文献速递脑血管病外科神经肿瘤

虚拟现实血管造影与三维打印血管造影作为教育工具的比较研究

Virtual Reality Angiogram vs 3-Dimensional Printed Angiogram as an Educational tool-A Comparative Study.
PubMed 文献 · Neurosurgery · 2019-01-01

本研究通过开发并测试一款虚拟现实(VR)智能手机应用,让10名来自澳大利亚和新西兰的神经外科受训者使用3个三维打印和VR血管造影模型完成两部分互动练习并填写问卷,另由一名合格神经外科医生进行15次VR血管造影模型操作练习以探究学习曲线效应。结果显示VR血管造影在分辨率、缩放能力、模型耐用性和教育潜力方面具有统计学显著优势,而三维打印模型在深度感知和操作便捷性方面具有统计学显著优势。作者认为在立体深度感知有帮助的复杂脑血管解剖病例中,VR血管造影应被考虑作为三维打印模型的可行替代方案用于神经外科培训和术前规划。

要点

  • VR血管造影在分辨率、缩放能力、模型耐用性和教育潜力方面优于三维打印模型。
  • 三维打印模型在深度感知和操作便捷性方面具有统计学显著优势。
  • 在立体深度感知有帮助的复杂脑血管解剖病例中,VR血管造影应被考虑作为三维打印模型的可行替代方案。

核心结论

  • 在立体深度感知有帮助的复杂脑血管解剖病例中,VR血管造影应被考虑作为三维打印模型的可行替代方案用于神经外科培训和术前规划。
  • 沉浸式虚拟环境提供出色的分辨率和缩放能力,使其成为尚未开发的潜在教育工具。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究通过开发和测试一款VR智能手机应用引入VR血管造影。
  • 10名来自澳大利亚和新西兰的神经外科受训者参与使用3个三维打印和VR血管造影模型的两部分互动练习,随后填写关于体验的问卷。
  • 在另一项探究学习曲线效应的练习中,一名合格神经外科医生进行了15次涉及操作VR血管造影模型的练习。

主要发现

  • VR血管造影在分辨率方面优于三维打印模型。
  • VR血管造影在缩放能力、分辨率、操作便捷性、模型耐用性和教育潜力方面具有统计学显著优势。
  • VR血管造影的问卷总分高于三维打印模型。
  • 三维打印模型在深度感知和操作便捷性方面具有统计学显著优势。
  • 结果与受训者年级、测试顺序或解剖结构无关。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,在立体深度感知有帮助的复杂脑血管解剖病例中,VR血管造影应被考虑作为三维打印模型的可行替代方案用于神经外科培训和术前规划。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Three-dimensional (3D) visualization of the neurovascular structures has helped preoperative surgical planning. 3D printed models and virtual reality (VR) devices are 2 options to improve 3D stereovision and stereoscopic depth perception of cerebrovascular anatomy for aneurysm surgery. OBJECTIVE: To investigate and compare the practicality and potential of 3D printed and VR models in a neurosurgical education context. METHODS: The VR angiogram was introduced through the development and testing of a VR smartphone app. Ten neurosurgical trainees from Australia and New Zealand participated in a 2-part interactive exercise using 3 3D printed and VR angiogram models followed by a questionnaire about their experience. In a separate exercise to investigate the learning curve effect on VR angiogram application, a qualified neurosurgeon was subjected to 15 exercises involving manipulating VR angiograms models. RESULTS: VR angiogram outperformed 3D printed model in terms of resolution. It had statistically significant advantage in ability to zoom, resolution, ease of manipulation, model durability, and educational potential. VR angiogram had a higher questionnaire total score than 3D models. The 3D printed models had a statistically significant advantage in depth perception and ease of manipulation. The results were independent of trainee year level, sequence of the tests, or anatomy. CONCLUSION: In selected cases with challenging cerebrovascular anatomy where stereoscopic depth perception is helpful, VR angiogram should be considered as a viable alternative to the 3D printed models for neurosurgical training and preoperative planning. An immersive virtual environment offers excellent resolution and ability to zoom, potentiating it as an untapped educational tool.

来源:Neurosurgery,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bairamian D, Liu S, Eftekhar B, et al. Virtual Reality Angiogram vs 3-Dimensional Printed Angiogram as an Educational tool-A Comparative Study. Neurosurgery. 2019. PMID: 30715444. doi:10.1093/neuros/nyz003

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。