三叉神经痛外科治疗的疼痛无发作结局与持久性:伽玛刀与微血管减压术的比较
该系统综述纳入2004至2014年发表的18篇微血管减压术(MVD)研究(2650例)和25篇伽玛刀手术(GKS)研究(2846例),比较两种治疗三叉神经痛的完全疼痛缓解率与无痛复发率。MVD的初始无痛结局率(92.22% vs 61.46%,P<0.0001)和末次随访长期无痛结局率(79.37% vs 41.62%,P<0.0001)均显著高于GKS,而无痛复发率两者相似(14.93% vs 19.38%,P=0.2536)。作者认为MVD可能比GKS更有效,并指出需要更一致的数据报告。
要点
- MVD初始无痛结局率显著高于GKS(92.22% vs 61.46%,P<0.0001)。
- MVD末次随访长期无痛结局率显著高于GKS(79.37% vs 41.62%,P<0.0001)。
- MVD与GKS的无痛复发率相似(14.93% vs 19.38%,P=0.2536)。
核心结论
- 作者认为MVD可能比GKS更有效,因其初始无痛结局率和长期无痛结局率更高。
- 需要更一致的三叉神经痛治疗结局数据报告。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索2004至2014年发表的MVD和GKS治疗三叉神经痛的研究。
- 通过MEDLINE/PubMed检索并追溯初始检索所得文章的参考文献筛选研究。
- MVD组纳入18篇文章共2650例患者,GKS组纳入25篇文章共2846例患者。
- 采用各研究报告的常见结局指标进行Meta分析。
主要发现
- MVD组初始无痛结局(Barrow神经科学研究所I级)率显著高于GKS组(92.22% vs 61.46%,P<0.0001)。
- MVD组末次随访长期无痛结局率显著高于GKS组(79.37% vs 41.62%,P<0.0001)。
- MVD组无痛复发率与GKS组相似(14.93% vs 19.38%,P=0.2536)。
关键数值与推荐
- 初始无痛结局定义为Barrow神经科学研究所I级。
- MVD组初始无痛结局率92.22%,GKS组61.46%,P<0.0001。
- MVD组长期无痛结局率79.37%,GKS组41.62%,P<0.0001。
- MVD组无痛复发率14.93%,GKS组19.38%,P=0.2536。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 需要更一致的三叉神经痛治疗结局数据报告。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Treatment options for trigeminal neuralgia include microvascular decompression (MVD) and Gamma Knife surgery (GKS). There is no consensus which option is more effective at providing immediate and long-lasting pain relief. This study evaluated the differences between these 2 options in terms of rates of complete pain relief and pain-free recurrence. METHODS: A systematic review was conducted of published studies of MVD and GKS for treatment of trigeminal neuralgia from 2004 to 2014. Studies were selected using a MEDLINE/PubMed search and from subsequent inspection of references from articles found in the initial search. Common outcome measures reported in the studies were used for meta-analysis to make conclusions based on current available data. RESULTS: The MVD group included 18 articles with 2650 patients, and the GKS group included 25 articles with 2846 patients. MVD was found to have a significantly higher rate of initial pain-free outcomes (Barrow Neurological Institute grade I) compared with GKS (92.22% vs. 61.46%, P < 0.0001). MVD was also found to have a significantly higher rate of long-term pain-free outcomes at last follow-up compared with GKS (79.37% vs. 41.62%, P < 0.0001). MVD was found to have a similar rate of pain-free recurrence compared with GKS (14.93% vs. 19.38%, P = 0.2536). CONCLUSIONS: MVD may be a more effective intervention than GKS owing to higher rates of initial pain-free outcomes and long-term pain-free outcomes. There is a need for more consistent data reporting of outcomes for treatment of trigeminal neuralgia.
引用
- Mendelson ZS, Velagala JR, Kohli G, et al. Pain-Free Outcomes and Durability of Surgical Intervention for Trigeminal Neuralgia: A Comparison of Gamma Knife and Microvascular Decompression. World Neurosurg. 2018. PMID: 29382615. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2018.01.141
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。