内镜与开放微血管减压术治疗三叉神经痛的比较:系统综述与对比荟萃分析
该系统综述与荟萃分析检索PubMed/MEDLINE和Ovid数据库至2017年,纳入23项研究共6749例患者,比较开放微血管减压术(MVD)与全内镜MVD(E-MVD)治疗三叉神经痛的疼痛缓解率与并发症。E-MVD组良好疼痛缓解率88%,MVD组81%;E-MVD组复发率9%,MVD组14%,但差异未达统计学显著。E-MVD组面肌无力、听力丧失、小脑损伤、感染和死亡的平均报告率显著低于MVD组,脑脊液漏两组相似。作者建议谨慎解读,因两组样本量不对称且E-MVD相对较新。
要点
- E-MVD组良好疼痛缓解率88%,MVD组81%。
- E-MVD组复发率9%,MVD组14%,差异未达统计学显著。
- E-MVD组总体并发症发生率8%,MVD组19%。
核心结论
- MVD与E-MVD在疼痛缓解方面临床结局相似。
- E-MVD研究复发率较低,但未达统计学显著。
- MVD的面肌无力与听力丧失等并发症发生率显著高于E-MVD,E-MVD总体并发症发生率8%低于MVD的19%。
- 作者认为内镜下行MVD治疗三叉神经痛至少可获得与开放MVD相当的手术结局,可能具有手术时间更短、骨窗更小和复发率更低的额外优势。
- 作者建议谨慎解读数据,因两组样本量不对称且E-MVD技术相对较新。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与对比荟萃分析,检索PubMed/MEDLINE和Ovid数据库自建库至2017年发表的研究。
- 纳入标准为成人患者、临床研究≥10例(排除个案研究以获得更高结局率数据量)、采用开放MVD或E-MVD治疗三叉神经痛、开颅与乙状窦后切口、英文文献,并报告疼痛缓解结局(完全、很好、部分或无)、复发率(患者数)和并发症(面肌无力、听力丧失、脑脊液漏、小脑损伤、感染、死亡)。
- 从1039项研究中纳入23篇文章,其中13篇关于传统MVD、10篇关于E-MVD。
- 总患者数6749例,其中5783例患者(5802次手术)接受MVD,993例患者(993次手术)接受E-MVD。
主要发现
- 良好疼痛缓解(完全或良好 vs 部分或无)在MVD组为81%,在E-MVD组为88%。
- 平均复发率在MVD组为14%,在E-MVD组为9%。
- 面肌无力或面瘫、听力丧失、小脑损伤、感染和死亡的平均报告率在E-MVD组统计学上低于MVD组,脑脊液漏两组相似。
- 总体并发症发生率在MVD组为19%,在E-MVD组为8%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为内镜下行MVD治疗三叉神经痛至少可获得与开放MVD相当的手术结局,可能具有手术时间更短、骨窗更小和复发率更低的额外优势。
- 作者建议谨慎解读数据,因两组样本量不对称且E-MVD技术相对较新。
局限性
- 两组样本量不对称。
- E-MVD技术相对较新。
- 复发率在E-MVD组较低但未达统计学显著。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Microvascular decompression (MVD) is commonly used in the treatment of trigeminal neuralgia (TN) with positive clinical outcomes. Fully endoscopic MVD (E-MVD) has been proposed as an effective minimally invasive alternative, but a comparative review of the two approaches has not been conducted. The authors performed a meta-analysis of studies, comparing patient outcome rates and complications for the open versus the endoscopic technique. METHODS: The PubMed/MEDLINE and Ovid databases were searched for studies published from database inception to 2017. The search terms used included, but were not limited to, "open microvascular decompression," "microvascular decompression for trigeminal neuralgia," and "endoscopic decompression for trigeminal neuralgia." Criteria for inclusion of studies in the meta-analysis were established as follows: adult patients, clinical studies with ≥ 10 patients (excluding case studies to obtain a higher volume of outcome rates), utilization of open MVD or E-MVD to treat TN, craniotomy and retrosigmoid incision, English-language studies, and articles that listed pain relief outcomes (complete, very good, partial, or absent), recurrence rate (number of patients), and complications (paresis, hearing loss, CSF leakage, cerebellar damage, infection, death). Relevant references from the chosen articles were also included. RESULTS: From a larger pool of 1039 studies, 23 articles were selected for review: 13 on traditional MVD and 10 on E-MVD. The total number of patients was 6749, of which 5783 patients (and 5802 procedures) had undergone MVD and 993 patients (and procedures) had undergone E-MVD. Analyzed data included postoperative pain relief outcome (complete or good pain relief vs partial or no pain relief), and rates of recurrence and complications including facial paralysis, weakness, or paresis; hearing loss; auditory and facial nerve damage; cerebrospinal fluid leakage; infection; cerebellar damage; and death.Good pain relief was achieved in 81% of MVD patients and 88% of E-MVD patients, with a mean recurrence rate of 14% and 9%, respectively. Average rates of reported complications were statistically lower in E-MVD than in MVD approaches, including facial paresis or weakness, hearing loss, cerebellar damage, infection, and death, whereas cerebrospinal fluid leakage was similar. The overall incidence of complications was 19% for MVD and 8% for E-MVD. CONCLUSIONS: The reviewed literature revealed similar clinical outcomes with respect to pain relief for MVD and E-MVD. The recurrence rate was lower in E-MVD studies, though not significantly so, and the incidence of complications, notably facial paresis and hearing loss, were statistically higher for MVD than for E-MVD. Based on these results, the use of endoscopy to perform MVD for TN appears to offer at least as good a surgical outcome as the more commonly used open MVD, with the possible added advantages of having a shorter operative time, smaller craniotomy, and lower recurrence rates. The authors advise caution in interpreting these data given the asymmetry in the sample size between the two groups and the relative novelty of the E-MVD approach.
引用
- Zagzoog N, Attar A, Takroni R, et al. Endoscopic versus open microvascular decompression for trigeminal neuralgia: a systematic review and comparative meta-analysis. J Neurosurg. 2018. PMID: 30544341. doi:10.3171/2018.6.JNS172690
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。