未破裂与破裂动静脉畸形的结局分析:545例手术治疗病例的多中心连续系列研究
这项意大利10家医院的多中心回顾性研究分析了545例连续手术治疗的动静脉畸形(AVM)。出血后治疗的AVM患者不良结局(改良Rankin量表评分>1)比例超过三分之一(37.69%);而未破裂AVM经预防性手术治疗后良好结局达93.8%,仅考虑Spetzler-Martin 1-3级时升至95.7%且无死亡(P<0.05)。作者结论认为在未破裂低级别AVM中,手术相关神经功能缺损风险随时间低于自发出血风险,交叉点为6.5年。
要点
- 出血后手术治疗的AVM患者不良结局比例为37.69%。
- 未破裂AVM预防性手术后良好结局为93.8%,Spetzler-Martin 1-3级为95.7%且无死亡(P<0.05)。
- 未破裂低级别AVM手术风险与出血风险的交叉点为6.5年。
核心结论
- 在未破裂低风险AVM(Spetzler-Martin 1-3级)中,随时间推移手术相关神经功能缺损风险变得低于自发出血风险,交叉点为6.5年。
- 由于平均出血年龄小于45岁,作者主张可推行预防性手术以保护患者并克服AVM自然史相关风险。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心回顾性研究,分析意大利10家医院连续545例手术治疗的AVM。
主要发现
- 出血后治疗的AVM患者不良结局(改良Rankin量表评分>1)比例超过三分之一(37.69%)。
- 未破裂AVM经预防性手术治疗后良好结局为93.8%,仅考虑Spetzler-Martin 1-3级时升至95.7%且无死亡(P<0.05)。
- 出院时结局在6个月时显著改善(P<0.05),许多初始神经功能缺损消失并呈一过性。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,在未破裂低风险AVM(Spetzler-Martin 1-3级)中可推行预防性手术以保护患者并克服自然史风险。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Recent literature strongly challenged indications to perform preventive surgery in unruptured arteriovenous malformation (AVM) claiming that invasive AVM treatment is associated with a significant risk of complications and thus conservative management may be a preferable alternative in many patients. On the other hand, the recent improvement of surgical instrumentation and treatment strategies (both surgical and interventional) yielded better outcomes than those achieved only a decade ago. Therefore, even among specialists, a wide variety of opinions, concerning the treatment of unruptured AVM, can be found. METHODS: This multicenter retrospective study analyzes a consecutive series of 545 surgically treated AVMs in 10 different hospitals in Italy. RESULTS: Patients with AVMs treated after hemorrhage had an unfavorable (modified Rankin Scale score >1) outcome in more than one third (37.69%) of the cases. Conversely, with proper indications, unruptured AVMs treated preventively have a good outcome in 93.8% of cases, increasing to 95.7%, with no death, if only Spetzler-Martin grades 1-3 are considered (P < 0.05). Outcomes on discharge significantly (P < 0.05) improve at 6 months with the disappearance of many of the initial neurologic deficits that turn out to be transient. CONCLUSIONS: In unruptured low-risk AVMs (Spetzler-Martin grades 1-3), over time, the risk of surgery-associated neurologic deficits becomes lower than that linked to spontaneous hemorrhage, with a crossover point at 6.5 years. Because the average bleeding age is less than 45 years, preventive surgery can be advocated to safeguard the patient and overcome the risks associated with the natural history of AVMs.
引用
- Cenzato M, Tartara F, D'Aliberti G, et al. Unruptured Versus Ruptured AVMs: Outcome Analysis from a Multicentric Consecutive Series of 545 Surgically Treated Cases. World Neurosurg. 2017. PMID: 29155066. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2017.11.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。