内镜经鼻入路不优于显微镜经颅入路治疗前颅底脑膜瘤——一项Meta分析
该Meta分析比较内镜经鼻蝶入路(eTSA)与显微经颅入路(mTCA)切除鞍结节脑膜瘤(TSM)和嗅沟脑膜瘤(OGM)的手术结局。共纳入64项病例系列研究,eTSA在TSM视觉改善上较高,但脑脊液漏发生率更高,且OGM的全切除率低于mTCA。结论认为eTSA并不优于mTCA。
要点
- OGM全切除率eTSA 70.9% vs mTCA 88.5%,差异显著(p交互<0.01)。
- TSM脑脊液漏eTSA 19.3% vs mTCA 5.81%,OGM为25.1% vs 10.5%(p交互均<0.01)。
- TSM术中动脉损伤eTSA 4.89% vs mTCA 1.86%(p交互=0.03)。
核心结论
- 该Meta分析显示,eTSA在OGM和TSM的切除方面均不优于mTCA。
研究设计与样本
- 系统检索2004年以来的文献,按照PRISMA指南进行Meta分析。
- 共纳入64项病例系列研究,比较eTSA与mTCA,计算全切除、视觉改善、脑脊液漏、术中动脉损伤和死亡率的合并发生率,并计算p交互值。
主要发现
- 固定效应模型显示,OGM的全切除率mTCA显著高于eTSA(eTSA 70.9% vs mTCA 88.5%,p交互<0.01);TSM的全切除率mTCA较高但差异未达统计学显著(eTSA 83.0% vs mTCA 85.8%,p交互=0.34)。
- TSM的视觉改善eTSA高于mTCA(p交互<0.01),OGM的视觉改善eTSA与mTCA差异未达统计学显著(p交互=0.33),原文提及存在相当大的异质性。
- 脑脊液漏发生率eTSA显著高于mTCA,OGM为eTSA 25.1% vs mTCA 10.5%(p交互<0.01),TSM为eTSA 19.3% vs mTCA 5.81%(p交互<0.01)。
- TSM的术中动脉损伤eTSA高于mTCA(eTSA 4.89% vs mTCA 1.86%,p交互=0.03);OGM的术中动脉损伤eTSA与mTCA差异未达统计学显著(p交互=0.10)。
- TSM(p交互=0.14)和OGM(p交互=0.88)的死亡率eTSA与mTCA均无显著差异;随机效应模型结果相似。
局限性
- 原文提及视觉改善分析存在相当大的异质性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECT: In the past decade, the endonasal transsphenoidal approach (eTSA) has become an alternative to the microsurgical transcranial approach (mTCA) for tuberculum sellae meningiomas (TSMs) and olfactory groove meningiomas (OGMs). The aim of this meta-analysis was to evaluate which approach offered the best surgical outcomes. METHODS: A systematic review of the literature from 2004 and meta-analysis were conducted in accordance with the PRISMA guidelines. Pooled incidence was calculated for gross total resection (GTR), visual improvement, cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak, intraoperative arterial injury, and mortality, comparing eTSA and mTCA, with p-interaction values. RESULTS: Of 1684 studies, 64 case series were included in the meta-analysis. Using the fixed-effects model, the GTR rate was significantly higher among mTCA patients for OGM (eTSA: 70.9% vs. mTCA: 88.5%, p-interaction < 0.01), but not significantly higher for TSM (eTSA: 83.0% vs. mTCA: 85.8%, p-interaction = 0.34). Despite considerable heterogeneity, visual improvement was higher for eTSA than mTCA for TSM (p-interaction < 0.01), but not for OGM (p-interaction = 0.33). CSF leak was significantly higher among eTSA patients for both OGM (eTSA: 25.1% vs. mTCA: 10.5%, p-interaction < 0.01) and TSM (eTSA: 19.3%, vs. mTCA: 5.81%, p-interaction < 0.01). Intraoperative arterial injury was higher among eTSA (4.89%) than mTCA patients (1.86%) for TSM (p-interaction = 0.03), but not for OGM resection (p-interaction = 0.10). Mortality was not significantly different between eTSA and mTCA patients for both TSM (p-interaction = 0.14) and OGM resection (p-interaction = 0.88). Random-effect models yielded similar results. CONCLUSION: In this meta-analysis, eTSA was not shown to be superior to mTCA for resection of both OGMs and TSMs.
引用
- Muskens IS, Briceno V, Ouwehand TL, et al. The endoscopic endonasal approach is not superior to the microscopic transcranial approach for anterior skull base meningiomas-a meta-analysis. Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2017. PMID: 29127655. doi:10.1007/s00701-017-3390-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。