Simpson分级系统是否适用于评估复发性颅内脑膜瘤显微术后肿瘤进展风险
该研究分析了Simpson分级系统在复发性脑膜瘤显微手术后评估肿瘤复发风险的适用性。共纳入829例原发性脑膜瘤和109例首次术后复发性脑膜瘤患者,比较Simpson分级和切除程度与肿瘤复发的关系。结果显示在原发性脑膜瘤中Simpson分级和切除程度与复发强相关,但在复发性脑膜瘤中二者与进一步肿瘤复发相关性差。
要点
- 复发性脑膜瘤手术与原发性脑膜瘤手术相比,术后并发症频率相似。
- 在复发性脑膜瘤中,Simpson分级和切除程度与进一步肿瘤复发相关性差。
- 复发性脑膜瘤中,肿瘤复发时年龄较大、男性和组织学分级2/3级与进一步复发相关。
核心结论
- 复发性脑膜瘤手术与原发性脑膜瘤切除相比,通常不增加术后并发症风险。
- 然而,复发性脑膜瘤中Simpson分级和切除程度与进一步肿瘤复发相关性差。
- 在手术具有挑战性的复发性脑膜瘤病变中,应考虑显微手术遗留肿瘤残端的预后价值较低。
研究设计与样本
- 研究分析了Simpson分级系统在复发性脑膜瘤显微手术后评估肿瘤复发风险的适用性。
- 共纳入829例原发性脑膜瘤患者(A组占88%)和109例首次术后复发性脑膜瘤患者(B组占12%)。
- 比较Simpson分级和切除程度(全切除[Simpson I和II级] vs 次全切除[Simpson ≥III级])与脑膜瘤复发术后肿瘤再发的关系,并与原发诊断肿瘤的发现进行比较。
主要发现
- 在A组中,Simpson分级(P = 0.003)和切除程度(P < 0.001)均与复发强相关。
- 在B组中,Simpson分级与肿瘤位置相关(P = 0.030),后颅窝脑膜瘤次全切除的风险更高(比值比5.26;P = 0.018),颅底脑膜瘤次全切除的风险更高(比值比6.16;P = 0.002)。
- 肿瘤复发时年龄较大(风险比[HR] 1.05;P = 0.001)、男性(HR 2.19;P = 0.02)和组织学分级2/3级(HR 2.18;P = 0.02)与进一步肿瘤复发相关。
- 然而,Simpson分级或二分类切除程度均与进一步肿瘤复发无关。
- 两组术后并发症频率相似。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: We analyzed the applicability of the Simpson grading system to estimate the risk of tumor recurrence after microsurgery for recurrent meningiomas. METHODS: Correlations between the Simpson grade and the extent of resection (EOR) (gross total resection [Simpson grade I and II] vs. subtotal resection [Simpson grade ≥III]) with tumor relapse after microsurgery for meningioma recurrence were investigated compared with the findings in primary diagnosed tumors. Location-specific differences were further elucidated in subgroup analyses. RESULTS: A total of 829 individuals (88% in group A) with primary diagnosed meningioma and 109 patients with first postoperative recurrence (12% in group B) who underwent surgery were included. In group A, both Simpson grade (P = 0.003) and EOR (P < 0.001) correlated strongly with recurrence. In group B, Simpson grade correlated with tumor location (P = 0.030), and the risk of subtotal resection was greater in the posterior fossa (odds ratio, 5.26; P = 0.018) and skull base (odds ratio, 6.16; P = 0.002) meningiomas. Older age at tumor relapse (hazard ratio [HR], 1.05; P = 0.001), male sex (HR, 2.19; P = 0.02), and grade 2/3 histologic findings (HR, 2.18; P = 0.02). However, neither the Simpson grade nor dichotomized EOR correlated with further tumor recurrence. The frequency of postoperative complications was similar in both groups. CONCLUSIONS: Surgery for recurrent meningiomas is not generally associated with an increased risk of postoperative complications compared with resection of primary diagnosed tumors. However, the Simpson grade and EOR in recurrent meningiomas correlated poorly with further tumor relapse. The lower prognostic value of the tumor remnants left behind during microsurgery for recurrent meningiomas should be considered when operating on lesions that can be surgically challenging.
引用
- Schipmann S, Schwake M, Sporns PB, et al. Is the Simpson Grading System Applicable to Estimate the Risk of Tumor Progression After Microsurgery for Recurrent Intracranial Meningioma? World Neurosurg. 2018. PMID: 30081236. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2018.07.215
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。