脊柱手术决策与专科及情感卷入的关联——脊柱手术适应证(INDIANA)调查
INDIANA调查以互联网问卷方式向全国脊柱专科神经外科与骨科医生呈现腰椎间盘突出、腰椎管狭窄和腰椎退变性滑脱的典型病例,并将医生随机分配至患者组或近亲属组以制造情感卷入。共122名脊柱外科医生完成问卷(应答率78.7%)。结果显示,在腰椎间盘突出和腰椎管狭窄病例中,骨科医生的保守治疗比例更高(腰椎间盘突出:OR 4.1,95%CI 1.7-9.7,p=0.001;腰椎管狭窄:OR 3.9,95%CI 1.8-8.2,p<0.001);情感卷入(患者组与近亲属组比较)在三种病例中均未影响结果(腰椎间盘突出:p=0.213;腰椎管狭窄:p=0.097;腰椎退变性滑脱:p=0.924)。
要点
- 骨科医生在腰椎间盘突出和腰椎管狭窄病例中更倾向保守治疗(OR 4.1、OR 3.9)。
- 情感卷入(患者组与近亲属组比较)在三种腰椎退变病例中均未影响治疗决策。
- 尽管已有高质量多中心试验证据,常见腰椎退变性疾病的治疗决策仍存在相当大的差异。
核心结论
- 在常见腰椎退变性疾病中,治疗决策存在相当大的差异,尽管已有来自大型多中心试验的高质量数据。
- 情感卷入(患者组与近亲属组比较)未影响治疗建议。
- 较高的应答率(78.7%)表明本研究提出的问题对专注脊柱的医生而言十分重要。
研究设计与样本
- 全国性互联网问卷调查,纳入专攻脊柱手术的神经外科医生和骨科医生,呈现腰椎间盘突出(DH)、腰椎管狭窄(SS)和腰椎退变性滑脱(SL)的典型临床病例。
- 医生被随机分配至患者组(PG)或近亲属组(RG),以制造情感卷入。
- 研究比较神经外科医生与骨科医生、患者组与近亲属组在治疗决策上的差异,共122名脊柱外科医生完成问卷(应答率78.7%)。
主要发现
- 在腰椎间盘突出病例中,骨科医生更倾向保守治疗(OR 4.1,95%CI 1.7-9.7,p=0.001)。
- 在腰椎管狭窄病例中,骨科医生更倾向保守治疗(OR 3.9,95%CI 1.8-8.2,p<0.001)。
- 情感卷入(患者组与近亲属组比较)在腰椎间盘突出(p=0.213)、腰椎管狭窄(p=0.097)和腰椎退变性滑脱(p=0.924)病例中均未影响治疗结果。
关键数值与推荐
- 腰椎间盘突出:骨科医生与神经外科医生相比,更倾向保守治疗的OR 4.1(95%CI 1.7-9.7,p=0.001)。
- 腰椎管狭窄:骨科医生与神经外科医生相比,更倾向保守治疗的OR 3.9(95%CI 1.8-8.2,p<0.001)。
- 情感卷入(患者组与近亲属组比较):腰椎间盘突出p=0.213、腰椎管狭窄p=0.097、腰椎退变性滑脱p=0.924。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,常见腰椎退变性疾病的治疗决策存在相当大的差异,尽管已有高质量多中心试验数据可用。
- 作者认为,情感卷入未影响治疗建议。
- 作者未据此给出具体临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Although recent trials provided level I evidence for the most common degenerative lumbar spinal disorders, treatment still varies widely. Thus, the Indications in Spinal Surgery (INDIANA) survey explores whether decision-making is influenced by specialty or personal emotional involvement of the treating specialist. METHOD: Nationwide, neurosurgeons and orthopedic surgeons specialized in spine surgery were asked to answer an Internet-based questionnaire with typical clinical patient cases of lumbar disc herniation (DH), lumbar spinal stenosis (SS), and lumbar degenerative spondylolisthesis (SL). The surgeons were assigned to counsel a patient or a close relative, thus creating emotional involvement. This was achieved by randomly allocating the surgeons to a patient group (PG) and relative group (RG). We then compared neurosurgeons to orthopedic surgeons and the PG to the RG regarding treatment decision-making. RESULTS: One hundred twenty-two spine surgeons completed the questionnaire (response rate 78.7%). Regarding DH and SS, more conservative treatment among orthopedic surgeons was shown (DH: odds ratio [OR] 4.1, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.7-9.7, p = 0.001; SS: OR 3.9, CI 1.8-8.2, p < 0.001). However, emotional involvement (PG vs. RG) did not affect these results for any of the three cases (DH: p = 0.213; SS: p = 0.097; SL: p = 0.924). CONCLUSIONS: The high response rate indicates how important the issues raised by this study actually are for dedicated spine surgeons. Moreover, there are considerable variations in decision-making for the most common degenerative lumbar spinal disorders, although there is high-quality data from large multicenter trials available. Emotional involvement, though, did not influence treatment recommendations.
引用
- Sollmann N, Morandell C, Albers L, et al. Association of decision-making in spinal surgery with specialty and emotional involvement-the Indications in Spinal Surgery (INDIANA) survey. Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2018. PMID: 29322267. doi:10.1007/s00701-017-3459-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。