脑创伤基金会指南依从性:一项多学科国际调查的结果
该国际多学科调查评估医生自报对脑创伤基金会(BTF)指南的依从性及影响因素,并调查颅内压监测实践。154名医生中15.9%报告其机构「总是」遵循BTF指南,72.2%报告「大多数时候」遵循。依从性与机构创伤级别(P=0.0010)、医生专科(P=0.015)和机构重型颅脑创伤病例量(P=0.008)显著相关。
要点
- 154名医生中15.9%报告其机构「总是」遵循BTF指南,72.2%报告「大多数时候」遵循。
- 依从性与机构创伤级别显著相关(P=0.0010):I级17.3%、II级13.0%、III级0%报告「总是」遵循。
- 依从性与医生专科(P=0.015)及机构重型颅脑创伤病例量(P=0.008)显著相关。
核心结论
- 较少受访者报告其机构「总是」遵循BTF指南。
- 普通外科医生和高容量I级创伤中心的提供者更可能遵循指南。
- 基于提供者和机构特征的调查应答差异可能有助于针对性开展教育工作。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为一项国际性、多学科调查,评估自报对BTF指南的依从性及多种可能影响依从性的因素,并调查颅内压监测实践。
- 调查共纳入154名医生受访者。
主要发现
- 154名医生受访者中,15.9%报告其机构「总是」遵循BTF指南,72.2%报告「大多数时候」遵循。
- 个人颅脑创伤病例量和执业年限与依从性无显著相关。
- 自报依从性随受访者机构创伤级别显著变化(P=0.0010):I级创伤中心17.3%的执业者、II级13.0%、III级0%报告「总是」遵循指南。
- 自报依从性随提供者专科(P=0.015)和机构重型颅脑创伤病例量(P=0.008)显著变化。
- 颅内压监测实践:52%受访者使用脑室外引流,21%使用脑实质内监测器,27%无偏好(P<0.001);不常规使用脑室外引流的受访者中,36%声称「总是」遵循指南;使用的颅内压监测类型与自报指南依从性之间无 apparent association。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Brain Trauma Foundation (BTF) guidelines reflect evidence-based best practices in management of traumatic brain injury. The aim of this study was to examine self-reported physician compliance and predictors of compliance related to BTF guidelines. METHODS: We conducted an international, multidisciplinary survey examining self-reported adherence to BTF guidelines and multiple factors potentially affecting adherence. We also surveyed intracranial pressure monitoring practices. RESULTS: Of 154 physician respondents, 15.9% reported their institutions "always" follow BTF guidelines and 72.2% reported that they follow them "most of the time." Personal volume of traumatic brain injury cases and years in practice were not significantly related to adherence. Reported adherence varied significantly in association with respondent's institutional trauma level (P = 0.0010): 17.3% of practitioners at level I, 13.0% at level II, and 0% at level III trauma centers reported "always" following guidelines. Reported adherence to guidelines also varied significantly in association with provider specialty (P = 0.015) and institutional volume of severe traumatic brain injury cases (P = 0.008). Regarding intracranial pressure monitoring practices, 52% of respondents used external ventricular drains, 21% used intraparenchymal monitors, and 27% had no preference (P < 0.001). Of respondents not routinely using external ventricular drains, 36% claimed to "always" follow guidelines. There was no apparent association between type of intracranial pressure monitoring used and reported guideline adherence. CONCLUSIONS: Few respondents reported their institutions "always" follow BTF guidelines. General surgeons and providers at high-volume level I trauma centers were more likely to comply with guidelines. Differences in survey responses based on provider and institutional characteristics may help target educational efforts.
引用
- Hirschi R, Rommel C, Letsinger J, et al. Brain Trauma Foundation Guideline Compliance: Results of a Multidisciplinary, International Survey. World Neurosurg. 2018. PMID: 29751187. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2018.04.215
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。