根据SLICS和TLICS系统评估创伤性脊柱骨折手术实践:威斯康星大学58例回顾
该研究回顾了1999至2013年威斯康星大学医院与诊所创伤数据库中因树架坠落导致的脊柱和脊髓损伤病例,由神经外科医生和神经放射科医生独立评定TLICS和SLICS评分。结果显示,按管理建议分组时,SLICS评分者间一致性为12/15(80%),TLICS为38/52(73%)。SLICS的阳性预测值达100%但置信区间宽,阴性预测值较差为54%-60%;TLICS的阳性预测值分别为77.8%和93.3%,阴性预测值分别为93.9%和89.2%。结论认为TLICS和SLICS评分者间信度良好至优秀,SLICS有效性差,TLICS对非手术病例合理、对手术病例中等。
要点
- SLICS评分者间一致性为12/15(80%),TLICS为38/52(73%)。
- SLICS阳性预测值100%,阴性预测值54%-60%。
- TLICS阳性预测值77.8%和93.3%,阴性预测值93.9%和89.2%。
核心结论
- TLICS和SLICS系统提供良好至优秀的评分者间信度,SLICS有效性差,TLICS对非手术病例合理、对手术病例中等。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析1999至2013年威斯康星大学医院与诊所创伤数据库中因树架坠落导致的脊柱和脊髓损伤病例,由一名神经外科医生和一名神经放射科医生独立评定TLICS和SLICS评分。
主要发现
- 按管理建议(手术、不确定、非手术)分组,SLICS评分者间一致性为12/15(80%),TLICS为38/52(73%)。
- SLICS阳性预测值达100%但置信区间宽,阴性预测值较差为54%-60%,非手术评分患者常接受手术治疗。
- TLICS阳性预测值分别为77.8%和93.3%,阴性预测值分别为93.9%和89.2%。
临床怎么用
- TLICS和SLICS系统可能最适合在教育环境中用于确认骨折形态和韧带损伤存在与否。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Spine surgeons at a Level 1 Trauma Center have observed a high incidence of spine and spinal cord injuries owing to falls from tree stands. These injuries have been retrospectively reviewed in the context of the Thoracolumbar Injury Classification and Severity (TLICS) and the Subaxial Cervical Injury Classification and Severity (SLICS) classification systems to assess inter-user reliability and validity. We hypothesize that the inter-rater reliability will be similar between neuroradiology and neurosurgery raters and validity of the scoring system will be maintained at our institution. METHODS: The University of Wisconsin Hospital and Clinics' trauma database was reviewed for tree stand-related injuries from 1999 to 2013, with a focus on patients suffering from spine and spinal cord injuries. The TLICS and SLICS scores were then independently determined for these injuries by a neurosurgeon and a neuroradiologist. RESULTS: When cases were grouped by management recommendation (operative, equivocal, and nonoperative) reviewer agreement was 12/15 (80%) of SLICS and 38/52 (73%) of TLICS scores. Operative SLICS positive predictive value reached 100%, however, with a wide confidence interval. Conversely, the SLICS negative predictive value was poor at 54%-60%, with frequent operative treatment for patients assigned nonoperative scores. TLICS scores reached 77.8% and 93.3% positive predictive value per reviewer, whereas negative predictive values reached 93.9% and 89.2%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The TLICS and SLICS systems provide good-to-excellent inter-rater reliability. SLICS validity was poor, whereas TLICS was reasonable for nonoperative cases and moderate for operative cases. Systems such as the TLICS and the SLICS may be best applied in the educational setting to confirm the fracture morphology and presence or absence of ligamentous injury between surgeons and radiologists.
引用
- Hamilton K, Josiah DT, Tierney M, et al. Surgical Practice in Traumatic Spinal Fracture Treatment with Regard to the Subaxial Cervical Injury Classification and Severity and the Thoracolumbar Injury Classification and Severity Systems: A Review of 58 Patients at the University of Wisconsin. World Neurosurg. 2019. PMID: 30851463. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2019.02.141
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。