文献速递神经肿瘤

脑肿瘤手术中的医疗过失诉讼:基于Westlaw数据库的美国31年诉讼原因分析

Malpractice Litigation in Brain Tumor Surgery: A 31-Year Analysis of Causative Factors in the United States from the Westlaw Database.
PubMed 文献 · World Neurosurg · 2018-11-23

本研究利用WestlawNext法律数据库检索1985年至2016年间与脑肿瘤相关的医疗过失诉讼案件,共纳入225例,分析诉讼原因(同案可多因)。案件分布于36个州及美国属地,最常见的诉讼原因为未诊断、未治疗、操作失误和未转诊进行诊断检查。作者结论认为良性脑肿瘤在诉讼中最常见,而手术问题仅占较小比例。

要点

  • 诉讼原因以未诊断(109例,28%)、未治疗(72例,18%)、操作失误(63例,16%)和未转诊进行诊断检查(55例,14%)为主。
  • 最常见诊断包括听神经瘤(27例,12%)、垂体腺瘤(26例,12%)和脑膜瘤(23例,10%)。
  • 医疗过失诉讼增加管理成本、加剧医生职业倦怠并推高患者医疗费用。

核心结论

  • 医疗过失诉讼增加管理成本并加剧医生职业倦怠,还推高患者医疗费用。
  • 本研究发现良性脑肿瘤在诉讼中最常见,手术问题仅占较小比例。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究使用法律数据库WestLawNext检索1985年至2016年间与脑肿瘤相关的全部案件,共识别225例并逐例分析诉讼原因(允许同一案件存在多个原因)。
  • 因许多案件有超过1个诉讼依据,所报告百分比以诉讼原因总计数为分母而非案件数。

主要发现

  • 案件分布于36个州及美国属地,加利福尼亚州(42例,20%)和纽约州(28例,13%)案件数最多。
  • 诉讼原因前四位为未诊断(109例,28%)、未治疗(72例,18%)、操作失误(63例,16%)和未转诊进行诊断检查(55例,14%)。
  • 最常见诊断为听神经瘤(27例,12%)、垂体腺瘤(26例,12%)和脑膜瘤(23例,10%)。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Medical malpractice litigation is an issue of major concern in neurosurgery, with 19.1% of neurosurgeons facing a claim annually. Neurosurgery possesses the greatest risk of malpractice of any specialty, likely owing to the complex clinical environment and disease severity. In the present study, we have characterized such litigation to determine the common factors that compel plaintiffs to file these claims. METHODS: WestLawNext, a prominent legal database, was used to identify all cases from 1985 to 2016 related to brain tumors. A total of 225 cases were identified, and each was analyzed for the cause of litigation (multiple causes were permitted). Because many had >1 ground for litigation, the reported percentages were based on the total counts of litigation rather than the number of cases. Additional information was collected from each case, including location, tumor type, and physician specialty. RESULTS: The cases were distributed across 36 states and U.S. territories: California (n = 42; 20%) and New York (n = 28; 13%) had the greatest number of cases. The top reasons for litigation were failure to diagnose (n = 109; 28%), failure to treat (n = 72; 18%), procedural error (n = 63; 16%), and failure to refer for diagnostic tests (n = 55; 14%). The most common diagnoses included pituitary adenoma (n = 26; 12%), acoustic neuroma (n = 27; 12%), and meningioma (n = 23; 10%). CONCLUSIONS: Malpractice litigation contributes to high overhead and physician burnout and escalates the cost of patient care. We found that benign brain tumors were the most common in litigation and that surgical issues accounted for only a small percentage.

来源:World Neurosurg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Kessler RA, Benzil DL, Loewenstern J, et al. Malpractice Litigation in Brain Tumor Surgery: A 31-Year Analysis of Causative Factors in the United States from the Westlaw Database. World Neurosurg. 2018. PMID: 30476665. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2018.11.112

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。