三叉神经痛患者初次伽玛刀失败后重复伽玛刀放射外科与微血管减压术的比较:系统评价与Meta分析
该系统评价与Meta分析纳入22项研究,比较三叉神经痛初次伽玛刀失败后重复伽玛刀与微血管减压术的结局。汇总分析显示,微血管减压术的完全疼痛缓解率(72% vs 46%,p=0.02)优于重复伽玛刀,而充分疼痛缓解、面部麻木和再治疗率两组无显著差异。作者本机构42例回顾性分析中两组各项结局均无显著差异。
要点
- 初次伽玛刀失败后,微血管减压术的1年完全疼痛缓解率高于重复伽玛刀(72% vs 46%,p=0.02)。
- 两组1年充分疼痛缓解率(88% vs 83%,p=0.49)、面部麻木(22% vs 32%,p=0.11)和再治疗率(13% vs 19%,p=0.74)无显著差异。
- 作者本机构42例中,重复伽玛刀与微血管减压术的1年充分疼痛缓解(80% vs 81%,p=1.0)和完全疼痛缓解(47% vs 44%,p=1.0)均无显著差异。
核心结论
- Meta分析未发现重复伽玛刀与微血管减压术在充分疼痛缓解、术后面部麻木和再治疗率方面存在优劣。
- 微血管减压术较重复伽玛刀提供更高的完全疼痛缓解机会。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价与Meta分析,检索PubMed、Cochrane Library、Web of Science和CINAHL数据库,纳入22项研究。
- 最终分析包括重复伽玛刀组(n=17项研究)和微血管减压术组(n=5项研究),未检索到直接比较两种治疗的研究。
- 作者本机构回顾性分析42例患者(重复伽玛刀15例,微血管减压术27例),是唯一直接比较两组的队列。
主要发现
- 汇总分析:充分疼痛缓解率重复伽玛刀组83% vs 微血管减压术组88%(p=0.49)。
- 汇总分析:完全疼痛缓解率重复伽玛刀组46% vs 微血管减压术组72%(p=0.02)。
- 汇总分析:术后面部麻木发生率重复伽玛刀组32% vs 微血管减压术组22%(p=0.11);再治疗率重复伽玛刀组19% vs 微血管减压术组13%(p=0.74)。
- 本机构研究:1年充分疼痛缓解率重复伽玛刀组80% vs 微血管减压术组81%(p=1.0);完全疼痛缓解率重复伽玛刀组47% vs 微血管减压术组44%(p=1.0);术后面部麻木和再治疗率无差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Gamma Knife radiosurgery (GKRS) has emerged as a promising treatment modality for patients with classical trigeminal neuralgia (TN); however, considering that almost half of the patients experience post-GKRS failure or lesion recurrence, a repeat treatment is typically necessary. The existing literature does not offer clear evidence to establish which treatment modality, repeat GKRS or microvascular decompression (MVD), is superior. The present study aimed to compare the overall outcome of patients who have undergone either repeat GKRS or MVD after failure of their primary GKRS; the authors do so by conducting a systematic review and meta-analysis of the literature and analysis of data from their own institution. METHODS: The authors conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of the PubMed, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, and CINAHL databases to identify studies describing patients who underwent either repeat GKRS or MVD after initial failed GKRS for TN. The primary outcomes were complete pain relief (CPR) and adequate pain relief (APR) at 1 year. The secondary outcomes were rate of postoperative facial numbness and the retreatment rate. The pooled data were analyzed with R software. Bias and heterogeneity were assessed using funnel plots and I2 tests, respectively. A retrospective analysis of a series of patients treated by the authors who underwent repeat GKRS or MVD after post-GKRS failure or relapse is presented. RESULTS: A total of 22 studies met the selection criteria and were included for final data retrieval and meta-analysis. The search did not identify any study that had directly compared outcomes between patients who had undergone repeat GKRS versus those who had undergone MVD. Therefore, the authors' final analysis included two groups: studies describing outcome after repeat GKRS (n = 17) and studies describing outcome after MVD (n = 5). The authors' institutional study was the only study with direct comparison of the two cohorts. The pooled estimates of primary outcomes were APR in 83% of patients who underwent repeat GKRS and 88% of those who underwent MVD (p = 0.49), and CPR in 46% of patients who underwent repeat GKRS and 72% of those who underwent MVD (p = 0.02). The pooled estimates of secondary outcomes were facial numbness in 32% of patients who underwent repeat GKRS and 22% of those who underwent MVD (p = 0.11); the retreatment rate was 19% in patients who underwent repeat GKRS and 13% in those who underwent MVD (p = 0.74). The authors' institutional study included 42 patients (repeat GKRS in 15 and MVD in 27), and the outcomes 1 year after retreatment were APR in 80% of those who underwent repeat GKRS and 81% in those who underwent MVD (p = 1.0); CPR was achieved in 47% of those who underwent repeat GKRS and 44% in those who underwent MVD (p = 1.0). There was no difference in the rate of postoperative facial numbness or retreatment. CONCLUSIONS: The current meta-analysis failed to identify any superiority of one treatment over the other with comparable outcomes in terms of APR, postoperative facial numbness, and retreatment rates. However, MVD was shown to provide a better chance of CPR compared with repeat GKRS.
引用
- Patra DP, Savardekar AR, Dossani RH, et al. Repeat Gamma Knife radiosurgery versus microvascular decompression following failure of GKRS in trigeminal neuralgia: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Neurosurg. 2018. PMID: 30485193. doi:10.3171/2018.5.JNS18583
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。