文献速递功能神经外科

读者对精神神经外科媒体报道的评论:过去的历史给未来蒙上阴影

Reader comments to media reports on psychiatric neurosurgery: past history casts shadows on the future.
PubMed 文献 · Acta Neurochir (Wien) · 2018-10-24

该研究对加拿大、美国、德国和西班牙四国2006至2017年间115篇报刊文章中读者关于精神疾病神经外科干预的662条评论进行主题分析,发现读者多提及历史精神外科且对毁损性干预多持负面悲观态度,对脑深部电刺激的评论较积极,对光遗传学的评论最具争议,并表达了对医疗专业人员的不信任及对社会和个人控制的担忧。

要点

  • 读者评论多提及历史精神外科,对毁损性神经外科干预多持负面悲观态度。
  • 对脑深部电刺激的评论较积极,对光遗传学的评论最具争议。
  • 评论中表达了对脑干预中医疗专业人员的 distrust 及对社会和个人控制的担忧。

核心结论

  • 结果提示,在提高公众对重新出现和新的神经外科干预的认识方面仍有许多工作要做;如果这些方法要在精神疾病医疗保健中找到一席之地,需要进行平衡的讨论。

研究设计与样本

  • 对2006年至2017年间来自加拿大、美国、德国和西班牙四国115篇报刊文章的读者评论(662个编码数据单元)进行主题分析,编码方案围绕基于母研究的四个先验类别和两个新出现的类别迭代完善。

主要发现

  • 读者评论中多次提及历史精神外科,对毁损性神经外科干预的评论大多为负面和悲观。
  • 对脑深部电刺激的评论较为积极,对光遗传学的评论最具争议。
  • 评论中还发现许多对脑干预背景下医疗专业人员的不信任表达,以及对 social and individual control 的担忧。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Comments made by readers in response to news articles about current events can provide profound insights into public understanding of and perspectives on those events. Here, in follow up to a paper published last year in this journal, we examined reader comments to articles in newspapers and magazines about neurosurgical interventions for treating psychiatric illness. METHOD: We conducted a thematic analysis of these comments (N = 662 coded units of data) posted in response to 115 newspaper and magazine articles from four countries (Canada, USA, Germany, and Spain) between 2006 and 2017. The comments were coded using an iteratively refined coding scheme that was structured around four a priori categories based on results from the parent study and two new categories that emerged. RESULTS: We found many references to historical psychosurgery and mostly negative and pessimistic comments about ablative neurosurgical interventions. Comments to deep brain stimulation were more positive, and comments to optogenetics most controversial. We also found many expressions of distrust of medical professionals in the context of interventions on the brain and concerns about social and individual control. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, results suggest there is still much work to be done to raise public awareness about re-emerging and new neurosurgical interventions. Balanced discussion is needed if these approaches are to find a place in health care for psychiatric disorders.

来源:Acta Neurochir (Wien),查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Cabrera LY, Bittlinger M, Lou H, et al. Reader comments to media reports on psychiatric neurosurgery: past history casts shadows on the future. Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2018. PMID: 30357485. doi:10.1007/s00701-018-3696-4

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。