奥尔堡螺栓连接引流(ABCD)研究:隧道式与螺栓连接脑室外引流的前瞻性比较
该前瞻性研究连续纳入2017年3月1日至2018年2月28日行脑室造瘘术的患者,比较螺栓连接脑室外引流(BC-EVD)与隧道式脑室外引流(T-EVD)的并发症。49例引流中T-EVD组19/32(59.4%)出现并发症,BC-EVD组3/17(17.6%)出现并发症(p=0.007),T-EVD并发症相对风险为BC-EVD的3.4倍。作者认为BC-EVD可降低并发症发生率和风险,应作为EVD置入的首选。
要点
- T-EVD组并发症19/32(59.4%),BC-EVD组3/17(17.6%),差异有统计学意义(p=0.007)。
- 使用T-EVD时并发症相对风险为BC-EVD的3.4倍。
- 作者认为BC-EVD应作为EVD置入的首选,但T-EVD在儿科及术中、枕部置入时仍有作用。
核心结论
- 与T-EVD相比,BC-EVD可降低脑室造瘘术并发症的发生率和风险,应作为EVD置入的首选。
- T-EVD在儿科患者以及术中置入和枕部置入的EVD中仍有作用。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,从本院引入BC-EVD技术起连续12个月将患者按连续分配方式纳入BC-EVD组或T-EVD组。
- 纳入2017年3月1日至2018年2月28日期间接受脑室造瘘术的患者。
- 由值班神经外科医生自主决定EVD指征和类型(BC-EVD或T-EVD),7名值班高级神经外科医生中3名愿意使用BC-EVD、4名不愿使用该技术,由此形成两个队列。
- 通过患者病历连续收集数据,包括脑脊液培养结果和可获得的CT/MRI扫描。
- 共纳入49例EVD(T-EVD 32例,BC-EVD 17例)。
主要发现
- T-EVD组32例中19例(59.4%)出现并发症,BC-EVD组17例中3例(17.6%)出现并发症(p=0.007)。
- 使用T-EVD时并发症相对风险为BC-EVD的3.4倍。
- 记录的并发症包括脑脊液漏、意外拔管、置入相关颅内出血、功能障碍、移位、感染和翻修。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为BC-EVD应作为EVD置入的首选。
- 作者认为T-EVD在儿科患者以及术中置入和枕部置入的EVD中仍有作用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Acutely increased intracranial pressure (ICP) is frequently managed by external ventricular drainage (EVD). This procedure is life-saving but marred by a high incidence of complications. It has recently been indicated that bolt-connected external ventricular drainage (BC-EVD) compared to the standard technique of tunnelled EVD (T-EVD) may result in less complications. AIM: To prospectively sample and compare two cohorts by consecutive allocation to either BC-EVD or T-EVD from the introduction of the BC-EVD technique in our department and 12 months onward. METHODS: Patients undergoing ventriculostomy between the 1st of March 2017 and the 28th of February 2018 were considered for inclusion. The neurosurgeon on-call sovereignly set the indication and decided on EVD type (BC-EVD or T-EVD), consequently resulting in two cohorts as 3/7 senior neurosurgeons on call were open to the use of BC-EVD, while 4/7 were reluctant to use this technique. Data was continuously collected using patient records, including results of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) culturing and available CT/MRI-scans. Recorded complications included CSF leakage, accidental discontinuation, placement-related intracranial haemorrhage, malfunction, migration, infection and revision. RESULTS: Forty-nine EVDs (32 T-EVDs/17 BC-EVDs) were included; 19/32 (59.4%) T-EVDs and 3/17 (17.6%) BC-EVDs were found to have complications (p = 0.007). The relative risk of complications when using T-EVD was 3.4 times that of BC-EVD. CONCLUSION: Ventriculostomy by BC-EVD compared to T-EVD reduces incidence and risk of complications and should be the first choice in EVD placement. That said, T-EVD has a role in paediatric patients and for intraoperatively and occipitally placed EVDs.
引用
- Asaad SK, Bjarkam CR. The Aalborg Bolt-Connected Drain (ABCD) study: a prospective comparison of tunnelled and bolt-connected external ventricular drains. Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2018. PMID: 30470903. doi:10.1007/s00701-018-3737-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。