文献速递神经肿瘤

医学学术谱系与发表结局之间的关联:无意识偏见对科学客观性的影响

Association between medical academic genealogy and publication outcome: impact of unconscious bias on scientific objectivity.
PubMed 文献 · Acta Neurochir (Wien) · 2019-01-23

该研究通过检索高级别胶质瘤(HGG)手术切除文献,对108篇文章中的70篇进行Meta分析与蒙特卡洛模拟,发现不同医学学术谱系作者的文章汇总结论相互矛盾,提示学术谱系可能造成发表文献的系统性偏倚。

要点

  • 不区分学术谱系时,HGG文献Meta分析显示GTR与间变性星形细胞瘤和胶质母细胞瘤术后死亡风险降低相关。
  • 以放射肿瘤学家为主的谱系文章未显示GTR后死亡风险降低,以神经外科医生为主的谱系文章则显示显著降低。
  • 蒙特卡洛模拟显示两种谱系文章间的差异不太可能仅由偶然产生(p < 0.006)。

核心结论

  • 不同医学学术谱系作者的文章经Meta分析得出不同且相互矛盾的汇总结论,提示学术谱系对发表文献的系统性偏倚有贡献。

研究设计与样本

  • 通过全面检索高级别胶质瘤(HGG)手术切除文献共识别108篇文章,对其中数据足够进行Meta分析的70篇文章进行分析。
  • 采用Meta分析和定量统计建模,并对关键学术谱系生成汇总估计,使用蒙特卡洛模拟判断仅由谱系归因的效应能否由偶然产生。

主要发现

  • 不考虑医学学术谱系时,HGG文献Meta分析显示GTR与间变性星形细胞瘤术后死亡风险比值比降低相关(log [OR] = -0.04,95% CI [-0.07至-0.01])。
  • 不考虑医学学术谱系时,HGG文献Meta分析显示GTR与胶质母细胞瘤术后死亡风险比值比降低相关(log [OR] = -0.36,95% CI [-0.44至-0.29])。
  • 对以放射肿瘤学家为主的谱系成员所贡献的胶质母细胞瘤文献进行Meta分析,未显示GTR后死亡风险降低(log [OR] = -0.16,95% CI [-0.41至0.09])。
  • 对以神经外科医生为主的谱系成员所发表的胶质母细胞瘤文献进行Meta分析,显示GTR与死亡风险显著降低相关(log [OR] = -0.29,95% CI [-0.40至0.18])。
  • 蒙特卡洛模拟显示,两个谱系成员所贡献文章之间观察到的差异不太可能仅由偶然产生(p < 0.006)。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Our previous studies suggest that the training history of an investigator, termed "medical academic genealogy", influences the outcomes of that investigator's research. Here, we use meta-analysis and quantitative statistical modeling to determine whether such effects contribute to systematic bias in published conclusions. METHODS: A total of 108 articles were identified through a comprehensive search of the high-grade glioma (HGG) surgical resection literature. Analysis was performed on the 70 articles with sufficient data for meta-analysis. Pooled estimates were generated for key academic genealogies. Monte Carlo simulations were performed to determine whether the effects attributed to genealogy alone can arise due to chance alone. RESULTS: Meta-analysis of the HGG literature without consideration for academic medical genealogy revealed that gross total resection (GTR) was associated with a significant decrease in the odds ratio (OR) for the hazard of death after surgery for both anaplastic astrocytoma (AA) and glioblastoma (AA: log [OR] = - 0.04, 95% CI [- 0.07 to - 0.01]; glioblastoma log [OR] = - 0.36, 95% CI [- 0.44 to - 0.29]). For the glioblastoma literature, meta-analysis of articles contributed by members of a genealogy consisting of mostly radiation oncologists revealed no reduction in the hazard of death after GTR [log [OR] = - 0.16, 95% CI [- 0.41 to 0.09]. In contrast, meta-analysis of published articles contributed by members of a genealogy consisting of mostly neurosurgeons revealed that GTR was associated with a significant reduction in the hazard of death [log [OR] = - 0.29, 95% CI [- 0.40 to 0.18]. Monte Carlo simulation revealed that the observed discrepancy between the articles contributed by the members of these two genealogies was unlikely to arise by chance alone (p < 0.006). CONCLUSIONS: Meta-analysis of articles contributed by authors belonging to the different medical academic genealogies yielded distinct and contradictory pooled point-estimates, suggesting that genealogy contributes to systematic bias in the published literature.

来源:Acta Neurochir (Wien),查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hirshman BR, Alattar AA, Dhawan S, et al. Association between medical academic genealogy and publication outcome: impact of unconscious bias on scientific objectivity. Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2019. PMID: 30673844. doi:10.1007/s00701-019-03804-9

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。