儿童分流手术质量指标的比较及负性分流翻修率的提出
该研究回顾性分析2015年单中心60例儿童分流手术,比较已发表的质量指标并提出负性分流翻修率(NSRR)作为新指标,定义为分流探查发现系统功能正常的比例。结果显示手术活动率0.127、翻修商2.333、30天分流故障率0.166、90天总体分流翻修率21.7%、可预防分流翻修率38.5%,NSRR为7.1%。作者认为NSRR可跨研究比较、以患者为导向、易于测量且可能可干预。
要点
- 60例分流手术中18例(39%)为新置管,42例(70%)为翻修。
- 90天内发生13例分流失败,主要为近端失败(6例,46%)。
- NSRR为7.1%,作者提出其作为新的质量指标。
核心结论
- 作者提出负性分流翻修率(NSRR)作为新的质量指标,覆盖既往未涉及的分流手术方面。
- 作者认为该指标可跨研究比较、以患者为导向、易于测量且可能可干预。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析本中心2015年儿童分流手术活动,共分析60例分流手术。
- 从电子病历中提取人口学、临床和影像学变量,计算手术活动率、翻修商、30天分流故障率、90天总体分流翻修率、可预防分流翻修率和NSRR。
主要发现
- 60例手术中18例(39%)为新分流置入,42例(70%)为翻修。
- 中位年龄18个月(范围0.03-204个月),主要病因包括出血后脑积水16例(41%)、先天性11例(28%)和肿瘤相关8例(21%)。
- 索引手术后90天内发生13例分流失败,主要因近端失败6例(46%)。
- 手术活动率为0.127,翻修商为2.333,30天分流故障率为0.166,90天总体分流翻修率为21.7%,可预防分流翻修率为38.5%。
- NSRR为7.1%。
关键数值与推荐
- NSRR定义为分流探查发现系统功能正常的比例,本研究中为7.1%。
- 手术活动率为0.127,翻修商为2.333,30天分流故障率为0.166,90天总体分流翻修率为21.7%,可预防分流翻修率为38.5%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Shunt surgery is common in pediatric neurosurgery and is associated with relevant complication rates. We aimed to compare previously published metrics in a single data set and propose the Negative Shunt Revision Rate (NSRR), defined as proportion of shunt explorations revealing a properly working system, as a new quality metric. METHODS: Retrospective analysis of our shunt surgery activity in 2015 was performed. Demographic, clinical, and radiologic variables were extracted from electronic medical notes. Surgical Activity Rate, Revision Quotient, 30-day shunt malfunction rate, 90-day global shunt revision rate, Preventable Shunt Revision Rate, and novel NSRR were calculated. RESULTS: Of 60 shunt operations analyzed, 18 (39%) were new shunt insertions, and 42 (70%) were revisions. Median age was 18 months (range, 0.03-204 months), and main etiologies were posthemorrhagic (n = 16; 41%), congenital (n = 11; 28%), and tumor-associated (n = 8; 21%) hydrocephalus. Within 90 days after index surgery, 13 shunt failures occurred, predominantly owing to proximal failure (n = 6; 46%). Surgical Activity Rate was 0.127, Revision Quotient was 2.333, 30-day shunt malfunction rate was 0.166, 90-day global shunt revision rate was 21.7%, and Preventable Shunt Revision Rate was 38.5%. NSRR was 7.1%. CONCLUSIONS: Our results correlate with published values and offer measurement of quality that can be compared across studies and considered patient-oriented, easily measurable, and potentially modifiable. We propose NSRR as a new quality metric, covering an aspect of shunt surgery that was not addressed previously.
引用
- Beez T, Steiger HJ. Comparison of Quality Metrics for Pediatric Shunt Surgery and Proposal of the Negative Shunt Revision Rate. World Neurosurg. 2017. PMID: 28987855. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2017.09.193
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。