复发性脑动静脉畸形(AVM):一项系统综述
该系统综述纳入14篇病例报告和16篇病例系列,共汇总73例手术切除后复发的脑动静脉畸形患者。首次发病平均年龄13.8岁,90%以出血起病,血管造影确认完全切除后至复发平均4.2年;成人组复发率2.7%,儿童组平均9.5%,强制短期连续影像随访的系列中复发率接近14%。作者认为完全手术切除后AVM复发主要见于儿童,强烈建议儿童患者术后1年内进行随访影像检查。
要点
- 手术完全切除后AVM仍可复发,复发主要发生于儿童。
- 成人复发率2.7%,儿童平均9.5%,强制短期连续影像随访系列接近14%。
- 血管造影确认完全切除后至复发平均4.2年,首次发病平均13.8岁。
核心结论
- 完全手术切除后AVM复发是已被认识的风险,且主要发生在儿童。
- 作者强烈建议儿童手术切除AVM患者术后1年内进行随访影像检查,即使术后血管造影已确认完全切除。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,经参考馆员执行文献检索并筛选后纳入14篇病例报告和16篇病例系列。
- 由2名作者提取所有可能数据,结果列表并以描述性统计(均值、范围、比例)报告,未进行正式统计分析。
主要发现
- 文献系统综述共发现73例手术切除后复发的AVM患者。
- 首次AVM发病平均年龄为13.8岁,大多数患者以出血起病(90%)。
- 血管造影确认完全手术切除后,至AVM复发的平均时间为4.2年。
- 成人系列或病例报告(n=8)中复发率为2.7%。
- 仅分析儿童病例报告或系列(n=12)时平均复发率为9.5%,在强制短期随访连续影像检查的系列中高达近14%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Risk factors for the recurrence of surgically excised brain arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) are poorly understood. In addition, ideal follow-up imaging paradigms to catch AVM recurrences are not well defined. We present a systematic review on risk factors for the recurrence of surgically resected AVMs and identify potential theories of recurrence. METHODS: A literature search was performed by a reference librarian, and after screening, 14 case reports and 16 case series were left for inclusion in the review. All possible data were abstracted by 2 authors, and the results were tabulated and descriptive statistics (mean, range; and proportions) were reported. No formal statistical analysis was performed as part of this study. RESULTS: Systematic review of the literature revealed 73 patients with a surgically resected AVM that recurred. The average age of first AVM presentation was 13.8 years, and most patients presented with hemorrhage (90%). After angiographically confirmed complete surgical resection, average time to AVM recurrence was 4.2 years. Rate of recurrence was 2.7% in adult series or case reports (n = 8). When we analyzed only pediatric case reports or series (n = 12), the average rate of recurrence was 9.5% but was as high as almost 14% in a series with compulsory short-term follow-up serial imaging. Four (5.5%) patients experienced re-recurrence of AVM after complete surgical excision of first AVM recurrence. CONCLUSIONS: AVM recurrence after complete surgical resection is a recognized risk that occurs primarily in children. Follow-up imaging within 1 year of surgery is strongly indicated for pediatric patients with surgically resected AVMs, even with postoperative angiographically confirmed complete excision.
引用
- Sorenson TJ, Brinjikji W, Bortolotti C, et al. Recurrent Brain Arteriovenous Malformations (AVMs): A Systematic Review. World Neurosurg. 2018. PMID: 29807175. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2018.05.117
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。