床旁螺栓外引流与手术室隧道式外引流的安全性、准确性和成本效益比较
该回顾性队列研究比较了2010年1月至2015年12月期间579例首次额部外引流(EVD)患者中床旁螺栓EVD(149例)与手术室隧道式EVD(430例)的指征、准确性、安全性和成本。结果显示两组导管尖端理想位置比例(66.4% vs 61.0%,P=0.33)和感染率(10.0% vs 14.2%,P=0.2)无显著差异;螺栓EVD套件成本260英镑,而手术室隧道式EVD置入成本1316英镑。作者认为,在选择性出血相关脑积水患者中,床旁螺栓EVD置入安全、准确且具有成本效益。
要点
- 床旁螺栓EVD与手术室隧道式EVD在导管尖端理想位置比例上无显著差异(66.4% vs 61.0%,P=0.33)。
- 两组感染率无显著差异(螺栓组10.0% vs 隧道组14.2%,P=0.2)。
- 螺栓EVD套件成本260英镑,手术室隧道式EVD置入成本1316英镑。
核心结论
- 作者认为,在选择性出血相关脑积水患者中,床旁螺栓EVD置入安全、准确且具有成本效益。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,基于前瞻性维护的EVD数据库,纳入2010年1月至2015年12月期间所有首次额部EVD置入患者,排除既往有脑脊液感染者。
- 共纳入579例 eligible 患者,年龄3个月至84岁;其中430例接受隧道式EVD,149例接受螺栓EVD。
主要发现
- 螺栓EVD组66.4%的导管尖端位置理想,隧道式EVD组为61.0%(P=0.33)。
- 螺栓EVD组感染确诊15例(10.0%),隧道式EVD组61例(14.2%)(P=0.2)。
- 最常见诊断为颅内出血(螺栓组73% vs 隧道组50.4%;P<0.001),其他诊断包括肿瘤(螺栓组4.7% vs 隧道组19.1%;P<0.001)和创伤性脑损伤(螺栓组17.5% vs 隧道组17.4%)。
- 每个螺栓EVD套件成本260英镑,而手术室置入隧道式EVD成本1316英镑。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: External ventricular drain (EVD) placement is required frequently in neurosurgical patients to divert cerebrospinal fluid and monitor intracranial pressure. The usual practice is the tunneled EVD technique performed in operating theaters. EVD insertion through a bolt in intensive care also is described. We employ both practices in our institute. Herein, we compare the indications, accuracy, safety, and costs of the 2 techniques. METHODS: This was a retrospective cohort study of a prospectively maintained EVD database of all patients undergoing first frontal EVD placement between January 2010 and December 2015. Those patients with preceding cerebrospinal fluid infection were excluded. We compared bolt EVD with tunneled EVD techniques in terms of accuracy of EVD tip location by analyzing computed tomography scans to grade catheter tip location as optimal (ipsilateral frontal horn) or otherwise suboptimal, and complications that include infection and revision rates. RESULTS: In total, 579 eligible patients aged 3 months to 84 years were identified; 430 had tunneled EVDs and 149 bolt EVDs. The most frequent diagnosis was intracranial hemorrhage (73% bolt vs. 50.4% tunneled group; P < 0.001). Other diagnoses included tumor (4.7% bolt vs. 19.1% tunneled; P < 0.001) and traumatic brain injury (17.5% bolt vs. 17.4% tunneled). In the bolt EVD group 66.4% of EVD tips were optimal, compared with 61.0% in the tunneled group (P = 0.33). Infection was confirmed in 15 (10.0%) bolt EVDs compared with 61 (14.2%) tunneled EVDs (P = 0.2). Each bolt EVD kit costs £260, whereas placing a tunneled one in the theater costs £1316. CONCLUSIONS: Bedside bolt EVD placement is safe, accurate, and cost effective in selective patients with hemorrhage-related hydrocephalus.
引用
- Roach J, Gaastra B, Bulters D, et al. Safety, Accuracy, and Cost Effectiveness of Bedside Bolt External Ventricular Drains (EVDs) in Comparison with Tunneled EVDs Inserted in Theaters. World Neurosurg. 2019. PMID: 30735879. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2019.01.106
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。