management, with reference to past successes and failures, what has been learned as a subspecialty over the past 50 years, as well as a vision for current and future practice. This subspecialty confronts problems of cancer pain, nociceptive pain, and neuropathic pain. For noncancer pain, ablative procedures such as dorsal root entry zone lesions and rhizolysis for trigeminal neuralgia (TN) should continue to be practiced. Other procedures, such as medial thalamotomy, have not been proven effective and require continued study. Dorsal rhizotomy, dorsal root ganglionectomy, and neurotomy should probably be abandoned. For cancer pain, cordotomy is an important and underutilized method for pain control. Intrathecal opiate administration via an implantable system remains an important option for cancer pain management. While there are encouraging results in small case series, cingulotomy, hypophysectomy, and mesencephalotomy deserve further detailed analysis. Electrical neuromodulation is a rapidly changing discipline, and new methods such as high-frequency spinal cord stimulation (SCS), burst SCS, and dorsal root ganglion stimulation may or may not prove to be more effective than conventional SCS. Despite a history of failure, deep brain stimulation for pain may yet prove to be an effective therapy for specific pain conditions. Peripheral nerve stimulation for conditions such as occipital neuralgia and trigeminal neuropathic pain remains an option, although the quality of outcomes data is a challenge to these applications. Based on the evidence, motor cortex stimulation should be abandoned. TN is a mainstay of the surgical treatment of pain, particularly as new evidence and insights into TN emerge. Pain surgery will continue to build on this heritage, and restorative procedures will likely find a role in the armamentarium. The challenge for the future will be to acquire higher-level evidence to support the practice of surgical pain management.
引用
- Burchiel KJ, Raslan AM. Contemporary concepts of pain surgery. J Neurosurg. 2019. PMID: 30933905. doi:10.3171/2019.1.JNS181620
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。