未破裂大脑中动脉动脉瘤治疗中弹簧圈栓塞与显微外科夹闭的比较:一项Meta分析
该Meta分析系统检索2011年1月至2015年10月文献,纳入37项研究共3352例未破裂大脑中动脉动脉瘤成人患者,比较显微外科夹闭与血管内弹簧圈栓塞。夹闭组完全闭塞率为94.2%(95%CI 87.6%-97.4%),栓塞组为53.2%(95%CI 45.0%-61.1%);夹闭组神经功能良好结局为97.9%(95%CI 96.8%-98.6%),栓塞组为95.1%(95%CI 93.1%-96.5%)。作者结论认为显微外科夹闭仍然安全有效,血管内治疗的有效性和安全性持续改善,但闭塞率较低。
要点
- 显微外科夹闭治疗未破裂大脑中动脉动脉瘤的完全闭塞率为94.2%(95%CI 87.6%-97.4%)。
- 血管内弹簧圈栓塞的完全闭塞率为53.2%(95%CI 45.0%-61.1%),低于显微外科夹闭。
- 夹闭组神经功能良好结局为97.9%(95%CI 96.8%-98.6%),栓塞组为95.1%(95%CI 93.1%-96.5%)。
核心结论
- 该更新的Meta分析显示,显微外科夹闭治疗未破裂大脑中动脉动脉瘤仍然高度安全有效。
- 血管内治疗未破裂大脑中动脉动脉瘤的有效性和安全性持续改善,但导致较低的闭塞率。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索2011年1月至2015年10月的文献,以更新此前的Meta分析。
- 纳入所有报告成人未破裂大脑中动脉动脉瘤接受显微外科夹闭或血管内弹簧圈栓塞治疗的研究并进行累积分析。
- 共纳入37项研究、3352例患者。
主要发现
- 采用随机效应模型,11项显微外科夹闭研究(626个动脉瘤)的汇总分析显示完全闭塞率为94.2%(95%CI 87.6%-97.4%)。
- 18项血管内弹簧圈栓塞研究(759个动脉瘤)的分析显示完全闭塞率为53.2%(95%CI 45.0%-61.1%)。
- 夹闭研究中22项评估神经功能结局(2404个动脉瘤),良好结局为97.9%(95%CI 96.8%-98.6%)。
- 栓塞研究中22项评估神经功能结局(826个动脉瘤),良好结局为95.1%(95%CI 93.1%-96.5%)。
- 采用固定效应模型的结果无实质性差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Open microsurgical clipping of unruptured intracranial aneurysms has long been the gold standard, yet advancements in endovascular coiling techniques have begun to challenge the status quo. OBJECTIVE: To compare endovascular coiling with microsurgical clipping among adults with unruptured middle cerebral artery aneurysms (MCAA) by conducting a meta-analysis. METHODS: A systematic search was conducted from January 2011 to October 2015 to update a previous meta-analysis. All studies that reported unruptured MCAA in adults treated by microsurgical clipping or endovascular coiling were included and cumulatively analyzed. RESULTS: Thirty-seven studies including 3352 patients were included. Using the random-effects model, pooled analysis of 11 studies of microsurgical clipping (626 aneurysms) revealed complete aneurysmal obliteration in 94.2% of cases (95% confidence interval [CI] 87.6%-97.4%). The analysis of 18 studies of endovascular coiling (759 aneurysms) revealed complete obliteration in 53.2% of cases (95% CI: 45.0%-61.1%). Among clipping studies, 22 assessed neurological outcomes (2404 aneurysms), with favorable outcomes in 97.9% (95% CI: 96.8%-98.6%). Among coiling studies, 22 examined neurological outcomes (826 aneurysms), with favorable outcomes in 95.1% (95% CI: 93.1%-96.5%). Results using the fixed-effect models were not materially different. CONCLUSION: This updated meta-analysis demonstrates that surgical clipping for unruptured MCAA remains highly safe and efficacious. Endovascular treatment for unruptured MCAAs continues to improve in efficacy and safety; yet, it results in lower rates of occlusion.
引用
- Alreshidi M, Cote DJ, Dasenbrock HH, et al. Coiling Versus Microsurgical Clipping in the Treatment of Unruptured Middle Cerebral Artery Aneurysms: A Meta-Analysis. Neurosurgery. 2018. PMID: 29438551. doi:10.1093/neuros/nyx623
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。