多脑叶切除术治疗3T MRI阴性癫痫:值得吗?
本研究回顾性分析4例3T MRI阴性药物难治性局灶性癫痫患者在本机构接受多脑叶癫痫手术的数据。末次随访(中位3.3年)时,2例完全无发作(Engel Ia),1例Engel Ic,1例Engel IIb,无手术并发症。作者认为多脑叶癫痫手术对经选择的3T MRI阴性候选者可有效持久控制发作,全面多模态术前评估是术后成功的前提,发作复发患者应考虑再评估,因再手术可能对初始局限切除无反应的部分患者特别有益。
要点
- 4例3T MRI阴性药物难治性局灶性癫痫患者接受多脑叶切除术,末次随访中位3.3年时2例完全无发作(Engel Ia)。
- 1例Engel Ic,1例Engel IIb,无手术并发症。
- 作者认为全面多模态术前评估是术后成功的前提,发作复发患者应考虑再评估。
核心结论
- 作者认为多脑叶癫痫手术对经选择的3T MRI阴性候选者可有效持久控制发作,本组全部4例均获良好结局。
- 作者认为全面多模态术前评估是术后成功的前提。
- 作者认为发作复发患者应考虑再评估,因再手术可能对初始局限切除无反应的部分患者特别有益。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析4例连续在本机构接受多脑叶癫痫手术、3T MRI阴性且为药物难治性局灶性癫痫患者的数据。
主要发现
- 首次手术平均年龄28.5岁(范围14-48),1例需2次连续再手术。
- 最终切除范围分别为额颞区和颞-顶-枕区各2例。
- 组织病理学显示轻度皮质发育畸形2例,局灶性皮质发育不良Ia型和IIa型各1例。
- 末次随访(中位3.3年,范围1-11)时,2例完全无发作(Engel Ia),1例术后曾有致残性发作但末次随访前已2年无致残性发作(Engel Ic),1例有值得的改善(Engel IIb)且末次随访前已1年无发作。
- 无手术并发症发生。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为多脑叶癫痫手术对经选择的3T MRI阴性候选者可有效持久控制发作。
- 作者认为全面多模态术前评估是术后成功的前提。
- 作者认为发作复发患者应考虑再评估,因再手术可能对初始局限切除无反应的部分患者特别有益。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Multilobar resection in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-negative drug-resistant epilepsy warrants attention because they account for up to one third of MRI-negative epilepsy surgery. Despite their high prevalence, data are sparse, and the risk/benefit ratio continues to be debated. The present study investigated the postoperative seizure outcomes in this especially challenging subgroup. METHODS: We retrospectively analyzed the data of 4 consecutive patients with 3T MRI-negative findings and drug-resistant focal epilepsy who had undergone multilobar epilepsy surgery at our institution. RESULTS: The mean age at first surgery was 28.5 years (range, 14-48); 1 patient required 2 consecutive reoperations. The final resection was in the frontotemporal and temporo-parieto-occipital regions in 2 patients each. Histopathological examination revealed mild malformations of cortical development in 2 patients and focal cortical dysplasia type Ia and type IIa in 1 patient each. At the last follow-up examination (median, 3.3 years; range, 1-11), 2 patients were completely seizure free (Engel class Ia), 1 patient had experienced some disabling seizures after surgery but had been free of disabling seizures for 2 years at the last follow-up examination (Engel class Ic), and 1 patient had experienced worthwhile improvement (Engel class IIb) and had been seizure free for 1 year at the last follow-up examination. No surgical complications developed. CONCLUSIONS: Our results have demonstrated that multilobar epilepsy surgery is effective for lasting seizure control for selected 3T MRI-negative candidates, leading to favorable outcomes for all 4 of our patients. Comprehensive multimodal preoperative evaluation is a prerequisite for postoperative success. Reevaluation should be considered for patients with seizure recurrence, because reoperation could be especially beneficial for selected patients who have not responded to an initially limited resection.
引用
- Kogias E, Schmeiser B, Doostkam S, et al. Multilobar Resections for 3T MRI-Negative Epilepsy: Worth the Trouble? World Neurosurg. 2018. PMID: 30502474. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2018.11.170
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。