脑膜瘤质地分级方案的前瞻性临床验证:与手术结局及肿瘤切除范围的相关性
本研究在两家高容量学术医院前瞻性评估既往验证的脑膜瘤质地分级方案在127例连续开颅手术患者中的临床效用,并按术后MRI分为全切除与次全切除。质地分级与最大肿瘤直径或位置无关;质地越高,手术时间越长、围手术期并发症有升高趋势、全切除比例越低。
要点
- 质地分级1–5分分布为3.1%、14.2%、44.1%、32.3%、6.3%,平均肿瘤直径3.6±1.7 cm。
- 手术时间随质地增高而延长:1–2级186分钟,3级219分钟,4–5级299分钟(p=0.000028)。
- 全切除比例随质地增高而降低:1–2级77%,3级68%,4–5级43%(p=0.0062)。
核心结论
- 除侵袭性等其他重要脑膜瘤特征外,肿瘤质地是手术结局(包括手术时间和切除范围)的关键决定因素。
- 作者认为,未来基于术前神经影像预测肿瘤质地的研究将大大有助于脑膜瘤的术前规划。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性评估既往验证的脑膜瘤质地分级系统,纳入2013至2016年在两家高容量学术医院由多位神经外科医生行开颅手术的127例连续脑膜瘤患者。
- 质地分级评分为1分(软)至5分(硬/钙化),回顾性分析其与手术结局及按术后MRI定义的全切除或次全切除的相关性。
主要发现
- 127例患者肿瘤质地分布为:1级3.1%、2级14.2%、3级44.1%、4级32.3%、5级6.3%;平均肿瘤直径3.6±1.7 cm。
- 统计分析将质地分为软(1–2级,17.3%)、中等(3级,44.1%)和硬(4–5级,38.6%)三组。
- 脑膜瘤质地与最大肿瘤直径或位置无关联。
- 平均手术时间随质地增高而延长:1–2级186分钟,3级219分钟,4–5级299分钟(p=0.000028)。
- 围手术期并发症率随质地增高呈升高趋势:1–2级4.5%,3级7.0%,4–5级20.8%(p=0.047)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐,仅指出肿瘤质地是手术结局的关键决定因素,并认为未来基于术前神经影像预测质地的研究将有助于术前规划。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The present study aims to assess the clinical utility of a previously validated intraoperative meningioma consistency grading scale and its association with extent of resection (EOR) and various surgical outcomes. METHODS: The previously validated grading system was prospectively assessed in 127 consecutive patients undergoing open craniotomy for meningioma by multiple neurosurgeons at two high-volume academic hospitals from 2013 to 2016. Consistency grading scores ranging from 1 (soft) to 5 (firm/calcified) were retrospectively analyzed to test for association with surgical outcomes and EOR, categorized as gross-total resection (GTR) or subtotal resection, defined by postoperative MRI. RESULTS: One hundred twenty-seven patients were included in the analysis with a tumor consistency distribution as follows: grade 1, 3.1%; grade 2, 14.2%; grade 3, 44.1%; grade 4, 32.3%; and grade 5, 6.3%. The mean tumor diameter was 3.6 ± 1.7 cm. Tumor consistency grades were grouped into soft (grades 1 and 2), average (grade 3), and firm (grades 4 and 5) groups for statistical analysis with distributions of 17.3%, 44.1%, and 38.6%, respectively. There was no association between meningioma consistency and maximal tumor diameter, or location. Mean duration of surgery was longer for tumors with higher consistency: grades 1 and 2, 186 minutes; grade 3, 219 minutes; and grades 4 and 5, 299 minutes (p = 0.000028). There was a trend toward higher perioperative complication rates for tumors of increased consistency: grades 1 and 2, 4.5%; grade 3, 7.0%; and grades 4 and 5, 20.8% (p = 0.047). The proportion of GTR for each consistency group was as follows: grades 1 and 2, 77%; grade 3, 68%; and grades 4 and 5, 43% (p = 0.0062). CONCLUSIONS: In addition to other important meningioma characteristics such as invasiveness, tumor consistency is a key determinant of surgical outcomes, including operative duration and EOR. Future studies predicting tumor consistency based on preoperative neuroimaging will help considerably with preoperative planning for meningiomas.
引用
- Itamura K, Chang KE, Lucas J, et al. Prospective clinical validation of a meningioma consistency grading scheme: association with surgical outcomes and extent of tumor resection. J Neurosurg. 2018. PMID: 30554187. doi:10.3171/2018.7.JNS1838
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。