额底脑膜瘤术后颅神经结局:最大安全切除与最低并发症的永恒追求
本研究基于2009年2月至2017年4月在本机构接受额底脑膜瘤切除的195例患者,按Simpson分级分层分析术后新发颅神经功能缺损与脑脊液漏。结果显示Simpson I级切除(含硬膜尾切除)术后即刻新发颅神经缺损率30%,高于Simpson II级的13%(P=0.007)和Simpson II-V级的17%(P=0.035);12个月随访时分别为29%、6%(P<0.001)和10%(P=0.001)。术后脑脊液漏在Simpson I级为10.1%,Simpson II级为2.3%(P=0.048)。两组再治疗率无差异(2.5% vs 3.4%;P=1.000)。作者认为对额底脑膜瘤应优先选择较不激进的切除方式。
要点
- Simpson I级切除术后即刻新发颅神经缺损率为30%,高于Simpson II级的13%和Simpson II-V级的17%。
- 12个月随访时新发颅神经缺损率Simpson I级为29%,Simpson II级为6%,Simpson II-V级为10%。
- 术后脑脊液漏发生率Simpson I级为10.1%,Simpson II级为2.3%,再治疗率两组无差异。
核心结论
- 作者认为,对额底脑膜瘤行包括邻近硬膜在内的根治性切除后,新发颅神经并发症和脑脊液漏发生率较高,因此应优先选择较不激进的切除方式。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为单中心回顾性分析,纳入2009年2月至2017年4月在本机构接受额底脑膜瘤切除的195例患者。
- 按切除程度将患者分为Simpson I级切除(含硬膜尾切除的激进手术方式)与Simpson II-V级切除两组,分层分析术后新发颅神经功能缺损和脑脊液漏。
主要发现
- 术后即刻新发颅神经缺损率:Simpson I级为30%,高于Simpson II级的13%(P=0.007)和Simpson II-V级的17%(P=0.035)。
- 12个月随访时新发颅神经缺损率:Simpson I级为29%,高于Simpson II级的6%(P<0.001)和Simpson II-V级的10%(P=0.001)。
- 术后脑脊液漏发生率:Simpson I级为10.1%,高于Simpson II级的2.3%(P=0.048)。
- 再治疗率在Simpson I级与Simpson II级之间无差异(2.5% vs 3.4%;P=1.000)。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议,对额底脑膜瘤应优先选择较不激进的切除方式,而非包括邻近硬膜在内的根治性切除。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Maximal aggressive meningioma resection has been suggested to provide the best tumor control rates. However, radical surgery of meningiomas located at the frontal skull base can be accompanied by impairment of adjacent cranial nerve function that negatively affects patients' quality of life. We, therefore, analyzed our institutional database for cases of new cranial nerve deficits and postoperative cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leakage stratified by the extent of tumor resection. METHODS: From February 2009 to April 2017, 195 patients underwent resection of frontal skull base meningioma at our institution. Postoperative new deficits of cranial nerve function and CSF leakage were stratified by the resection into Simpson grade I resection with excision of the dural tail as an aggressive surgical approach and Simpson grade II-V resection. RESULTS: Simpson grade I resection was associated with a significantly greater percentage of new cranial nerve deficits immediately after surgery (30%) compared with Simpson grade II (13%; P = 0.007) and Simpson grade II-V (17%; P = 0.035). The differences were greater at the 12-month follow-up point (29% Simpson grade I, 6% Simpson grade II [P < 0.001]; 10% Simpson grade II-V [P = 0.001]). Postoperative CSF leakage occurred in 10.1% of Simpson grade I versus 2.3% of Simpson grade II resections (P = 0.048). The retreatment rates did not differ between these 2 groups (2.5% vs. 3.4%; P = 1.000). CONCLUSIONS: We found high levels of new cranial nerve morbidity and CSF leakage after radical removal of frontal skull base meningiomas that included the adjacent dura. Thus, less aggressive surgery for frontobasal meningioma should be preferred.
引用
- Schneider M, Schuss P, Güresir Á, et al. Cranial Nerve Outcomes After Surgery for Frontal Skull Base Meningiomas: The Eternal Quest of the Maximum-Safe Resection with the Lowest Morbidity. World Neurosurg. 2019. PMID: 30738945. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2019.01.171
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。