使用血流增强装置对脑室腹腔分流管通畅性和脑脊液流动的无创热学评估
该研究在71根分流管中完成82次独特测试,评估微泵增强热学流动检测能否预测7天内分流管翻修需求。结果显示检测敏感度73%、特异度68%,未检测到流动时翻修概率高5.6倍,样本阴性预测值为94.2%。作者认为最佳温度阈值可能低于制造商建议的0.2°C,建议开展多中心研究。
要点
- 微泵增强热学流动检测预测7天内翻修的敏感度为73%、特异度为68%。
- 未检测到流动时翻修概率高5.6倍,样本阴性预测值为94.2%。
- 最佳温度阈值可能低于制造商建议的0.2°C。
核心结论
- 热学流动评估与分流管未发生故障的临床印象之间存在强关联,这是首项报告该关联的研究。
研究设计与样本
- 在71根分流管中完成82次独特测试,比较微泵增强热学流动检测结果与测试后7天内翻修需求,统计分析基于盲法解读测试结果和测试期间记录的原始温度数据。
主要发现
- 检测预测翻修需求的敏感度为73%、特异度为68%,未检测到流动时翻修概率高5.6倍。
- 样本阴性预测值为94.2%,不需要翻修的概率随总温度下降幅度增加而增加。
- 多种可能阈值分析显示,最佳温度截断值可能低于制造商建议的0.2°C(0.125°C vs 0.2°C)。
临床怎么用
- 当前推荐阈值可能不必要地增加假阳性率。
- 随着临床医生对该方法积累经验,他们可能发现检查温度曲线本身有价值。
- 作者建议开展多中心研究以进一步明确该诊断检查的作用。
局限性
- 作者建议开展多中心研究以进一步明确该诊断检查的作用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: While a noninvasive flow determination would be desirable in the diagnosis of cerebrospinal fluid shunt malfunction, existing studies have not yet defined a role for thermal flow detection. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate a revised test protocol using a micropumper designed to transiently enhance flow during thermal testing to determine whether thermal detection of flow is associated with progression to shunt revision surgery. METHODS: Eighty-two unique tests were performed in 71 shunts. The primary outcome, need for revision within 7 d of testing, was compared with results of micropumper-augmented thermal flow detection. Statistical analysis was based on blind interpretation of test results and raw temperature data recorded during testing. RESULTS: The test was sensitive (73%) and specific (68%) in predicting need for revision, with 5.6-fold higher probability of revision when flow was not detected. Negative predictive value in our sample was 94.2%. The probability of not requiring revision increased with increasing total temperature drop. Analysis of various possible thresholds showed that the optimal temperature cutoff may be lower than suggested by the manufacturer (0.125°C vs 0.2°C). CONCLUSION: This is the first study to report a strong association between thermal flow evaluation and a clinical impression that a shunt is not malfunctioning. The current recommended threshold may increase the false positive rate unnecessarily, and as clinicians gain experience with the method, they may find value in examining the temperature curves themselves. Multicenter studies are suggested to further define a role for this diagnostic test.
引用
- Hameed MQ, Zurakowski D, Proctor MR, et al. Noninvasive Thermal Evaluation of Ventriculoperitoneal Shunt Patency and Cerebrospinal Fluid Flow Using a Flow Enhancing Device. Neurosurgery. 2019. PMID: 29917093. doi:10.1093/neuros/nyy246
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。