经皮棘突间撑开器与减压术治疗神经源性跛行患者的比较:特定患者中的替代选择?
多中心国际随机对照试验纳入163例退变性腰椎管狭窄伴神经源性间歇性跛行患者,1:1随机接受经皮棘突间撑开器(IPD)或单纯减压手术(SDS),随访24个月。IPD在12个月主要终点未达非劣效(P=.172),24个月达非劣效(P=.005);IPD再手术率18.2%高于SDS的9.3%。
要点
- IPD与SDS在12个月主要终点未达非劣效,24个月达非劣效。
- IPD再手术率18.2%高于SDS的9.3%。
- IPD手术时间和失血量低于SDS。
核心结论
- IPD与开放减压在缓解高度选择患者的神经源性间歇性跛行症状方面取得相似结果,但IPD再手术率更高。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心、国际、随机对照试验,19个中心纳入163例患者,1:1随机分至IPD组或SDS组,随访24个月。
主要发现
- 12个月时IPD组与SDS组苏黎世跛行问卷躯体功能较基线平均百分比变化分别为-32.3±32.1和-37.5±22.8,24个月分别为-37.9±21.7%和-35.2±22.8,均P<.001。
- IPD在12个月未达非劣效(非劣效界值10%,P=.172),在24个月达非劣效(P=.005)。
- IPD组平均手术时间和失血量分别为24±11分钟和6±11毫升,低于SDS组的70±39分钟和189±148毫升,均P<.001。
- IPD组索引节段再手术率为18.2%,SDS组为9.3%。
- 两组症状严重程度、患者满意度、视觉模拟量表腿痛和SF-36随时间均有改善。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Standalone interspinous process devices (IPDs) to treat degenerative lumbar spinal stenosis with neurogenic intermittent claudication (NIC) have shown ambiguous results in the literature. OBJECTIVE: To show that a minimally invasive percutaneous IPD is safe and noninferior to standalone decompressive surgery (SDS) for patients with degenerative lumbar spinal stenosis with NIC. METHODS: A multicenter, international, randomized, controlled trial (RCT) was con- ducted. One hundred sixty-three patients, enrolled at 19 sites, were randomized 1:1 to treatment with IPD or SDS and were followed for 24 mo. RESULTS: There was significant improvement in Zurich Claudication Questionnaire physical function, as mean percentage change from baseline, for both the IPD and the SDS groups at 12 mo (primary endpoint) and 24 mo (-32.3 ± 32.1, -37.5 ± 22.8; and -37.9 ± 21.7%, -35.2 ± 22.8, both P < .001). IPD treatment was not significantly noninferior (margin: 10%) to SDS treatment at 12 mo (P = .172) but was significantly noninferior at 24 mo (P = .005). Symptom severity, patient satisfaction, visual analog scale leg pain, and SF-36 improved in both groups over time. IPD showed lower mean surgical time and mean blood loss (24 ± 11 min and 6 ± 11 mL) compared to SDS (70 ± 39 min and 189 ± 148 mL, both P < .001). Reoperations at index level occurred in 18.2% of the patients in the IPD group and in 9.3% in the SDS group. CONCLUSION: Confirming 3 recent RCTs, we could show that IPD as well as open decompression achieve similar results in relieving symptoms of NIC in highly selected patients. However, despite some advantages in secondary outcomes, a higher reoperation rate for IPD is confirmed.
引用
- Meyer B, Baranto A, Schils F, et al. Percutaneous Interspinous Spacer vs Decompression in Patients with Neurogenic Claudication: An Alternative in Selected Patients? Neurosurgery. 2018. PMID: 28973638. doi:10.1093/neuros/nyx326
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。