内镜下经鼻肿瘤手术中脑脊液漏与颅底缺损分级修补的演变:509例患者修补失败与脑膜炎发生率趋势
该研究回顾性分析单机构2010年4月至2017年4月509例经鼻内镜手术患者,按脑脊液漏分级(0-3级)记录修补技术,分两个阶段比较修补失败与脑膜炎发生率。结果显示术后脑脊液漏9例(1.6%),脑膜炎6例(1.1%);第二阶段1-3级修补失败从4.1%降至2.1%,脑膜炎从3.5%降至0.7%(p=0.08)。作者认为分级修补策略在内镜时代仍有效,修补技术和脑膜炎发生率进一步降低。
要点
- 术后脑脊液漏发生率1.6%(9/551次手术),脑膜炎1.1%(6/551次手术)。
- 1-3级修补失败从第一阶段4.1%(6/143)降至第二阶段2.1%(3/141)。
- 1-3级脑膜炎从第一阶段3.5%(5例)降至第二阶段0.7%(1例),p=0.08。
核心结论
- 内镜时代经鼻手术后颅底分级修补策略仍然有效,且技术已显著演变,术后脑脊液漏率进一步降低。
- 作者认为支撑物对大多数1级和2级漏及所有3级漏的修补有益,带蒂黏膜瓣对3级漏似乎有利。
- 作者认为脑脊液分流可能不必要且是脑膜炎的危险因素,高BMI应促使采用积极的多层修补策略。
- 作者认为在内镜颅底肿瘤手术中,修补失败率和脑膜炎率低于1%是合理目标。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性单机构经鼻内镜患者数据库(2010年4月至2017年4月)分析。
- 共551次手术、509例患者,病变包括垂体腺瘤(66%)、Rathke裂囊肿(7%)、脑膜瘤(6%)、颅咽管瘤(4%)及其他(17%)。
- 术中脑脊液漏按大小分级(0级无漏、1级、2级、3级),记录各分级修补技术。
- 按是否实施严格围手术期抗生素方案及更广泛使用永久和/或临时支撑物将系列分为2个阶段,比较两阶段修补失败率和术后脑膜炎率。
主要发现
- 术后脑脊液漏9例(1.6%),脑膜炎6例(1.1%);扩展入路占41%。
- 0、1、2、3级术后漏率分别为0%、1.9%、3.1%、4.8%;脂肪移植物使用率分别为33%、84%、97%、100%。
- 带蒂黏膜瓣共78个,0-2级合并使用率2.6%,3级使用率79.5%(鼻中隔瓣60个、中鼻甲瓣6个);鼻中隔瓣使用率颅咽管瘤手术最高(80%),垂体腺瘤手术最低(2%);2个(3%)鼻中隔瓣失败。
- 9例修补失败的相关因素包括BMI≥30(7/9)、无支撑物(4/9)、3级漏(4/9)、术后呕吐(4/9)。
- 两阶段比较:1-3级修补失败从6/143(4.1%)降至3/141(2.1%),1-3级脑膜炎从5例(3.5%)降至1例(0.7%)(p=0.08)。
关键数值与推荐
- 脑脊液漏分级:0级无漏、1级、2级、3级。
- 修补失败率判定:术后脑脊液漏。
- 脑膜炎率判定:术后脑膜炎。
- 两阶段比较采用p值,p<0.001为显著,p=0.08未达统计学显著。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为分级修补策略在内镜时代仍然有效。
- 作者认为支撑物对大多数1级和2级漏及所有3级漏的修补有益。
- 作者认为带蒂黏膜瓣对3级漏似乎有利。
- 作者认为脑脊液分流可能不必要且是脑膜炎的危险因素。
- 作者认为高BMI应促使采用积极的多层修补策略,修补失败率和脑膜炎率低于1%是合理目标。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The authors previously described a graded approach to skull base repair following endonasal microscopic or endoscope-assisted tumor surgery. In this paper they review their experience with skull base reconstruction in the endoscopic era. METHODS: A retrospective review of a single-institution endonasal endoscopic patient database (April 2010–April 2017) was undertaken. Intraoperative CSF leaks were graded based on size (grade 0 [no leak], 1, 2, or 3), and repair technique was documented across grades. The series was divided into 2 epochs based on implementation of a strict perioperative antibiotic protocol and more liberal use of permanent and/or temporary buttresses; repair failure rates and postoperative meningitis rates were assessed for the 2 epochs and compared. RESULTS: In total, 551 operations were performed in 509 patients for parasellar pathology, including pituitary adenoma (66%), Rathke’s cleft cyst (7%), meningioma (6%), craniopharyngioma (4%), and other (17%). Extended approaches were used in 41% of cases. There were 9 postoperative CSF leaks (1.6%) and 6 cases of meningitis (1.1%). Postoperative leak rates for all 551 operations by grade 0, 1, 2, and 3 were 0%, 1.9%, 3.1%, and 4.8%, respectively. Fat grafts were used in 33%, 84%, 97%, and 100% of grade 0, 1, 2, and 3 leaks, respectively. Pedicled mucosal flaps (78 total) were used in 2.6% of grade 0–2 leaks (combined) and 79.5% of grade 3 leaks (60 nasoseptal and 6 middle turbinate flaps). Nasoseptal flap usage was highest for craniopharyngioma operations (80%) and lowest for pituitary adenoma operations (2%). Two (3%) nasoseptal flaps failed. Contributing factors for the 9 repair failures were BMI ≥ 30 (7/9), lack of buttress (4/9), grade 3 leak (4/9), and postoperative vomiting (4/9). Comparison of the epochs showed that grade 1–3 repair failures decreased from 6/143 (4.1%) to 3/141 (2.1%) and grade 1–3 meningitis rates decreased from 5 (3.5%) to 1 (0.7%) (p = 0.08). Prophylactic lumbar CSF drainage was used in only 4 cases (< 1%), was associated with a higher meningitis rate in grades 1–3 (25% vs 2%), and was discontinued in 2012. Comparison of the 2 epochs showed increase buttress use in the second, with use of a permanent buttress in grade 1 and 3 leaks increasing from 13% to 55% and 32% to 76%, respectively (p < 0.001), and use of autologous septal/keel bone as a permanent buttress in grade 1, 2, and 3 leaks increasing from 15% to 51% (p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: A graded approach to skull base repair after endonasal surgery remains valid in the endoscopic era. However, the technique has evolved significantly, with further reduction of postoperative CSF leak rates. These data suggest that buttresses are beneficial for repair of most grade 1 and 2 leaks and all grade 3 leaks. Similarly, pedicled flaps appear advantageous for grade 3 leaks, while CSF diversion may be unnecessary and a risk factor for meningitis. High BMI should prompt an aggressive multilayered repair strategy. Achieving repair failure and meningitis rates lower than 1% is a reasonable goal in endoscopic skull base tumor surgery.
引用
- Conger A, Zhao F, Wang X, et al. Evolution of the graded repair of CSF leaks and skull base defects in endonasal endoscopic tumor surgery: trends in repair failure and meningitis rates in 509 patients. J Neurosurg. 2018. PMID: 29749920. doi:10.3171/2017.11.JNS172141
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。